City Fish Market
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
1/4 lb, lemon mustard butter sauce
Food was of poor quality (supposedly fresh) with terrible preparation and presentation.
Food was great. All of the waiters were wearing masks and the they were only using every other table so there was nobody nearby.
We went to celebrate my daughter’s graduation and the food was top notch as usual though the menu is a little shorter now. The restaurant clearly takes every precaution possible to provide a safe experience, more so than other restaurants I have been to recently, which I appreciated.
After enjoying the food at Chops lobster bar I decided to give city fish market a try (same restaurant group). The waiters here were much more friendly and attentive. The oysters were fresh and perfect. The sea bass I had, however, was sadly the worst I’ve ever eaten. It was the smallest, thinnest piece of sea bass I’ve ever been served. Something visually was off with it, but I couldn’t quite figure out what. The first bite tasted nothing like sea bass. It wasn’t buttery or flaky at all. It seemed undercooked and the flavor was quite fishy. It didn’t taste fresh. Recently I’ve had sea bass at capital grille, cut432 and twenty twenty grill. I eat it very regularly. I was so put off by this preparation that after my second bite i pushed the plate away and had zero interest to try anything else from the menu. If the sea bass was that disappointing, I didn’t want to be further disappointed. I also asked for charred/caramelized asparagus, and was assured it was cooked on a grill, but instead i was served bland, boiled asparagus. A little oil and seasoning goes a long way. I can assuredly say i won’t come back. Even if on another day the food was decent, consistency for me is key to any establishment where I become a regular, and first impressions are everything.
All servers were very friendly- only issue was that I was not made aware of price of specials by server until I saw on bill
Always a great meal at City Fish Market - Matthew our server and the rest of the staff were excellent - Glad to finally back!
Great table overlooking the pond. The restaurant had only recently reopened, but all the care and training done before they did really showed. Hadn't been back in awhile, but always a fantastic meal and experience.
Felt very safe. Everyone was nice but kept masks on and everything was donw with safety in mind. Even valet was very careful.
This was our first time out since the lock down. City Fish Market did everything right! Everyone was very aware to be clean they all had face masks on and there was hand sanitizer everywhere. All of the staff was very friendly. The service and the food was excellent. We will be going back soon!!!
Celebrated my assistant’s Birthday. Social distancing we’ll done. All staff had masks and gloves. Food was delicious. Service was fabulous.
Our thanks to Chuck for being so attentive to our needs! Food, service, atmosphere A+++!
First time dining in a few months. Experience was very positive feeling safety first. Food was delicious as I remembered, service very attentive, timing of courses serviced was perfect. Many thanks to the staff and will continue to support this restaurant.
The restaurant went to great pains to ensure everything was sanitized and the staff was masked; the tables were properly spread out; and the food and service was excellent. We felt very comfortable dining in these unusual times.
Guest, thank you for the five star review! We are so glad that we were able to deliver an unforgettable experience for you! Thank you for acknowledging all the hard work that our team is doing to ensure everyone's safety. Thank you for your support during this time and we look forward to serving you soon!
The ratings say it all.
Everything was perfect. Our server was fabulous and super friendly.
pattyprev, thank you for the five star review!! Glad to hear you thought everything was perfect, including the great service! Thank you for your support during this time and we look forward to serving you soon!
Service and food were outstanding as always-but the noise level was markedly improved-because of the weird “pandemic ambience”-this was the first dinner out since the infection caused such severe changes,and ambience is much affected by mask and glove wearing servers-with hygiene overtaking the whole setting-am very glad we ventured here,but will not dine out again till the restrictions are lifted!
Great service and food like always!
Guest, thank you for the five star review! We are so glad that you can depend on us for a great experience, time and time again! Thank you for your support during this time and we look forward to serving you soon!
I realize it was your reopening but quality was just not there. The bread wasn’t fresh. The shrimp/lump crabmeat cocktail just didn’t taste fresh. Entrees were ok but not up to CFM’s previous quality. Wish it could have been better.
Dear ROBERTO, thank you for leaving feedback about your most recent experience at City Fish Market. We would like to apologize for the lack of delivery you experienced while dining with us. Anytime you are not 100% satisfied with your meal, let our management team know so they can prepare another dish to your liking. We hope that you will come back and give us another shot to wow you for a five-star experience.
Food, service and ambiance all great. I had the oyster sampler and the broiled flounder with mixed vegetables and jasmine rice. I wasn’t going to have dessert but when they mentioned cheesecake I couldn’t resist.
Frank, thank you for the five star review! We are so glad that we were able to deliver a wonderful experience for you! Thank you for your support during this time and we look forward to serving you soon!
Pleasant comfortable and great service
It was a wonderful meal.
Choose your fish and how it’s prepared is the way to go. The blackened mani magi was a great choice. Very flavorful and moist. The sole francese was good but could have been more flavorful. Great service.
Lovely space with great service but the food is all bland and lacks flavor. We were a party of 6 and 3 of us ordered Hong Kong style fish dishes and we all had the same experience. The dishes had no seasoning other than heavy soy sauce. My son had the fried sole and chips. The piece of fish was very thin and after the deep fry was very dry. The other two entrees were also low on seasoning and flavor.
We were very excited to celebrate a family gathering at City Fish after reading the great reviews but it was a total miss.
great food, great table, great service
Food always fresh, beautifully cooked and plated. Service excellentm
We've been there twice and have enjoyed it each time. Sunday and Monday nights wine bottles under $100 are 50% off! The food is always excellent as is the service. Their bread and butter are to die for, although the last time the bread was a little dry. The staff gladly replaced it asap. Definitely a great place to dine with friends!
Two of us shared scallops with sweet potato mash and veggies, which was plated in the kitchen. It was plenty of food for two women. The restaurant was overbooked and the waiting area was packed upon arrival. We sat at the bar and ordered a shrimp cocktail to have with a drink. It was absolutely not worth it. Four shrimp lying on a plate with a couple of dishes of dip. No style marks and definitely not worth $10. Once we were seated, waiter was great and food was delicious. Not my first time there and will go again
Excellent service and food. I love a round table when I’m with 6 friends.
Lots of fish choices cooked in several ways. Each fish dish comes with two sides. Portions were generous, food tasty and service friendly. Had a table overlooking the lake. A good place to celebrated an occasion.
Lovely open space with delicious seafood dinners. Noise levels got higher as evening procressed, so go early.
Wonderful atmosphere wonderful service and excellent food
We had the pleasure of seating by a window at a table for 4 people. I had the delicious Rainbow Trout. All of us enjoyed our experience and look forward to dining there again.
Maitre d’ was terrific helping us celebrate our wedding anniversary.
Spence the waiter was also really great and very knowledgeable about all menu items.
Enjoyed the meal.
Service was fine
Inside is very noisy.
I will come back
We had a lovely time celebrating an anniversaries. It was pricey so it willl be for special occasion
Food was ok, mine arrived about 10 minutes after everyone else's. The salmon was a bit under done for one person. The daily catch was excellent
Dear Jewels, thank you for leaving feedback about your most recent experience at City Fish Market. We are happy to hear that you chose to dine with us. Anytime you are not 100% happy with a dish, please let our staff now and we will gladly prepare something new for you! We hope that you will come back and give us another shot to wow you for a five-star experience.
Absolutely delicious. Everything was just great, the tuna tartare and salmon spinach salad, fresh and tasty. Our waiter was knowledgeable and ambiance perfect as well. We had a really good time. Thank you.
This was my first time here and I had an amazing experience. Our waitress was fabulous. I have never had mussels so BIG! The King crab legs were heavenly. Everything about this night was perfect. I was also expecting it to be more expensive. The prices are very reasonable. The outside area was closed because it was cold and I watched them accommodate a group that really wanted to sit outside. Even though outside was closed we still had a great view. Thank you for a great night!
We had tempura shrimp to share. Entres of fresh grouper and yellow snapper were fresh and perfectly cooked. One of the best key lime pies ever. Buttery graham crust and nice tart filling. Tasted home made.
City Fish Market offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (561) 487-1600.
City Fish Market is rated 4.5 stars by 4915 OpenTable diners.
City Fish Market does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://secure.buckheadrestaurants.com/.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.