Best American Restaurants in Mahopac

Price: Moderate (8)Price: Expensive (7)Price: Very Expensive (3)

9 restaurants available nearby

1. Stone House Grill

4.6

Exceptional(68)

Price: Expensive

• American • Mahopac

Booked 9 times today

The Stone House Grill, praised for its exceptional European cuisine, features exquisite and straightforward food meticulously prepared, as stated in one of the many positive reviews. Enthusiastic diners highlight the great food, excellent service, and pleasant staff, insisting that the restaurant is ‘highly recommended’. Diners are welcomed with warm and attentive service, and moments of celebration are generously rewarded with complimentary treats, such as home-made limoncello and desserts. For their impressive care and quality in food and service, the Stone House Grill has garnered a strong reputation, making it a definite must-try destination for lovers of European cuisine.

2. Tee Bar & Grille

4.4

Awesome(63)

Price: Moderate

• American • Jefferson Valley

Booked 4 times today

Welcome to the Tee Bar & Grille a modern American bistro nestled within the serene greens of our beautiful golf course. We pride ourselves on creating an exceptional dining experience where delicious food meets the ambiance of the sport. Our passion for culinary craftsmanship is evident in every dish we serve, as we strive to offer a contemporary twist on classic American favorites. Whether you're a golf enthusiast, a local foodie, or simply seeking a memorable meal in a picturesque setting, our bistro is the perfect destination. We are open all year long and you don't need to be a golfer to dine here! We have a great happy hour Monday - Friday 3pm- 6pm as well as live bands and DJ's throughout the year!!

3. Tilly's Table

4.5

Awesome(914)

Price: Expensive

• American • Brewster

Booked 17 times today

Tilly's Table is renowned for its exceptional American cuisine, offering a unique blend of tradition and innovation. The reviews reveal that it is highly praised for its phenomenal food, especially noted for its deliciousness, freshness, and generous portion sizes - making it an embodiment of the heartiness often associated with American cuisine. Reviewers also applaud the excellent service and unique atmosphere that blend with the ambiance of a modern rustic setting, preserving the charm of the original barn. The welcoming staff add to the small community feel, enhancing the overall experience. The frequent praise and high recommendations suggest a consistent quality that marks Tilly's Table as a premier destination for great American food.

4. Farmhouse Tavern

4.4

Awesome(170)

Price: Moderate

• American • Bedford

Booked 13 times today

Farmhouse Tavern has established itself as an iconic institution in the realm of American cuisine. Patrons consistently praise its delicious food, with reviews highlighting dishes such as the Branzino picatta and chicken parm. The restaurant has been highly recommended for its lovely decor, great martini, and fun ambiance, balancing both casual and beautiful elements. Reviewers also applaud the restaurant's excellent service, noting friendly, attentive staff and fast responses to any food order issues. The general consensus assures you of a wonderful dining experience at Farmhouse Tavern, with several patrons eager to return. It's definitely a hallmark of American gastronomy.

5. The Gramercy

4.6

Exceptional(457)

Price: Moderate

• American • Yorktown Heights

Booked 15 times today

Nestled in Yorktown Heights, The Gramercy offers a delightful dining experience, frequently described as a hidden gem. This American cuisine restaurant, characterized by enthusiastic reviews, boasts savory fare such as hushpuppy crab cake, paella, and bourbon pecan cobbler. Patrons highlight the excellent service, epitomized by servers like Bucky, who create a warm, inviting atmosphere. The restaurant's ambiance is frequently compared to a chic Manhattan eatery, complete with tastefully decorated emerald green sofas and wood tables with brass bases. Furthermore, the menu gets high praise with dishes like mushroom ravioli and a rib eye steak cooked to perfection, creating an unforgettable culinary experience.

6. Peter Pratt's Inn

4.4

Awesome(180)

Price: Expensive

• American • Yorktown Heights

Booked 9 times today

Peter Pratt's Inn boasts a rich tradition of preparing the quintessential American cuisine with an adventurous twist. Guests praise the wide variety of dishes which range from Venison to Rabbit stew, and Cioppino to Lamb chops. Dishes are not only delightfully flavorful but are also a visual treat, for instance, the Venison Tostones has garnered rave reviews for its tender meat and amazing flavors. Complementing this, the restaurant is known for its superb service, offering a warm, welcoming, and friendly atmosphere. As reflected in the reviews, it consistently provides a unique dining experience that makes every occasion special. Whether it's the cozy, old farmhouse ambience, outstanding service, or palate pleasing food, Peter Pratt's Inn ticks all the boxes for an outstanding American dining experience.

7. Nadine's

4.6

Exceptional(399)

Price: Expensive

• American • Yorktown Heights

Booked 10 times today

We serve a delicious selection of German, Austrian, American and French specialties designed to please and delight.

A photo of 121 Restaurant & Bar - North Salem restaurant

8. 121 Restaurant & Bar - North Salem

4.2

Awesome(565)

Price: Expensive

• American • North Salem

121 Restaurant & Bar in North Salem stands out for its exceptional American cuisine, eloquently confirmed by numerous reviews. Serving a variety of delicious dishes such as burgers, octopus, calamari pizza and tuna wings, the restaurant is praised for its excellent food and service. Its "cozy", "rustic" setting and a wide selection of "awesome cocktails" further add to the dining experience. Diners also appreciate the attentive staff, with mentions of waiters going above and beyond to enhance their visit. Coupling these attributes with its vibrant, lively atmosphere, 121 Restaurant & Bar consistently delivers a top-tier dining experience, ensuring it is a fan-favorite for many locals.

9. Clock Tower Grill

4.6

Exceptional(989)

Price: Moderate

• American • Brewster

Booked 4 times today

Clock Tower Grill is a highly recommended destination for anyone seeking authentic American cuisine with a creative twist. This upscale, farm-to-market restaurant stands out due to its unique ambience and top-notch ingredients sourced from their own farm. Known for a menu that includes American staples and inventive new creations, patrons rave about the "amazingly delicious" and "deliciously inventive" food. Dishes like the lobster grill cheese sandwich, beef brisket sandwich, and the vanilla bean honey pudding have been highlighted by customers for their outstanding taste. The restaurant also offers a variety of fresh, regional American brews. Despite the upscale nature, Clock Tower Grill maintains a cozy, country farm atmosphere. Recent reviews commend it not just for its food, but also for its efficient and friendly service.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Mahopac

American