Given that the restaurant had a LOT of five star reviews, we decided to give it a try. The ambiance was good, the service amazing, but the food was just OK.
A wonderful restaurant for a special occasion. While it is a great steakhouse, the seafood offerings are equally as good. My husband's steak was perfectly cooked which is hard to achieve . Wines are notable and range is price. It is not your typical men's club steakhouse making it a great date night spot. It is on our favorite list in NYC .
Surprised my boyfriend for his birthday with a very sophisticated and unique steakhouse experience. We had a reservation at 7:30 on a Saturday night, and when we arrived, there was no waiting, our table was already prepped. Wonderful hostess, wait staff, waitress, generous food portion, and great flavors. Started out with exquisite Cesar and Beet salads, great textures and taste. For the main course, we enjoyed our veal chop and prime rib eye steak, both medium-rare. Our sides included creamed spinach and creamy mashed potatoes. Then they cleared out plates and after a short wait, they brought over delicious chocolate mousse and other dessert samplers for my wonderful boyfriend! The hostess even took a complimentary photo for us. The entire experience from beginning to end was truly unforgettable in a gorgeous red textured setting. Incredibly romantic and beautiful. We look forward to dining there again!
The food is always great and the service is fantastic.
Fantastic warm and inviting atmosphere.
Great place for a date.
Very good food.
A bit pricey but well worth it for a special occasion.
Está de moda. No hay relación calidad de comi
Excellent service and delicious food.
This is my favorite steak house. Been coming here for years and the service is ALWAYS on point. It will impress any date. The decor is really classy & comforting. The filet mignon is the bomb be careful you will get hooked on it. It’s that good. Also love the sides, creamed spinach and mashed potatoes are amazing here!
My favorite steak house. Simply love it! We had great time , delicious food and with that I mean best steak , cooked perfectly. Service was so attentive and took care of us from the beginning till the end. A night to remember.
The wait staff was excellent. The porter house for 2 was amazing. The Mac and cheese was delicious. This place is in the upper echelon of NYC steakhouses. Great value and a great family run vibe to the place.
Everything was amazing!
My boyfriend and I would like to thank manager and all staff for a beautiful evening at their restaurant. It was a Birthday celebration and they made us feel special. Everything from appetizers to dessert was delicious. 5* service!!! We will definitely be back.
A fantastic restaurant - the staff are very friendly, helpful and clearly enjoy their job, while the steak is brilliant. A great range of side orders, and super drinks menu means the restaurant has it all. The best steak in NYC.
Great as usual
My husband and I visited Club A for our anniversary dinner on a Saturday evening. We were kindly seated earlier than our reservation. We sat upstairs by the window and it was a pretty view as the sun went down and the greenery was lit up. The bread basket was good, as was our wine selections. We ordered the porterhouse for 2 and it was cooked perfectly and delicious. The mac and cheese side was also memorable. Skip the fingerling potatoes and creamed spinach, neither was mind blowing. The service was attentive and top notch. The complimentary dessert was a nice touch and the perfect finish to our evening. Overall, we had a great experience at Club A and look forward to returning in the future!
Service was poor the waiter had a bad attitude. The steak wasn’t the best I’ve had but it wasn’t the worst either. Nothing really stood out during my experience there.
very Good Service with nice people
Good food! Large portions.
Awesome experience!! This was a the first dinner on our honeymoon and wow we where beyond satisfied!!
One of my favorite restaurants in NYC hands down. Service and quality of food is always top notch.
Love this place. Will visit again.
What stands out most was the great service by the entire staff. They were very friendly and helpful, but not over bearing. The staff also did an incredible job with the timing of the meal. We were not rushed, but yet checked on in a most pleasing manner. Excellent job. Very good food. Highly recommended.
We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience, the staff was friendly and the service was great. Steaks were cooked and tasted perfect! We were near the music which was an added bonus, and who can complain about some free desserts? Would highly recommend.
First of all, the food is good! Love the smoke bacon and steak! Big size! The in home jazz music is great and never stop provide a romantic atmosphere really great for dates. The waiter also service us a lot of dessert provide by house lovely and delicious!
We loved everything the appetizer, salad, steaks are melt in your mouth good. Then at the end the plate of desserts were just phenomenal. Definitely a must return restaurant!
We went there with friends during a former trip and it was so delicious that we wanted absolutely to come again so much the meat is delicious !
It’s a very good idea and very friendly to bring a free assortment of desserts at the end of the meal.
Fantastic, brought serious NYC foodie bankers who never went here, they loved it. Great food, steaks and seafood both great. Amazing service and the decor was warm and impressive.
I went with a Groupon voucher and they were so friendly and very patient with my boyfriend and I. They were helpful when choosing what to order and let us taste the wine before deciding on it. Super professional and would definitely come here again and again! Steak is phenomenal!! Really cozy and dim lighting is perfect!
We are on holiday visiting New York from the UK. For us, this was the best meal of our trip. My boyfriend had the fillet steak, I had the swordfish. Both dishes were delicious, hot, great sides and very tasty. We tried the steak at Wollensky's but decided this was even better. Service was great and very friendly and the strawberry mojitos also very scrummy! Would totally recommend. Budget about $90 per person.
We went with a groupon. The bottle of red wine included was very nice. We had the steak tartare and fried calamari as appetizers, delicious. The hanger steak wa cook to perfection, and the garlic rosemary fries were extra crisp and tasty.
& they give you gifts
Jut amazing highly recommended
amazing experience. i took my wife and 2 kids there
From the time you enter the door its first class all the way. The meat is great, staff friendly attentive but do not bug you. They are highly flexible and respond positively when you have a special request such as a particular food ingredient or type alergy
I really enjoyed the dinner in Club A Steakhouse. I went there to have dinner with my mother and sister who come to NYC all the way from Japan. service and ambient was perfect. and I'm sure this is the best STEAK House in NYC. Ravioli was also great!
Waiter spilled half a glass of (expensive) wine. We were offered a complimentary plate of dessert, which was a nice gesture.
1st time in New York and we were looking for recommendations. This had great reviews and did not disappoint. Food was great, polite assertive waiters. Starters, mains and desert all equally good and overall felt very reasonable. Would recommend.
Lovely ambiance, delicious food, friendly & assertive staff.
We enjoyed every morsel. The service was superb and the atmosphere was quiet and warm. Can't wait to go back.
The ambiance was so nice and service was good as well. I wanna recommend to my people .
Meat is just so juicy and tasty!! Service profesionnal but friendly. This is really a " valeur sûre". And additionally they offered deserts!!