CRATE Sushi & Seafood

A delightful evening

Best sushi ever. Service is amazing. Have already been back twice since.

We loved the ambiance. Our server Dan was attentive to our toddler and anticipated her needs. The dood was delicious. It was the dish fry we had been craving to end our vacation week.

We love the restaurant. One of the top three restaurants for evening dining in Sturgeon Bay.

Kitchen is so slow it’s unbelievable. Waited 45 min for our order. They cater to people going to the “show” so either say that you’re going to one or expect a 2 hour dinner, and leave hungry. Waiter is apologetic and asks us to “be patient” but offers nothing else for the crazy long wait.

This was a good experience, but it took far too long to get our food. Our reservation was at 6:30PM and we did not get out of there until 9PM. There was one stretch where we did not see or hear from our server for 45 minutes. I realize that there was a rush of business, but it would have been nice for the wait person to tell us what was going on. Food was very good.

Crate Sushi never disappoints. We heard their new winter menu came out so we had to take another trip over. I never have a bad meal. The service was excellent. I don't think I asked once for a refill of my drink or water carafe. He was so on top of everything. Excellent

Exceptional red snapper chef's special! Amazing taste and presentation. Tried 3 different types of Sushi which were all very fresh and with amazing tastes!

Wonderful food and perfect service by Benjamin. Great date night

Ben was our server, he was fantastic. The food arrived promptly and was delish. This was our first time at Crate and certainly not our last. Thanks for the great experience.

Place was almost empty and I felt sick after dinner

Really well prepared dishes. Nice wine selections. Service could be better .

My husband and I visited crate over the weekend. The atmosphere was lovely and our waiter was outstanding. My husband ordered the Pork Belly Ramen, but was told that they were out. Our waiter was very apologetc. We ended up each ordering a basic sushi roll and a special sushi roll. Typically (at other sushi resturaunts that we frequent) a special roll costs $5-10 more than a basic roll, but is also larger than a basic roll. These rolls all appeared to be on the small side for the price. They were delicious though, and would return if in the area. The ingredients like, lemon infused tobiko and fresh basil, gave the rolls a unique flavor compared to other sushi I have had. Overall it was a nice dinner.

Crate is one of the more creative restaurant alternatives to the typical sports bars and supper clubs in Door County, especially when it comes to seafood. It's only drawback is its noise level that emanates from the bar and the annoying level of too energetic music. High energy levels, even from the otherwise excellent servers who have to shout for attention, seem like strange accoutrements when it comes to a personal evening of sushi, saki and sophisticated food preparation. Crate needs to dial it back.

Great sushi, great service, oysters tasted great but definitely over priced (6 for$20)

Food was a little slow to arrive but the place is so nice and the waiter Benjamin was too that I have to give it five stars. Lots of great menu options, delicious food, reasonably priced. Would definitely go back. 😊

Food was good, service could have been better that evening.

The flavor of all the food we had was great, but some items were warmer than we would have expected. For example, the raw oysters and sushi. Not sure if they were put onto warm plates or sat at room temperature for too long, but thought they should have been cooler.

We have not had Sushi since moving to Door County. It was great to find a place that is equivalent to the sushi restaurants we were used to in Milwaukee.

We had a delightful meal at the CRATE this past weekend, having selected a variety of choices from their menu. Our sushi, calamari and each of their accompanying sauces were delicious. The edamame saiad a treat of flavors and textures. And, the ahi tuna entree we shared was exceptionally fresh, perfectly seared and accompanied with some delicious side dishes. It is a pleasant surprise to find this quality of restaurant in a smaller town. The table we had added to our evening's pleasure, being in the front of the house by the window. It kept the noise level of a larger party, dining at the same time and in the back of the house, down to a level that could have been obtrusive.

The meal was delicious! They were able to accommodate both my gluten allergy and my sons dairy. The waitress was a little too busy but overall she did a great job. The sushi was pretty basic stuff and the presentation was very plain, but overall they tasted great so I would recommend.

This is our 3rd time at Crate and it did not disappoint. We had a delicious bottle of wine, my husband had the special t-bone and I had the white fish. Both entrees cooked to perfection. Our server Coco was top notch and bright and a sunny part of our dinner.

Very Good Food, waiter was awesome, forgot his name. Tartare sauce was good on the fish lol

It was just ok.

Friday night fish dinners are very good. Really enjoy the whitefish plate. Good variety of sushi. Nice dinner option for Sturgeon Bay. Friendly staff.

We are from Milwaukee and stayed at a bed and breakfast in Algoma. We told another two other guests and they went the next day and also had great food and experience.
Thank you for a fun time on my 65th birthday,
Gordon Steckler

Cocktails were great. The food was good. Loved the use of C&B goods for furniture, plates, glasses etc. Also like to go in store after dinner.

Reasonable prices, large range of food choices and ranging from small portion to dinner size.

Benjamin is the best. Makes our trip to CRATE worth while.

Great food, great service

The sushi was so-so but the vichyssoise was amazing I would come back just for that.

The first time we ate at Crate we loved it so much we ended up going back the next night. It is now on our "must-do" list every time we go to Door County. The sushi is fresh, creative and easily the best we have ever had in Wisconsin!

The majority of our dinner was awesome! Fresh raw oysters, lobster cocktail and beef carpaccio—all great. Good beer and cocktail selection. Loved the “gin fix”! My rainbow trout was very good and our friends had steaks, which they reported as delicious. Our only disappointment were the crab cakes—-more like deep fried crab fritters. Not what one expects in a crab cake. Would go back, for sure.

Excellent sushi and service! We had unagi and avocado rolls, salmon sashimi and tuna rolls. Everything was absolutely delicious. Nice location. Didn't enjoy the hot sake, however. I'd go with the bottled sake next time.

Our family of seven dined at Crate during a trip to Sturgeon Bay for salmon fishing. Looking for a foodie experience, we were not disappointed. The food was on point and the server had great energy. Love this addition to Sturgeon Bay, great atmosphere and even better sushi/entrees. Thank you for a lovely evening.

Wonderful sushi rolls. Limitted but creative menu. Delightful staff. Superb service. Very high quality steak, seafood and pork. Enjoyable evening at Crate.

Great food. We were able to sit outside and just enjoyed the foot traffic going by.

I have eaten several times at CRATE and have never been disappointed. Great Food, Great Service.
Spent the first 30 minutes at the bar. Great service.

We had an awesome time at CRATE on Monday night. The Bhudda's Delight was perfect for the vegans in our group. Can't thank the chef enough for swapping out ramen noodles for rice instead. Others in our party loved the scallops, and we were all pleased by the wine list. We would recommend CRATE to others and would go back. Many thanks to our server & our chef!

We have been to Crate about 4 times for Sushi, and have always enjoyed it, but this week we felt like getting a hot dish. We found our cooked fish very creative and delicious, large scallops on bacon grits, cooked just right. The special Mauhi, was also delicious and creative. It is so convenient to the TAP theatre, which has one of their best musicals showing right now, La La Lucille. Perfect evening!