Server took the order and when food came out the lobster (that was ordered did not come out). It took over 25 minutes for the lobster to arrive. The manager took the price of the lobster off the bill but by that time the evening had a little kink in it. And supposedly, we were seated at that table because the server we were given was one of the best. The Pompano fish that the waiter raved about was just ok (a little dry for my taste).
Best fish restaurant. Great selection. Top notch service.
Waitress well knowledge of the menu and recommended the jumbo lump crab cake, which was amazing! Very friendly place.
CFM is always reliable. They let you share salads, switch side dishes, etc with no hassle. Food is always fresh and service is caring. Manager always checks to see if things are going well.
From the start our Friday night dinner was a bad experience. We had a 7:30pm reservation. We arrived 10 minutes early our friends arrived 5 minutes early. When we arrived I introduced myself to the hostess. She asked if we were all present, I said my friends would arrive any moment. She said as soon as they arrived we would be seated. Well we waited to be seated for 15 minutes after they arrived. At the table we waited for another 10 minutes or so until our waitress came to our table. She took our drink order, our dinner order a few minutes later. After bringing our drinks and then our appetizers (salad) we waited one and a quarter hours to be served our dinner, two of the 4 orders were incorrect. The side dishes of the other two orders were not as ordered. A complimentary shrimp cocktail and a piece of cake did not make up for the screw-ups. Never again!!
We visited City Fish with another couple last Friday night and left very disappointed. After sitting in the bar waiting for our reserved table we ordered a glasses of wine. We asked the waiter there about the lobster sizes this evening. He said “up to 2 lbs.”.
Seated at our dinner table the waiter, when asked the same question said that they indeed had 3 pound and up. Three of the four of us ordered the larger lobsters. While waiting, the other couple ordered an expensive bottle of wine. After about 15-20 minutes, the waiter returned only to tell us that there were no 3 pound lobsters. He offered larger ones. Feeling like we got the “bait and switch”, we asked that he check with the manager about getting us the next size up but only charge for 3 pounds. That did not happen.
To add insult to injury, after ordering our substitute entrees (without salads) they brought salads out that had been ordered, and came with, the lobsters. Initially, we refused them but, because of the long wait we accepted them. We were charged for them. The description of what does, and does not, come with sides or salads is very confusing.
When it got to an hour after we sat down without dinner being served, we called the manager over to express our displeasure. He said he would look into it and as he walked away our dinner came. Once the plates were presented he said he would “take care of (our) bar bill” which was transferred to the dinner tab.
My wife’s fish was dry and way over-cooked. The side broccoli was ice cold. The other couple’s dinners were tepid, at best. My guess is they sat under the warming lamps way too long going undelivered.
The final insult came when the bill came….with our dinner drinks on it. They did rectify it, but it was another negative experience for a very expensive evening.
We will probably go back for their happy hour which is good. We will not be dinner customers.
Go for the great food. Don't go if you want quiet. Wonderful warm bread. We ate too much before dinner. My favorite entree is almond encrusted brook trout.
Amazing food and service.
Avery noise inside but outside was perfect
Fabulous as always.
I love this place
Our visit to City Fish Market was a real treat. It was my wife's birthday and it couldn't have been better. The ambiance with a view of the lake was great, the service was amazing and the food was outstanding. Will definitely return again.
Great ambiance and service...pepper swordfish was different but excellent
Beautiful setting, great service and very good food.
Great, as usual
The Dover sole is excellent. We were seated by the water in a private room. Our server was outstanding. Wonderful.
When I had originally made the reservation I had asked for something to commemorate our friends anniversary. Upon checking in I confirmed this request which was acknowledged. However upon completion of dinner when asked if we wanted coffee no mention of dessert was offered and the bill came. I was quite disappointed that we did not have the opportunity to have a cake with a candle or any celebratory item
We ate outside for dinner in early April and it was very comfortable and relatively quiet. The service was excellent and the food was tasty, but the portions rather small for the price.
My wife ordered the seafood newburg, looking for a creamy white sauce with lump crab, scallops and shrimp. What she received was disappointing, a creamy red sauce with some type of slightly spicy or cajun seasoning. Although cooked well it is nothing like the traditional newburg. She commented the menu should definitely be updated with a more accurate description and include its a red sauce with a little cajun/creole (whatever) spice. Outside of the portion size, the only negative with the dining experience.
We'll be back because the fresh clams on the half shell and the Oysters Rockefeller were good. Not the size of Abe & Louie's Oysters but tasty nonetheless.
Food is always good.
I ordered lobster tails and when I got my plate the tail looked more like a shrimp and the presentation was very poor It only had a half of sweet potato on it and dinner was not worth $32. They offered me another tail charged me then took it off the bill We were very disappointed and probably will not return
Wanted to try this since it's part of the Buckhead restaurant group - we've eaten at Chops Lobster Bar & Grill in Boca a number of times and thought we'd give this a try. Atmosphere is not as upscale as Chops, but very pleasant and comfortable. Food was excellent - I had the crabcakes and my wife had the King Crab legs - both were right on target. Nice variety on the menu , service was attentive but not overbearing. A bit noisy, but able to carry on a conversation without having to shout. We will definitely go back.
Horrible service, will not go back😩😩😩😩
City Fish is always excellent all around. They have the best service, quality food and great prices. 5 Star Restaurant!!
All good not inexpensive but well worth it
The best recommendation that I can give is that City Fish Market is always consistent ....consistently excellent. The service is attentive and efficient and the food is great ... EVERY TIME.
Also worth mentioning is that my seating requests, through Open Table, have always been honored.
For a fish specialties restaurant, it’s unacceptable that you serve a piece of tuna that was no way to cut it even with a steak knife.
Furthermore you offer to replace it but you let french fries and vegetables in the plate
to be sure it was very cold.
We have been there many times but it will be the last one.
I thought it was a bit pricey for the amount of food they gave you, but the quality and service were good.
One of my favorite s but this visit down hill. First request ed outside table told all taken but for our total dinner a set table for four remained unused. Then although emphasized wanted sword fish very rare, came out well done and dry. Took 15 minutes to replace it. All and all not the usual visit
City Fish Market continues to be one of my favorite restaurants. The happy hour can't be beat and the live music in the bar is fun, but not overwhelming. The food is always fresh and delicious. The wait staff is friendly and recognizes loyal faces! LOVE THIS PLACE!
Food was VERY good service was excellent.
Probably the best restaurant I’ve ever visited. Easter Sunday. Packed very packed with customers. Our waiter completely understood the menu. My husband rarely compliments food. He couldn’t stop with the praise. You get more than what you pay. Highly recommend.
been eating at their restaurants since 1981, never a bad meal. service is always great no matter which restaurant you go to---p
Always good. Service impeccable. Can be pricey . Still love the place
Our waitress Brittany was awesome as always. She is so friendly & explains everything to you in a professional manner. I was there on 04/01/18 with my cousins & we all had a lovely time.
Great food and service as always, enjoyed the Dover sole!
Consistently good food and professional staff. The variety of seafood offerings is always a treat. Overall nothing but good things to say.
Always a pleasure getting seated at this restaurant with quick service, tasty fish, steak and sides. Gazebo makes for a pretty view and outdoor seating available. Nice menu to choose from. We will return.