This includes info about cleaning, sanitizing, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn more.
Coldwater Cafe & Catering
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Waitstaff wear masks
roasted garlic smashed potatoes, sauted zucchini, house made steak sauce, fried onions
4 oz hand cut filet mignon served atop a bed of chopped iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, gorgonzola, red onion, and scallions, served with a side of house made creamy parmesan dressing
sriracha cocktail sauce
We were very please with the food, drinks, service and outside seating
perfect evening, great food, great service, all the help couldn't have been more pleasant, love the new whiskey glasses
There were six of us and the booth was a bit cramped with six older adults. My husbands lamb shank was tough but his friend ordered the same and his was tender. Go figure.
Sat in the vault by ourselves. It was nice. The past with shrimp was outstanding along with the wedge salad. My wife had the Tilapia and it was good as well. Coldwater Cafe is her favorite and it was her birthday. Our waitress was so nice and attentive.
the lobster crabcakes were very good. so were the steaks
Fantastic food! Will be back for sure. Super convenient to reserve the table online instead of a long wait. Great service and I can’t say enough about the food! Have already told quite a few people they have to stop in!
My husband wears a hearing aid in one ear and a cochlear device in the other, so noise level is very important to us. We had a pleasant lunch with our granddaughter. Everything was wonderful.
Well organized and prompt, the service and food was amazing and dessert was heavily enjoyed. Best restaurant in the Dayton area, by far.
The weather was perfect for an outdoor lunch.
The service was perfect and so was the food.
Hope you get the squash soup back soon!
Only gave 4 stars because my husband ordered the Lamb Shank and he felt if was over cooked and didn't care for the flavor. We had Kelly as our server and she was outstanding. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and just a very good server.
Our food was delicious and our server was friendly and professional. The salmon with couscous and citrus vinaigrette tasted fresh and flavorful. (The only minor hitch was that the entree came out half way through the salad course but the server was apologetic and this is not typical of our experiences here.)
Amazing food and atmosphere. Our waitress was very attentive. Small menu which obviously shows that they care greatly about each dish they prepare. Highly recommended. New favorite local dinner spot.
The service and food excellent as always! Their bread is amazing! Sadly the bees wanted to join us but there’s not much you can do about that, I wouldn’t want them hurt but they were annoying. I always look forward to my next visit!
With an unanticipated cool evening the restaurant modified our request for outdoor seating and placed my wife and I at a secluded indoor table. Our server, Robyn, was well-versed in the menu and wine list, attentive to our needs and acknowledged our wedding anniversary in style. Both food and wine selections were excellent - we will be back !
Great atmosphere. Food is always excellent and service is great.
Coldwater Cafe' never disappoints. Delicious food, delightful atmosphere, and friendly service!
Crab cakes are delicious! Desserts are extraordinary!
Great atmosphere!, Good food and service! Love this place!
The food is outstanding! Everything we get there is great! One of the best restaurants in the Dayton area! A little pricey.
Great food and the outside dinning is a fun change of pace.
We made a reservation for Saturday evening through Open Table one week in advance on a Saturday evening. We were entertaining out of town guests and wanted to be seated somewhere with a nice patio area. We arrived 7 minutes early and were told we could be seated but would not have our waitress until she arrived. My husband ordered a $36 filet cooked medium well done. We specifically requested pink in the middle and the waiter insisted we order it medium well done or it would have blood oozing. The filet looked more like a small steak (thin) and was charred on the outside and well done on the inside with not a trace of pink. The waiter seemed overwhelmed and we could not get his attention regarding the steak. When he came and looked at it he offered to remove it from our $200 bill, but he had to get permission and the woman that came out only gave us half off because my husband had eaten half of it. We ordered a bottle of Malbec wine and the same woman had to be consulted on the wine and she came to our table and said they were out of the wine we ordered but she brought a sample of a different non Malbec wine. Our guest was taken back because there were multiple choices of Malbec on the menu and not one was offered. The waiter had to consult with the wine expert (the same woman). They did find a $40 bottle of Malbec. It was not that good. Our other guest asked if she could have sauteed spinach with their Tilapia on top as she is on a diet. The waiter said he would have to ask if they could do that. They did agree to it, but the fish was just two small pieces and they charged the full meal price. We received one bread basket for 4 people and no one checked to see if we wanted more or how the food was. We were very disappointed. We had hoped for the jazz music that had been promoted on their website, but alas, because of the COVID were told it was no longer available. The patio area is new and beautiful, but for the money we felt like it was a bust.
Complimentary wine to celebrate our anniversary was very nice. Zachary gave excellent service. Their filet is the best!
Always a great experience. Amazing food + service. Kelly is our favorite and always gives us the best service.
Had a great lunch and wonderful waitress!
Had a reservation for noon. Waited 30 minutes and table still not available. Changed our request from a 6 top to 2 4 tops and got seated. Service slow. Never given a desert menu. Food excellent. Best quiche I’ve ever had in my life. Outdoor dining area like a wind tunnel, very cold. Needed heaters.
Always my favorite. Perfect in every way. Service is top notch, seating is perfection, food is always fresh, creative and inviting.
Just 4 of us celebrating a retirement. Good food as always. Great service as usual. And it was wine on Wednesday so...
Excellent, as always!
The Tuna Tartar is a rich mixture of tuna, avocado, cucumber and scallion with a sauce-spice blend that pulls it all together into a delectable beginning to a fabulous and unforgettable dining experience.
Always a fantastic place with impeccable service and very delicious food. A place I return to frequently. Maybe one of the finer restaurants in the Miami county.
Very good menu that changes with the seasons. Love the carrot cake!
Can’t think of a better place to celebrate a happy occasion .
First time! Excellent food, excellent service. Restaurant did a great job adhering to social distancing. We Look forward to our next visit.
We really enjoyed the food. The staff were very kind and offered great service. The restaurant is inviting and nicely decorated. A great atmosphere!
We have visited three times in the last two months. The quality is outstanding. A little pricey, but worth it.
The food and service was great! The atmosphere was a little older than what I typically go for, but it was wonderfully nonetheless.
Great patio setting. Wonderful service. The lobstercake over spinach salad is my favorite. Looking forward to our next visit!
This is a must if in the area of Tipp City, Miami County
Always a lovely setting and excellent food. Cleanliness and social distancing standards were also excellent.
Delicious wedge salad and crab cakes while dining on the patio. It was a very nice evening ! Our server was excellent, and I felt very safe. Thank you!
Coldwater Cafe & Catering offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (937) 667-0007.
Coldwater Cafe & Catering is rated 4.9 stars by 1631 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.