Best Afternoon Tea Restaurants in Theater District / Times Square

Price: Moderate (424)Price: Expensive (397)Price: Very Expensive (179)

10 restaurants available nearby

A photo of The Whitby Bar and Restaurant restaurant

1. The Whitby Bar and Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(1166)

Price: Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Midtown West

Booked 109 times today

The Whitby Bar and Restaurant, located in Upper Midtown, Manhattan, offers a unique, American cuisine experience in a magical ambience with eclectic furnishings. Guests find their outstanding service, top-notch food, and diverse menu truly impressive. This establishment is especially known for its elegant high tea experience, which has been deemed "a whimsical retreat" and "a must-see in NYC." Guests have also praised its ability to offer a perfect setting for celebrations from birthdays to business lunches. Their attentive, unobtrusive service has been highly acknowledged, as well as their top flight service and gorgeous decor. The Whitby Bar and Restaurant thus stands as a superb place for all American cuisine lovers to visit.

A photo of The Palm Court at The Plaza Hotel restaurant

2. The Palm Court at The Plaza Hotel

4.3

Awesome(5778)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Midtown East

Booked 65 times today

The Palm Court at The Plaza Hotel in New York City is renowned for delivering an exclusive and elevated dining experience. Reviewers commend it as a "must for anyone visiting New York City", citing it as one of the best services they've had in both Europe and America. Patrons praise the establishment for its excellent service, detailed attention, and for offering a memorable dining experience that far exceeds expectations. Despite being a bit pricey, the Palm Court is celebrated for its vegan offerings and a wide range of teas. The ambiance, food quality, and exceptional service all contribute to making visits to the restaurant "a magical experience."

A photo of The Parisian Tea Room- NYC restaurant

3. The Parisian Tea Room- NYC

3.6

Very Good(192)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Garment District / Flower District

Booked 5 times today

The Parisian Tea Room in New York City is a highly recommended destination for an authentic Afternoon Tea experience. Patrons laud it for its superb service, exquisite ambiance, and notably delicious food. The restaurant's presentation of dainty courses, including a variety of teas, cheese, sweets, and croissant sandwiches, has left a lasting impression on guests. The charm is further amplified by the decor, reminiscent of a romantic Parisian setting. Reviewers commend the owner, Karen, for her graciousness and dedication in crafting the perfect afternoon tea. Whether it's for special occasions or simply enjoying high-quality tea, The Parisian Tea Room has consistently exceeded expectations.

4. Lady Mendls

4.9

Exceptional(979)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Union Square

Booked 20 times today

Lady Mendls in NYC, is an exquisite spot for Afternoon Tea, noted by many as one of the best tea rooms in the city. Customers repeatedly praised the restaurant's warm, inviting ambiance, excellent service, and the quality of their food as some of the core reasons for their high ratings. The selection of sandwiches, scones, and teas has received particularly strong reviews, with one customer highlighting the "variety of tastes and textures" in the finger sandwiches. It is also a popular venue for celebrations such as birthdays and bridal teas, enhancing the overall experience with its sophisticated atmosphere and attentive staff.

5. Gotham Lounge

4.4

Awesome(107)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Midtown West

Booked 2 times today

Gotham Lounge, located at the Peninsula Hotel in New York City, comes highly recommended for its exceptional Afternoon Tea cuisine. The lounge, known for its elegant atmosphere and impeccable service, provides a unique experience that is consistently praised in reviews. Customers highlight the delicious and light food offerings, the beautiful ambiance, and the staff's attention to special occasions. The Holiday Afternoon Tea at Gotham Lounge is particularly celebrated due to its festive charm, making Christmas in NYC even more delightful. Visitors from all over the world, including Australia, speak of their fantastic experiences, with some making it a yearly tradition. The establishment's commitment to making every visit a memorable affair, from the food to the generous service, makes it a must-visit destination.

6. AnnTremet Cake

4.4

Awesome(31)

Price: Expensive

• Afternoon tea • West Village

Booked 2 times today

AnnTremet Cake offers a delightful Asian dining experience that resonates in the heart of its many patrons. Their tea service comes highly recommended, although a reservation is crucial due to the limited seating. The homemade mousse cakes, available in an array of flavors, are described as "phenomenal" and "scrumptious". The Mother's Day tea is a popular choice, praised as "delicious". The food is not only rich in flavor but also in cultural authenticity, with their lychee cake drawing rave reviews. The welcoming and accommodating staff adds to the overall ambience, making AnnTremet Cake a beloved dining spot where Asian cuisine comes alive.

7. Wildcard Bar

new

5.0

Exceptional(0)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Midtown East

Booked 8 times today

Wildcard Bar is a Japanese inspired cocktail bar hidden on the second floor of a townhouse in Midtown Manhattan. Our Afternoon Tea menu features Japanese inspired savory bites, finger sandos, and housemade sweets. Our décor is reminiscent of Meiji Restoration era Japan with cues from the four seasons throughout the space. Our team's first priority is hospitality and we look forward to having you at Wildcard.

A photo of Cacao Bar & Tea Salon by Mariebelle restaurant

8. Cacao Bar & Tea Salon by Mariebelle

4.9

Exceptional(65)

Price: Expensive

• Afternoon tea • SoHo

Booked 24 times today

Cacao Bar & Tea Salon by Mariebelle, located in Soho, offers a delightful high tea experience. From the savory sandwiches to the fluffy scones and tempting macaroons, their offerings are delicious, beautifully presented, and of excellent quality. The ambiance of the establishment is often compared to a quaint French café, making it a perfect, cozy spot for small gatherings. The service has been consistently praised in reviews, with several mentions of the friendly and attentive waiter, Johnny. Reviewers highly recommended the afternoon tea experience and appreciated the unlimited teas and coffees that are included. The hot chocolate, which has also received rave reviews, adds a unique touch to the traditional afternoon tea.

A photo of The Parlour, Brooklyn High Low restaurant

9. The Parlour, Brooklyn High Low

4.9

Exceptional(52)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Park Slope

Booked 9 times today

Situated in Park Slope Brooklyn, The Parlour, Brooklyn High Low offers a unique and inviting experience for Afternoon Tea enthusiasts. The establishment provides an intimate, calming ambiance that customers love and continually praise. Visitors highlight the meticulously crafted menu, including an array of delicately made sandwiches, a variety of sweet desserts and an impressive selection of teas. The attentive staff, beautiful decor, and comforting, home-like setting make this eatery extraordinary. Patrons express their delight with the flavorful food, the attentive service, and the thoughtful details, including individual unique teapots. It has become a recurrent destination for locals and tourists alike, with many guests eagerly anticipating their next visit.

10. Brooklyn High Low

4.8

Exceptional(270)

Price: Very Expensive

• Afternoon tea • Prospect Heights

Booked 3 times today

Brooklyn High Low offers an exceptional afternoon tea experience, highly praised for its inviting ambience, attentive service, and outstanding tea offerings. Patrons appreciate the "relaxed environment" and "comfortable seating" in this quaint yet unpretentious setting. The variety of teas and sandwiches on offer received rave reviews for being more extensive than most places, leading many to call it "one of my favorite afternoon tea experiences." The unique decor contributes to the overall charm, creating a cozy and calming atmosphere perfect for an afternoon escape. The staff is consistently commended for their warmth and eagerness to enhance the tea experience, making Brooklyn High Low a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable high tea experience.

Explore OpenTable

Theater District / Times Square

Afternoon tea