Best American Restaurants in Matawan

Price: Moderate (33)Price: Expensive (26)Price: Very Expensive (5)

19 restaurants available nearby

A photo of The Goat by David Burke restaurant

1. The Goat by David Burke

4.3

Awesome(891)

Price: Moderate

• American • Union Beach

Booked 2 times today

The Goat by David Burke is recognized for its excellent American cuisine, as numerous customer reviews attest. Diners commend not only the superb service but also the variety and quality of food on offer. Stand-out dishes include the beet salad, the new pork chop and dumpling entree, the salmon, and the unique eggplant chips appetizer. The prime rib may be an exception, but overall, the food has been described as "delicious", "outstanding", "perfectly cooked" and "topnotch". The atmosphere is praised as well, with special mention of the goat-themed decor. Furthermore, the restaurant seems to continuously update their menu, keeping the offerings fresh and exciting.

2. McDonagh's Pub

4.0

Excellent(195)

Price: Moderate

• American • Keyport

McDonagh's Pub is a revered American restaurant that offers a rewarding dining experience, as reflected by customers' reviews. Revelers laud the friendly service, large portions, and excellent food quality, with the corned beef Rueben sandwich receiving special praise. The fun atmosphere, featuring live music and diverse activities like trivia night and bingo games, adds to the overall appeal of McDonagh's Pub. Its offerings also include a well-priced weekday lunch menu and a unique create-your-own waffle station. Guests also appreciate the establishment's dog-friendly policies and regard it as a perfect spot for social gatherings and celebrations. The combination of all these elements makes McDonagh's Pub an embodiment of good American cuisine.

A photo of Houlihan's - Holmdel restaurant

3. Houlihan's - Holmdel

4.7

Exceptional(582)

Price: Moderate

• American • Holmdel

Booked 2 times today

Houlihan's in Holmdel is quickly becoming a local favorite for its consistent delivery of outstanding American cuisine. Patrons have praised it for its excellent food, refreshing drinks, and exceptional service. Visitors note that the quality of the food is far from typical "chain" quality, but rather presents a great culinary experience that never disappoints. Regulars highlight the restaurant's fantastic beef offerings, like the prime ribs and fillet mignon, as well as their varied menu options. The pleasant atmosphere, exceptional value for money, and attentive servers like Vanessa and David L., who always ensure a memorable dining experience, make it a top choice for those seeking good American cuisine. Despite occasional remarks about overcooked steak, feedback suggests that the restaurant remains a delightful surprise and a solid choice for regular visits.

A photo of Semolina Restaurant restaurant

4. Semolina Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(3086)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 32 times today

Semolina Restaurant, located in the heart of Red Bank, is a gem that consistently serves impressive farm-to-table cuisine. The menu, which changes often based on season and available fresh ingredients, showcases an array of dishes made from locally sourced produce. Known for its exceptional service as noted by many reviews, the staff is not only attentive but also knowledgeable, expertly guiding patrons through their food journey. It's particularly praised for its homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and innovative flavor combinations. Customers have deemed Semolina the "best execution of farm-to-table menu in Red Bank", and have fondly lauded the "creative dishes" and the "fresh delicious food". The restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality is further emphasized by their practice of indicating the source farms of their ingredients. Semolina Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone seeking to enjoy a remarkable farm-to-table dining experience.

5. Cuzin's Clam Bar

4.7

Exceptional(162)

Price: Expensive

• American • Marlboro

Booked 56 times today

You know what you’re missing around here?A really great seafood place — and a cool place to kick back and enjoy the good life with family and friends.Enter: Cuzin’s Seafood – Clam Bar.Cuzin's Seafood Clam BarOur casual-chic seafood eatery serves up a fresh take on all your favorite fare.Savor the flavor of summer all year round, complete with top service and gorgeous décor that’s part Miami sizzle, part NYC style and all Jersey Shore chill.Whether you’re dining inside or eating al fresco on our outdoor patio, like our name promises, when you’re at Cuzin’s, you’re family.

A photo of The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn restaurant

6. The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn

4.5

Awesome(1207)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 6 times today

The Dining Room at Molly Pitcher Inn is one of the most acclaimed eateries serving Contemporary American cuisine. First-time diners and loyal customers alike rave about the exceptional food, pairing rustic hearty meals with creative culinary spins. Consistently praised for its ambiance, this place offers outdoor patio seating with an impressive view of the pool area and a panoramic view of the Navesink River, making it a preferred destination for special occasions. Despite its five-star status, the restaurant maintains a warm, welcoming atmosphere and prioritizes safety measures, including temperature checks. Customer reviews highlight the fantastic service, creative cocktails, and remarkable dining experiences as reasons to keep returning. The outstanding meals such as their famous Atlantic Chowder filled with lobster and the lump crab and avocado eggs benedict are recommended by many. The Dining Room at Molly Pitcher Inn is indeed a go-to place for a delightful and memorable dining experience.

A photo of The Robinson Ale House - Red Bank restaurant

7. The Robinson Ale House - Red Bank

4.6

Exceptional(1460)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 14 times today

Located in Red Bank, The Robinson Ale House is an undeniably exceptional choice for American cuisine, as voiced by many satisfied patrons. It has won the hearts of its guests through its variety of delicious food, superior service, and a calm ambiance. As one customer puts it, it's a "perfect for a date night" with a "great variety of salads" and "delicious meatloaf". Furthermore, they accommodate dietary needs such as vegetarian and gluten-free options, making it inclusive for everyone. Beyond the food and service, guests appreciated the establishment's comfortable atmosphere with sound reducing acrylic dividers, making it "a great place to meet with friends". Definitely a must-visit for food lovers.

A photo of Rosalita's - Marlboro restaurant

8. Rosalita's - Marlboro

4.6

Exceptional(269)

Price: Moderate

• American • Marlboro

Booked 1 time today

Rosalita's in Marlboro has won over the hearts of many with its authentic Mexican cuisine. Numerous reviews describe the restaurant as a fun and festive place that serves delicious, excellent quality Mexican food at an affordable price. Patrons often rave about the warm, crisp chips and just-right spicy salsa, the excellent choice of margaritas and beer, and the wide array of other menu offerings. Customers also appreciated the courteous, efficient, and accommodating service. "Always a fun place to have dinner. Food is always excellent," said one review. Another mentioned, "The steak was delicious and tons of flavor. The pain killer drink is strong but VERY good."

A photo of Olde Silver Tavern restaurant

9. Olde Silver Tavern

4.4

Awesome(159)

Price: Moderate

• American • Manalapan

Booked 6 times today

Olde Silver Tavern is a symbol of excellence in American cuisine. The restaurant consistently delivers not only high-quality and diverse menu, but also exceptional service. Patrons laud the food as "spectacular", "generous" in portions, and "fresh". The menu stands out as being unique and not the "same old boring menu". One customer emphasized how the food was "amazing" with a mention of the pizza with peach and hot honey, as well as the salmon with sweet potato and white asparagus. The professional and friendly service has been commended by many, one of whom said, "James and Sandra were the most gracious hosts!". With a beautiful decor described as "rustic yet modern", the Olde Silver Tavern delivers an overall 10/10 experience as per one satisfied customer. The combination of exceptional food, service, and ambience has turned visitors into regular customers.

A photo of Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel restaurant

10. Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel

4.6

Exceptional(522)

Price: Moderate

• American • Red Bank

Booked 4 times today

The Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel is renowned for offering an impeccable dining experience with its superior Contemporary American cuisine. Reviewers rave about the diverse food options, from deliciously filled burgers and perfectly prepared swordfish to the unforgettable lobster roll packed with a generous amount of lobster. Indeed, the excellence in preparation and presentation of dishes has been consistently praised, with comments like "Food was excellent from presentation to flavors and temperature." The ambiance of the restaurant, with views over a beautiful water landscape, enhances the overall dining experience. Besides, the commendable service is frequently highlighted, with statements such as, "Peter is a wonderfully attentive server, friendly, efficient and not missing a beat." Further, the restaurant's effort in providing an inclusive menu is appreciated, despite some guests wishing for more vegetarian options. A dedication to quality and an unforgettable dining experience makes Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel a must-visit for fans of Contemporary American cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Matawan

American