Best American Restaurants in Middle Island

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

Suffolk

Neighborhoods

BellportLake GroveNesconsetPatchoguePort JeffersonRocky Point

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

20 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Karvers Grille

4.6

Exceptional(1841)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 18 times today

Karvers Grille in Patchogue, Holbrook, is a shining example of top-tier Gastro Pub cuisine, celebrated for its dedication to quality and authenticity. This beloved local haunt prides itself on using the freshest ingredients sourced from nearby farms, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor. Patrons rave about the generous portions, with one diner noting that "the food was fresh and tasted great!" The warm, welcoming atmosphere is complemented by friendly staff, making every visit a delightful experience. With consistently "great food and service," Karvers Grille remains a favorite neighborhood gem, enticing both regulars and newcomers to savor its culinary offerings.

2. Spiro's

4.7

Exceptional(1708)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• American • Rocky Point

Booked 14 times today

Spiro's, nestled in the heart of Rocky Point, is a beacon of authentic American cuisine, celebrated for its exceptional dining experience. With over seven years of acclaim as Long Island's best happy hour, Spiro's offers a tantalizing menu featuring dry-aged steaks, seafood delights, and mouthwatering appetizers, all crafted from the finest ingredients. Diners rave about the "superb food" and "top-notch service," with one review highlighting how "the food and service are fantastic as always!" The vibrant yet cozy atmosphere, paired with an extensive cocktail list of over 100 options, makes Spiro's the perfect spot for any occasion. Come and taste why this gem is the talk of the town!

A photo of Shands General & The State Room restaurant

3. Shands General & The State Room

4.7

Exceptional(221)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• American • Patchogue

Booked 13 times today

Shands General in Patchogue is a culinary gem that masterfully captures the essence of authentic Continental cuisine. Chef Francis Derby, Michelin-trained, showcases an innovative menu rooted in seasonality and sustainability, leaving patrons raving about the "incredibly freshest quality food experience on Long Island." From exquisite raw bar selections to house-made pastas and expertly dry-aged steaks, each dish is a celebration of flavor and meticulous craftsmanship. The ambiance exudes a sophisticated charm reminiscent of NYC, making it "a must-go for dining." With an eclectic beverage menu and a staff renowned for impeccable service, Shands General promises an unforgettable dining journey.

4. Chachama Grill

4.9

Exceptional(1981)

$$$$Price: Very Expensive

• American • Patchogue

Booked 7 times today

Chachama Grill is a New American restaurant located in East Patchogue."friendly warm atmosphere & amazing service. Our menu is diverse focusing on freshness and simplicity .Featuring an extensive selection of wines by the glass & bottles & our superb cocktails .

5. Ristegios

4.1

Excellent(1082)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 5 times today

Ristegios in Patchogue is renowned for its exceptional steak cuisine, offering a dining experience that is both authentic and indulgent. The steaks are masterfully prepared, "cooked exactly to order and arriving hot and tasty," ensuring each bite is a flavorful delight. Diners frequently rave about the "amazing skirt steak special" and the "excellent Tomahawk steak," which are highlights of their menu. The restaurant's commitment to quality and attention to detail make it a standout destination for steak lovers. With a vibrant atmosphere and attentive service, Ristegios promises an unforgettable culinary journey that will have you coming back for more.

A photo of Porters on the Lane restaurant

6. Porters on the Lane

4.6

Exceptional(1011)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• American • Bellport

Booked 11 times today

Porters on the Lane in Bellport Village offers an exceptional seafood dining experience that truly stands out. Known for its "fantastic lobster rolls" and "unreal lobster mac n cheese," this restaurant serves dishes that are bursting with fresh, authentic flavors. Diners consistently rave about the high quality of seafood, with one review highlighting the "delicious baked clams" and another praising the "creamy, sweet lobster" in their dishes. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make every visit memorable. Whether you're a local or visiting the charming town, Porters on the Lane promises a seafood feast you won't soon forget.

A photo of Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue restaurant

7. Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue

4.7

Exceptional(380)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 8 times today

Ruta Oaxaca - Patchogue offers a delightful journey into the heart of Contemporary Mexican cuisine, where authenticity and quality take center stage. This vibrant spot is known for its exceptional service and an atmosphere that's both lively and inviting. Diners rave about the "amazing and delish" food, with standout dishes like the Pechuga & Mole Verde praised as "outstanding." The restaurant's dedication to honoring Oaxacan culinary traditions shines through in its exquisite moles, which are more than just sauces—they're the soul of the meal. A visit to Ruta Oaxaca promises an unforgettable dining experience, making it a must-visit for Mexican food enthusiasts.

A photo of Sea Basin Restaurant restaurant

8. Sea Basin Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(781)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• American • Rocky Point

Booked 6 times today

Sea Basin Restaurant, nestled in the lively neighborhood of Rocky Point, offers a delightful journey into American cuisine with a distinctive flair. Celebrated for its "excellent food and service," this family-owned gem has been a local favorite since 1979. The recent renovation has infused a modern charm into the space, making it perfect for any occasion. Diners rave about the "generous portions and superb flavors," ensuring every meal is a memorable one. Signature events like Whiskey Wednesday and Sunday Wine Day add to the vibrant atmosphere. With its warm hospitality and enticing specials, Sea Basin is indeed a beloved destination for American culinary delights.

9. WhiskeyNeat

4.6

Exceptional(86)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• American • Patchogue

Booked 10 times today

We’re a food-focused restaurant drawing inspiration from across the culinary landscape—from fine dining and steakhouses, to food trucks, and even grandma’s kitchen—to deliver an innovative menu in a fun and relaxed environment. And we have some whiskey too...

10. Fifth Season

4.8

Exceptional(3214)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• American • Port Jefferson

Booked 24 times today

Fifth Season in Port Jefferson is a beacon of authentic American cuisine, celebrated for its commitment to fresh, seasonal ingredients. Drawing inspiration from local farms and waters, the restaurant crafts a dynamic menu that evolves with each season, ensuring a unique dining experience with every visit. Guests rave about the "consistently delicious" dishes and the "outstanding food and service" that never fail to impress. The carefully curated American micro-brews and wines perfectly complement the chef's creations, while the house-infused artisan cocktails offer a delightful touch. With stunning views of the Long Island Sound, Fifth Season is the epitome of American culinary excellence.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

G
Greg
New York City •2 reviews
4.0
Dined 1 day ago
We are frequent guests & enjoy the food. The noise level is usually the only complaint when your trying to talk to the people in your own party
More info
Karvers GrillePrice: Moderate• American• Patchogue
•
4.6
L
Liz
1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Service, ambiance and experience were great! We ordered the Steak Tartaré appetizer which was delicious and presentation was cool. Then we ordered rib eye for 2 which came with poutine. Our only complaint was the poutine did not rise to the quality and taste level of the rib eye. Steak was cooked perfectly and tasted great. The poutine was glorified shoestring potatoes with cheese and gravy. I would suggest a more upscale type of side - this was disappointing for the $185 price of the entree.
More info
Shands General & The State RoomPrice: Expensive• American• Patchogue
•
4.7
D
DerekVIP
New York City •17 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
As always a great culinary experience! Great everything!
More info
Fifth SeasonPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Port Jefferson
•
4.8
J
John
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 6, 2025
The service was exceptional and the food was delicious!
More info
Spiro'sPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Rocky Point
•
4.7
M
MelissaVIP
New York City •17 reviews
5.0
Dined on Mar 29, 2025
Victoria, our server was amazing attentive and was very caring. She made sure our experience was enjoyable. The octopus appetizer never dissppoints.
More info
RistegiosPrice: Moderate• American• Patchogue
•
4.1

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Cuisine Nearby
American Cuisine

Middle Island

American

Rye
East Quogue
Nyack
Greenlawn
Speonk
Chappaqua
Nesconset
Greenvale
Garden City
Melville
St. James
Woodbury
Bay Shore
Bellport
New Hyde Park
Huntington
Port Jefferson
Hauppauge
Sayville
Plainview