Best American Restaurants in Short Hills

Price: Moderate (80)Price: Expensive (61)Price: Very Expensive (7)

56 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills restaurant

1. Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills

4.1

Excellent(2594)

Price: Expensive

• American • Short Hills

Booked 14 times today

Legal Sea Foods in Short Hills is renowned for its excellent seafood cuisine. With a long history in the Boston area, this restaurant receives acclaim for consistently delivering fresh and delicious seafood. Whether dining after a day at the mall or stopping by while in the area, patrons appreciate the balance between classic and innovative dishes. Happy customers note the restaurant's exceptional service, generous portions, quality of ingredients, and pleasant atmosphere. However, the restaurant also welcomes constructive feedback, and some customers have expressed the desire for beloved dishes to return to the menu. Whether it's an anniversary lunch, a special occasion, or just a regular meal, Legal Sea Foods never disappoints, cementing its reputation as a go-to seafood destination.

A photo of NM Cafe by Neiman Marcus - Short Hills restaurant

2. NM Cafe by Neiman Marcus - Short Hills

4.6

Exceptional(93)

Price: Moderate

• American • Short Hills

NM Cafe by Neiman Marcus - Short Hills is a delightful haven at the Short Hills Mall, known for its Contemporary American cuisine. Customers rave about their wide variety of salads, sandwiches, and non-alcoholic beverages that combine traditional food with modern flair. The relaxed and comfortable ambiance of the café is routinely praised, with one customer describing it as a 'festive location for a luncheon.' Not only is the food delicious, but the calorie count displayed on the menu is an added bonus for health-conscious individuals. The place's impeccable service is often noted, with multiple favorable mentions of their friendly staff, especially servers like Kiki. The café's tempting menu, combined with its welcoming atmosphere, makes it a must-visit destination at the Short Hills Mall.

A photo of Fin Raw Bar - Summit restaurant

3. Fin Raw Bar - Summit

4.7

Exceptional(768)

Price: Expensive

• American • Summit

Booked 15 times today

Fin Raw Bar - Summit is a much-praised seafood restaurant with rave reviews from its patrons. Diners commend it for consistently delivering "fresh, innovative, and enjoyable" seafood dishes. They note that it "always delivers a delicious meal and a pleasant dining experience." Patrons are particularly fond of the restaurant's BYOB status and the attentive service provided by the friendly and efficient staff. The restaurant’s food selection, including items like the salmon, lobster sliders, and oysters, are appreciated for their freshness and perfect preparation. With regulars stating it's the "best seafood restaurant in the area", Fin Raw Bar continues to demonstrate its relevance in the seafood cuisine landscape.

4. Nero's Grille

4.7

Exceptional(668)

Price: Moderate

• American • Livingston

Booked 33 times today

Nero's Grille is a superior Steakhouse, well-established and highly praised by numerous diners. The restaurant is renowned for its excellent blend of Steakhouse and Italian cuisine. Patrons laud the restaurant's delicious food, friendly and attentive service, and reasonable prices. Reviews are replete with phrases like "the best steak I've ever had" and "dry aged an outer edge as char-grilled as preferred red and inside as tender juicy perfect." The restaurant beautifully merges seafood, steakhouse and Italian classics, with the steak, in particular, being consistently commended for its perfect seasoning and cooking. Nero's Grille doesn't just serve food; it provides a consistent quality dining experience that keeps customers returning.

5. Par 440

3.9

Excellent(307)

Price: Expensive

• American • Short Hills

Par 440 is a celebrated American cuisine restaurant known for its impressively diverse menu and vibrant atmosphere. From pizzas to pastas, burgers to entrees, the menu boasts a wide array of scrumptious dishes. It also features much-appreciated American classics like BBQ ribs and prime rib, while offering a diverse selection of seafood. According to reviews, diners have highly appreciated the food, service, and ambiance at Par 440, with special mention of the "top notch food" and "excellent service." The restaurant is also praised for its live music, fostering a lively atmosphere that guests find enjoyable. The good pricing and comfortable environment further enhance Par 440's reputation as a prime location for great American cuisine.

A photo of McLoone's Boathouse restaurant

6. McLoone's Boathouse

3.9

Excellent(3719)

Price: Moderate

• American • West Orange

Booked 19 times today

McLoone's Boathouse stands as a beacon of great American cuisine, featuring a beautiful lakeside setting perfect for brunches, dates, and celebrations. The restaurant is praised for its exceptional service, with reviewers mentioning professional and pleasant servers who offer great drink recommendations and go above and beyond to enhance the experience. The consistency in the delightful experience received high remarks from the guests. Diners have raved about the delicious pulled pork sandwich, crab cakes, Steak Frites, and more. Their outdoor patio invites customers to enjoy their food while luxuriating in a serene reservoir view, often described as romantic and calming. The ambiance, combined with the great food and dedicated service, makes McLoone's Boathouse a must-visit American restaurant.

A photo of Carriage House Restaurant restaurant

7. Carriage House Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(1757)

Price: Expensive

• American • Millburn

Booked 19 times today

Carriage House Restaurant is a haven of Contemporary American cuisine, offering an exquisite dining experience with dynamic entertainment. As praised in numerous reviews, this establishment not only provides well-chosen, innovate menu items including superb lamb shank, seafood paella, and rich, dark chocolate sorbet, but also takes serious precautions regarding customer safety amid COVID-19. Customers feel comfortable and at ease with the restaurant's arrangements, including temperature checks and well-spaced tables. The Carriage House's dedication to quality is evident in its satisfied customers who return regularly for stand-out brunch and dinner experiences, as well as for its unique Brookside Cabaret series. Its offerings are a testament to the creativity and appeal of contemporary American cooking.

8. The Dining Room

3.8

Excellent(147)

Price: Expensive

• American • Short Hills

The Dining Room is highly praised for its authentic and innovative approach to American cuisine. Reviewers frequently laud the restaurant's excellent food and service, with one stating, "Very good cheeseburger and beautiful atmosphere." Another review emphasized, "One of the best cheeseburgers in town," indicating the restaurant's dedication to a classic Americana dish. The Dining Room also caters to diverse diets, offering options that even a vegan found "just wonderful". Patrons have recommended it for different occasions such as business meetings, family brunches and for "peaceful delicious dinner". Reviews consistently highlight the "Greatest burger in town, with fast courteous service," reinforcing The Dining Room's stance as a superior establishment for American cuisine.

A photo of MADISON WINE & TAP restaurant

9. MADISON WINE & TAP

4.4

Awesome(142)

Price: Expensive

• American • Madison

Booked 1 time today

Madison Wine & Tap Room garners high praise from patrons for its exceptional Wine Bar cuisine. The restaurant's exceptional offerings include a robust selection of wines and beers, and an array of delicious food, acknowledged for its freshness and uniqueness. The highly accommodating staff, praised for their knowledge, professionalism, and warmth, evidently play a significant role in the restaurant's reputation. Interestingly, the venue is also fully accessible, offering low tables to accommodate wheelchair users. This combined with their excellent service creates a comfortable dining experience for all. However, its popularity suggests reservations may be required at weekends. Also noteworthy is the ambience which is frequently described as great, trendy, and fitting for a variety of occasions, from business dinners to date nights.

A photo of MoonShine - Modern Supper Club restaurant

10. MoonShine - Modern Supper Club

new

4.2

Awesome(1336)

Price: Expensive

• American • Millburn

MoonShine - Modern Supper Club is beloved as a high-quality establishment serving inventive New American cuisine. The restaurant's ethos is embedded in providing customers with great value for their money through generous portions and inventive fare, which patrons laud for its creativity and exquisite taste. Its brunch offerings receive special praise for their variety and quantity, with cocktails being a highlighted feature. The celebrations at MoonShine are noted to have a festive and energetic vibe, contributing to its identity as a lively culinary hub. The reviews reflect a consistently positive dining experience, crediting delightful cuisine, a swanky atmosphere, and an attentive serving staff that collectively encourage return visits. Exceptional reviews also recommend their creamy shrimp with tempura and cauliflower soup, filet mignon au poivre with rocquefort mashed potatoes, Asian inspired black sea bass, and the rum raisin bread pudding for dessert. MoonShine - Modern Supper Club is indeed a treasure trove of tantalizing American flavors in a modern and comfortable setting.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Short Hills

Discover the vibrant American dining scene in Short Hills, Essex, New Jersey, where culinary diversity meets local charm. This area showcases a delightful selection of eateries that specialize in American cuisine, each providing a unique twist on traditional and modern dishes. From gourmet burgers and classic barbecues to innovative American fusion, the restaurants in Short Hills cater to a variety of tastes and preferences. These dining spots not only pride themselves on their culinary offerings but also emphasize a warm, inviting atmosphere that's perfect for family dinners, casual meetups, or special occasions. The dining scene in Short Hills is characterized by its commitment to quality and service, ensuring a memorable experience for every visitor. Whether you're a local or a tourist, exploring these restaurants offers a genuine taste of American hospitality and culinary excellence. Each establishment strives to create dishes that are both enticing and satisfying, making Short Hills a must-visit destination for food lovers.

Explore OpenTable

Short Hills

American