Best American Restaurants in Cape Elizabeth

Price: Moderate (14)Price: Expensive (13)Price: Very Expensive (3)

16 restaurants available nearby

1. Shade

4.5

Awesome(344)

Price: Expensive

• American • Scarborough

Booked 8 times today

Shade is a phenomenal seafood restaurant that has built an exceptional reputation for its fantastic dishes and impeccable service. Its menu might be limited, but the seafood dishes from ciappino to blackened halibut are nothing less than extraordinary. The lobster scampi, as well as the haddock in brown butter, have been highlighted by patrons as being simply superb. The service is also noted for its friendliness and efficiency, making it an excellent dining spot. Situated at Higgins Beach, its cozy and warm atmosphere adds to the overall wonderful dining experience. Its high-praised seafood, coupled with the convenience of being located at an exceptional location, make Shade a must-visit for seafood lovers.

2. David's 388

4.8

Exceptional(1292)

Price: Expensive

• American • South Portland

Booked 25 times today

David's 388 is a standout bistro renowned for its exceptional cuisine. Patrons laud it as a 'reliable local bistro with excellent food and wine choices,' cementing its place as a favorite neighborhood hotspot. Offering a menu teeming with a plethora of palatable dishes - from scrumptious starters such as arancini and Brussels sprouts to delicious entrees like lamb, salmon, and haddock - every meal is a culinary triumph. One reviewer likened their dining experience at David's 388 to 'my favorite little neighborhood bistro in Paris.' This glowing review underscores the fact that the restaurant skillfully elevates bistro fare to a gastronomic art, delivering '5 star quality at extremely reasonable bistro prices.'

A photo of David's Restaurant restaurant

3. David's Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(3710)

Price: Moderate

• American • Portland

Booked 19 times today

David's Restaurant is a highly recommended destination for Contemporary American cuisine. The menu offers an eclectic mix, from pizzas and salads to gourmet entrees such as porcini mushroom dusted haddock and pepper crusted sushi rare tuna. This broad selection ensures that there is something for every palate. Reviewers frequently commend their exceptional food and service, describing dishes as 'delicious', 'unique' and 'the best meal they've ever had'. The atmosphere is praised for its background music and contemporary vibe, making it a great location for a date or a gathering of family and friends. The restaurant's cocktails are also popular among visitors, signaling a good range of quality drinks.

A photo of The Chart Room at Black Point Inn restaurant

4. The Chart Room at Black Point Inn

4.4

Awesome(402)

Price: Expensive

• American • Scarborough

Booked 10 times today

The Chart Room at Black Point Inn is celebrated for its exceptional American cuisine. Touted for its excellent service, reviewers commend the attentive and friendly staff, with special mentions to Tess, Rachel, and Reese. The food is consistently praised, from the "fun surprises" on the menu to the "delicious" brisket sandwich and the "amazing" clam chowder and lobster roll. Guests also appreciated the beautiful view and ambiance, notably complimenting the ocean lookout and the sunset from the outdoor deck. The restaurant's patriotism is evident, as it has served as a memorable venue for veterans to celebrate Military Appreciation Month accompanied by "warm smiles and welcoming thoughts." Despite high menu prices and a call for more variety, lovers of American cuisine will definitely find The Chart Room at Black Point Inn a worthwhile experience.

A photo of The Grill Room & Bar restaurant

5. The Grill Room & Bar

4.5

Awesome(1191)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Portland

Located in Portland, The Grill Room & Bar receives glowing reviews for its high-quality Steakhouse cuisine. Customers praise the restaurant for its delicious ribeye steak, perfectly cooked with all the traditional trimmings, and its old-school steakhouse atmosphere. Some declare it the best steakhouse in Portland, lauding its hardworking team and the unrivaled quality of beef. Customers also admire the restaurant's fantastic service and exquisite food, from a variety of steaks to scallops, all cooked to perfection. The Grill Room & Bar is highly recommended for its superb cuisine, with many planning to return for more unforgettable experiences.

6. Thames Landing

4.4

Awesome(17)

Price: Expensive

• American • Portland

Booked 2 times today

Thames Landing brings you modern New England fare—centered around seafood, local meat, and seasonal vegetables—in an airy, bright dining room and on our expansive garden patio.Menu includes appetizers like salt cod croquettes, mussels and deviled eggs, a variety of salads and entrees that range from lobster rolls and smashed burgers to lobster dinners and NY strip steaks. A private dining room remains in place and a cozy expanded outdoor seating area is now available.

A photo of Dunstan Tap And Table restaurant

7. Dunstan Tap And Table

4.8

Exceptional(646)

Price: Expensive

• American • Portland

Booked 14 times today

Dunstan Tap and Table stands out as a superior American cuisine restaurant situated in the heart of Old Orchard. The restaurant is continually praised by its patrons for its sumptuous, distinct food, and its quality service. The glowing testimonials such as "Best local place around", "food is DELICIOUS" and "Food was hot and fresh" underscores its excellence in serving authentic American food. The restaurant has been particularly appreciated for its inventive, fresh, high-quality and locally-sourced dishes which push the envelope on American comfort food. This, combined with the friendly staff and modern ambiance, make Dunstan Tap and Table a must-visit culinary destination.

A photo of The Garden Cafe, at The Portland Regency Hotel & Spa restaurant

8. The Garden Cafe, at The Portland Regency Hotel & Spa

new

4.3

Awesome(5)

Price: Moderate

• American • Portland

The Garden Café, at the Portland Regency Hotel and Spa - In the warmer months (and weather permitting), we invite you to dine al fresco across the street from the hotel at our enchanting Garden Café. Open for lunch, dinner, cocktails, or dessert, the café is framed by flowers, trees, and gentle ocean breezes; it’s a fabulous destination for catching up with friends or colleagues over delicious fare. During inclement weather we will serve inside at the Armory Lounge.

9. The Front Room

4.6

Exceptional(456)

Price: Moderate

• American • Portland

Booked 23 times today

Located in a serene residential neighborhood, The Front Room is an exceptional Portland restaurant that serves superb American cuisine. Often lauded by patrons as a "little gem" that delivers the warmth and familiarity of a neighborhood restaurant, the food and service at The Front Room are consistently outstanding. Their menu highlights include the Wagyu double smashed burgers, mushroom toast, and the Reuben sandwich. Patrons reliabily describe the food as delicious and of high quality, complemented by friendly, professional service. They also offer enticing specials such as $2 oysters and drink specials during Happy Hour. Although nestled in a quiet location, their elevated gastronomic offerings have earned them a stellar reputation. Despite its casual atmosphere, the food is upscale and exceptional, earning rave reviews from customers.

A photo of Eighteen95, at The Portland Regency Hotel & Spa restaurant

10. Eighteen95, at The Portland Regency Hotel & Spa

4.9

Exceptional(326)

Price: Moderate

• American • Portland

Booked 1 time today

Eighteen95 is lauded for its remarkable American cuisine. Reviewers constantly highlight the quality of their food, which includes popular dishes like Brussels sprouts, ricotta gnocchi, and duck. The excitement for their offerings extends to their desserts, with the chocolate cherry cake earning well-deserved praise. Their service is consistently described as stellar, professional, and attentive, contributing to the overall dining experience. The reviewers also mention their excellent brunch service and the delightful atmosphere, with many patrons making it a part of their annual trips to Portland. Additionally, their unique take on mimosas and esteemed bloody Mary’s have not gone unnoticed. The constant stream of positive reviews clearly signifies Eighteen95 as a hidden gem in American cuisine.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Cape Elizabeth

American