See availability for bonus point tables
Daily 4:00PM - 5:00PM
Food was excellent. Service could be better. Overall pricey. Not ideal for quiet romantic dinner.
Food was great. It was a bit expensive. Good for a special occasion
For the second time in two months our dining experience was a disaster. Service was horrendous!! Waited an hour and a half between appetizer and entree. Both times we were told the kitchen was “overwhelmed.” When the entrees came out the scallops were burned beyond recognition and the swordfish wasn’t cooked through. And our entrees were served by a manager that we complained to about the slow service!! It seemed to me that the quality of the food wasn’t all that important. It was an embarrassing experience because both times we brought friends who had never been to the restaurant.
Since Catch moved from their old space into the old Gotham and became Catch 19 the service, quality and attention to detail has all but disappeared. Never again!! Total amateur operation!!
Great dinner and exceptional service. Ask your server for recommendations and trust what they say!
There were 4 of us, 2 couples Pre-Concert dinner. Atmosphere was nice, Host and Waitress were kind and friendly, especially Athena!!! Athena had a great personality and was very attentive. Food was outstanding. We only ordered 2 different dishes...the guys both ordered the special Surf and Turf, Filet Mignon and Angry Shrimp and Lobster, while the ladies had the scrumptious, buttery Chilean Sea Bass. I would definitely recommend Catch 19 .
Just had a lovely lunch with my friends at Catch we were treated to a great meal that complimented great company!!!! Sorry first review I had stars backwards great place!!!!
Just excellent from the wine to the food to the service!!
Food was just as good when it was Catch next door. And the service was great A J was terrific...she was very friendly
Lamb chops were very fatty and tough. Sesame encrusted tuna with Asian vegetables was good.
We had a fantastic meal. Blackened Swordfish! Holy Cow! Amazing. We own a brewery in town... Red Tank Brewing ... and are always looking for local perfection and Catch 19 is it! Great staff, James is an awesome waiter and Ryan is a fantastic manager.
Great place and even better food. On the more pricey end
Very nice night!
First visit...and we were impressed
We waiting over half an hour for our table to be told that they could only offer a table top at the bar and they didn't know when our table would be ready. The steak was over cooked and the waiter not friendly. Such a big disappointment.
830 reservation, didn’t get main course until 10:15. Cesar salad was wilted Romain from a bag with cheese sprinkled on it. Main courses were ok but waiter mixed up orders
dinner food was outstanding ...waiting "Very" Long for apps and Dinner. Spoke to waiter and blamed the Kitchen. Gave us complementary desert .
Food was great. Service was slow.
Had a wonderful meal. Ordered the Sea Bass which was delicious. My husband had sea scallops and liked them very much as well. We will be going back soon
Great food. Fish is very fresh and drinks were delicious.
Celebrated my mother’s birthday. The food was great, the service was good. Service got a little slow at the end, but it was a busy Saturday evening so it was kind of expected. Definitely would come again.
The food is outstanding and the Angry Shrimp and Lobster appetizer is worth the trip alone. Unfortunately, the noise level is rather high and the recorded background music only served to add more ambient noise to try to converse over.
But, if a high noise level is not an issue, we highly recommend Catch 19 for its excellent food!
Great food, great service, great atmosphere. Everything for this special occasion was great from soup to nuts; all in the party of six raved about the food and wine selection. One minor nitpick, while the deserts were all excellent, the desert selection was limited. Only drawback - and it is a big one - is it is very expensive, and I do mean very expensive. If it is a special occasion and you don't mind dropping big bucks, then there is not a better place to go.
Food was delicious, service not so much. I don't want to have to ask for lemon, repeatedly in a Seafood Restaurant. Had to ask for fresh pepper at every course. At a restaurant like this, that's just a SHAME.
We have not been to Catch 19 since they moved from down the block. We loved it when it was there and was pleasantly surprised at the new place. Very nicely decorated, great bar, and a very satisfying dining experience. The dinner was excellent. We had the Sea Bass and the Swordfish. Both were great. Our server Travis, was also excellent. We will definitely make this one of our go-to places.
My honey and arrived for reservation at five pm. Just kinda a strange "vibe". Not sure
Food was nice Place is very pretty Comfortable We might return Just strange
Arrived sat right away Nice seating location Quiet Pretty
Was asked sparkling water or tap. I chose sparkling girlfriend chose tap. Got water fairly quick from waiter Waiter walked away Never asked if we wanted wine or cocktails. Thought OK maybe not our waiter In a bit maybe a little more than a bit Bread came Restaurant was not busy at all. Not at all. Waiter finally returned It was awhile Enough time that we both were looking around for waiter. Weird vibe Strange feeling. Then waiter finally arrived and asked if we wanted a drink. YEAH! Finally/ Got drink then waiter returned and asked if we were ready to order. We were We did. Then five minutes later waiter at table three over from us was giving guests the specials of the evening. We were not informed of any specials. Maybe we were inconveniencing our waiter. Strange night at dinner. Food was good.
Waiter was out standing! Had absolute knowledge of the menu and threw in appropriate comments describing his favorite dishes and why.
Don't miss the Angry Shrimp and Lobster - great appie to share! All the other seafood was very good and the Cippino was awesome!
Catch 19 has become my family's go-to for Sunday brunch and special occasions. The chef, Dominic Rizzo runs the house with zest and has high standards for everything that leaves the kitchen. For Red Bank, he has set a high bar for dining with entertainment (piano and singers) and solid happy hour pricing. Hoping for a long run for Catch 19 on Broad Street and for Dom so we have our go-to for years to come.
Food was sub par. Service was terrible. Beautiful space, but that was about it. Not a fan.
Excellent food and service. We enjoyed oysters and the crab meat appetizer to start followed by Chilean Sea Bass for me and the Snapper special for my husband. The sea bass was truly outstanding and I highly recommend it. We really appreciated the attentiveness of our server and were also quite surprised to get a phone call from a restaurant manager following our visit to inquire about the quality of our experience. Nice touch!
Cocktails for the table were not served together -
Food was outstanding. Had to wait an hour and a half between appetizer and entree. Server said the kitchen was backed up. I suspect he forgot to put the order into the kitchen. Gave us another bottle of wine on the house. Food as always was outstanding.
Always an amazing meal at Cathch. Travis always goes above and beyond to make our dining experience special. My favorites are Angry Shrimp and Lobster to start and The Brick Chicken for dinner. Never disappoints!!!!
I was tasked with finding a restaurant for a business meeting that would be a bit more upscale and not your "typical" lunch place. We were not disappointed. The food was excellent, waiter was very good. He was just the right amount of attentive without being overbearing and provided explanations when needed. Perfect! We discussed the décor and what a nice job they did. Refreshing not to be in a place that looks like your usual "franchise" type build out. Note: This is not a franchise restaurant. I'm just making a reference. Catch 19 was perfect for our business meeting. I will try it for dinner. I highly recommend.
Excellent restaurant! Michael was outstanding host!
Surf N Turf special is always my favorite. Definitely hard to pass up with such a great menu.
Delicious food and great atmosphere. We had a wonderful experience.
Love this place. The food is soooo good. Staff's friendly and attentive. You should go!