This is our all time favorite place to eat! We have eaten here many times and are never disappointed.
Had dinner for the first time at the Coldwater Cafe and overall was pleased with my visit.
Service was good, waitress was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and specials, food was delivered with good timing between courses, and was good also. Two things that struck me, the bar noise carried into the dinning room, making it hard to talk quietly at our table and the prices seemed a little inflated for where it is located.
Other than that, no complaints!
Excellent as usual!!
Coldwater Café is our favorite restaurant. We have been coming here for years and have never had a bad meal. The food is delicious! The service is excellent. We love to eat there and also go there on special occasions.
We have introduced our friends to Coldwater
and they love it , too.
We recently celebrated our anniversary there and Coldwater made it extra special. Thank you to Coldwater for always making dining there extra special!!!!!
The wine, food and service were outstanding , as always. This place is out favorite! It’s consistent And cares about all of its customers and goes
Out of its way to value the regulars like us.
As always another great dining experience at the Coldwater Café.
I gave all 4's on my first review because we went on Valentines Day and the place was a madhouse, but our latest outing was exceptional. The food, the service, the seating, everything was superb. If they would add Col. E.H. Taylor Bourbon to their top shelf I'll be able to grant that last star the next time we visit...and there will definitely be a next time.
My wife and I were celebrating our 50th wedding anniversary along with our son and daughter in law. When I made the reservation on open table I mentioned this fact and asked if they could make baked Alaska which is definitely not a common desert. The executive Chef surprised us with a great presentation of the desert after a truly wonderful meal. My thanks to all of the staff who made our evening very special and memorable.
The food is always good at Coldwater Cafe I love Wednesday wine night all glasses only $5 and their house salad dressing is a cucumber dill that is really good. I do wish they would put their Lobster crab cakes back on dinner menu and not just as an appetizer it has always been one of my favorite. You will not be disappointed if you dine here
Excellent food and outstanding service. The dinner menu is creative, and the presentation is beautiful. The Coldwater Cafe is one of the few truly special dining experiences in the Dayton area. I've already made plans to return for lunch this week!
Wanted to find a memorable venue for a very special visit, and we were very pleased with our entire experience. It is a warm, cozy and unique venue with upscale menu selections and an outstanding wine selection, all at a very reasonable price considering the quality. Will definitely keep this option in mind for future special occasions.
Birthday. Enjoyed food and service
Just an awesome environment and experience! Well done!!
I recommend this restaurant all the time...I have never been disappointed,
Nick and Katie were the best!! Kelli did a great job taking care us all!! We appreciate the tour of the kitchen and Nicks establishment next door!! Always a pleasant experience!!!
We enjoyed the food and the experience, and look forward to returning there--liked that there was flexibility to tailor items for dietary needs.
We had an excellent dinner! We met friends from Piqua and it was a perfect restaurant to spend the evening at. The bar area is wonderful and they had live entertainment when we arrived.
My wife says this is her new favorite restaurant, so she would likely give it a 5. I also really enjoyed it. Everything from the appetizer to the desert were on point with a creative flair. My only criticism would be that just about everything we ordered was just a little bit sweet. Each individual dish was spot on, but I’m going to try and avoid that overarching theme next time. For the record my wife thought everything was perfect and that I was crazy for uttering anything but praise, so your mileage may vary. The ambiance was nice. We particularly enjoyed the live music, which was loud enough to enjoy but not affect conversation. Our server was great. We spent about $120 with tip, for the two of us. On the expensive side around here, but fine for a nice night out given the quality. We’ll definitely be back. If you like fish, try the ruby trout. Cheers.
Coldwater is one of the best fine dining establishments in our area. Food preparation, timing of courses, great drinks, and muscles to die for. Doesn't get any better than that.
I'm always a fan of coldwater cafe. The food is always delicious. The port shoulder was beautifully cooked and very tender. As usual, I had to get the cherry almond bread pudding. Huge fan of the bread that is served. This place gets two thumbs up!!!!
Excellent food, excellent service, knowledgeable sommelier. Our favorite place and it's 25 miles away
We have been a fan of Coldwater Cafe for many years. We have enjoyed lunches as well as dinners and have never been disappointed with the service or the food. This is our “go to place” when we are looking for an outstanding dining experience.
This is our favorite restaurant, but we had never been here for Valentine’s Day. It was even more lovely than we had imagined. They closed the restaurant between lunch and dinner (which they don’t normally do) to transform the restaurant. It was beautiful and we enjoyed the fresh flowers and chocolates they provided. We will definitely do it again next year!
The restaurant was phenomenal. The food was out of this world. The service was incredible. However, there should be a better connection between open table and the restaurant because the reservation was a little over an hour pass it’s time, and that really made it a little tempting to leave...
For Valentines and man did it come through on the love category. The make you feel very welcomed (even though reservations were running an hour behind... so what... and extra glass of wine while waiting is NOT a bad thing). They even left you a rose at your table... Just a totally amazing place.
We had reservations on Valentines Day and were an hour late being seated, so, reserving one star for that. We do plan to return for a mid-week meal so we can see what it's like on a more typical day. The food was very good.
Valentines. The only negative is they messed up the reservations and our table was an hour late.
Unfortunately in spite of good food and atmosphere management of this restaurant continu to fail guests who have reservations. We had the reservation at 7:30 pm. We have to until 8:20 before table was offered and we were standing during all this time. Guest who had reservations at 7pm they waited until 8pm and some of the guests decided to leave. This is not first time happened at this location. Management continue to underestimate, cooking or service time and making their guests suffer.
Food was great! Service was great! Atmosphere was great! A table near us probably didn't have the same experience, but I assure you, it wasn't because of the service. Some people just can't be pleased. Second time at the restaurant and it was just as good if not better than before.
This restaurant always delivers great food and service.
Valentine’s Day dinner!! Our server Stephanie was AWESOME!! They offered a special menu but we ordered from the regular menu.
All the food was prepared as ordered and was delicious. We shared a first course of Lobster Crab Cakes. The spicy corn sauce was amazing!
We both had the Brussels Sprout salad which also was very tasty. A basket of sourdough bread with honey butter accompanied the salads.
Third course was Scottish Salmon (ordered medium rare) with asparagus and Jasmine rice for my husband. I ordered the New York Strip steak (ordered medium rare) with asparagus and garlic mashed potatoes.
Dessert was Chocolate Mousse cake with chocolate ganache. The cake was light and moist. Mousse and ganache YUM!!
A Winter Margherita and a glass of Pinot Noir completed the meal.
Wonderful atmosphere too!!
The most amazing home town dining anywhere around. Not good but great food eveytime and the service is top notch.
As always Coldwater Cafe is a favorite for great romantic dining. I highly recommend anything on the menu as I’ve never been wrong with a different choice each time!
What a treat! We drove to Tipp City from Columbus to meet with Springfield friends and we were delighted with a country french ambiance, lively crowd but not too loud for conversation, and the food was fabulous! It was totally worth the drive and we hope to see the charming Tipp City in the daylight!
Good food and service
All good. Wait staff and food very good
Went this time to celebrate family. An amazing time. The waitress overheard me tell my daughter to order the house salad with the dill dressing as the dressing is fabulous and I am still trying to copy it at home. At the end of the evening, the waitress gifted me with a nice quart tub of their dill dressing. The staff are just so warm and friendly at this place.
This restaurant has consistently good food served piping hot. We always have had attentive servers that know their food and beverages. Live 2 piece band play on weekends starting at 7pm for nice background music. Make sure you have reservations or you won't get a table on the weekend.
Service and food were excellent!
The service, food, ambiance and staff are all fantastic. We love dining here.