Always enjoy the food and the atmosphere. Last night sat at the best table in the house.. next to the fireplace! A perfect evening.

Great time for our anniversary

Great experience. First time at the restaurant. Everything was amazing. Will definitely go back!

Our family of five really enjoyed our dinner at Casa Rustica. We had been meaning to go there for a couple years and we finally made it. Very tasty food and our waiter was very attentive. Entrees were great, appetizers were awesome (calamari and arancini), bread was delicious. We will definitely go back when we are in the mood for Italian food.

28th Anniversary. 1st time visiting for me. We’ve lived in the area for 25 years.
Great server (Conor). All employees wore masks appropriately.
Restaurant called back to accept changes in reservation (changed from 2 people to 3 people). Slightly bummed that the online reservations asked if the event was for anything special, but no recognition of our anniversary during the dining experience.
Nice experience, good selection for vegetarians. A lot of food. Could easily split entrees w/ someone (up charge for this).
In-person menu was much more vague than the online menu, so I’m glad I’d downloaded the Open Table app to view the menu before visiting.
Husband ordered spaghetti w/ meatballs. Would prefer meatballs w/o veal.. ? Ick. That wasn’t listed on the in-person menu but was online.
My daughter ordered the Six-Cheese Pasta Purse. Plenty left over for another meal. I ordered fettuccine w/ the cacciatore sauce (onions and mushrooms) and added primavera vegetables. Again, PLENTY left over. Slightly spicy?
We also ordered the appetizer of Asiago Pimento dip. Very good!
Overall experience was great. Total bill for three people, two glasses of wine, two beers, one tea, = $105. (Not including tip).
Will definitely visit again.
Happy New Year!
C, K, and R Phillips

Good Italian food and complementary wine pairings in a rustic lodge setting. Family friendly and the noise level was reflective of that. Come later if you want to enjoy a more intimate experience. Server was great. Parking, a little bit more trying.

We read a few negative reviews but decided to try the restaurant anyway and were pleasantly surprised. The food was excellent, server was attentive and our wait was only a few minutes. We would definitely come here again.

We had a reservation and It took over an hour to get food after being seated.
My veal was undercooked and my wife’s salmon was over cooked.
We did get a free desert but it was in a Togo box
Due to COVID the restaurant was way too crowded, and we thought about leaving.
Wish we had left!
Poor all around!

Food was not good, service was better the food but don’t rush to this place.

Good food, recommend the Chicken Parmesan. Dessert was great as well

Very bad service “Briana was our server” we had to ask twice someone else to bring drinks. Briana did not knew the menu so she was not helpfulI. Food was ok my older son asked for a Fillet Mignon that came out 45 min later and on a to go box our waitress thought that was funny. The restaurant did not end up charging us for the stake. Over all experience was not the best. i would think twice to go back to Casa Rústica

We love Casa Rústica. We visit it when ever we are in Boone. The food is delicious and the service is wonderful!

Great food and good portions!

I really hate to give this restaurant a bad review as all are struggling with Covid issues but I have been going here for almost 3 years and it’s always been at least good to excellent. Last week the food was not warm. Almost everyone thought their entree was less than stellar. My husband ordered manicotti, a dish I have ordered many times there. It usually comes in a little boat dish and the manicotti is covered with sauce and cheese. His came on a plate. The manicotti were barely covered with any marinara and no cheese. They looked like they were fried and resembled two starved burritos. I can no longer recommend this restaurant until the standards it once had are put back.

We love this restaurant and reserve a table for Sunday night about every 2 weeks. We always look forward to our evening at Casa Rustica.

So delicious!

Great service and the food was very good. Great combinations and choices. Not the best we've ever had but definitely worth a visit.

We often dine at Casa Rustica due to location near where we stay when we are in the area. This time we made a reservation due to COVID. Our seating location was excellent, service was outstanding and we never had to ask for anything. Food is always consistent, tables were adequately spaced due to covid restrictions. It was a very nice dining experience!

We requested a table by the fireplace and that is exactly where we were seated ! The restaurant is a log cabin and was just beautiful. Everything we ordered was delicious and the portions were very large. We were pleasantly surprised when we received our bill since it was half of what we would have paid anywhere else. We will surely return when in the Boone area.

We liked it so much we went back two nights in a row. Great service and fantastic food!

This was our first time here and it did not disappoint. From the shareable appetizer to the starter, dinner, and fabulous dessert, everything was so delicious. We will definitely be back soon.

We celebrated our 55th wedding anniversary. It was our first time dinning at this restaurant. The service and food were excellent .We certainly picked the right place for our celebration.

Everyone was masked and more protective measures in place! I’m immune compromised, but felt very safe eating there.

Food and service are always great and that night was no exception.

Food was solid, but not spectacular! Good.value for the money, however!

Great place! We actually ate there two nights in a row!

Very charming and cozy place. Love the mountain atmosphere. First time in Boone with family and friends. We definitely will visit again. We order the Shrimp/scallop on vodka sauce and Seafood Fra Daviolo..uff the best with a little kick and calamari friti. Excellent service. Strongly recommend.

Nice Place for a Casual dinner, prices are good close to Marriott

This place is not fancy, just an everyday restaurant. We had to reorder an appetizer twice and it still wasn’t what we ordered but we gave up at that point. The meal was good but not remarkable. Probably wouldn’t return next time I’m in the area.

Been coming here for twenty years, whenever I visit Boone. Always consistent great Italian food. Everyone in our party was very happy with the flavor and had great portions, only made me sad as I was too stuffed to have dessert. Good Covid protocols, which I appreciate right now.

Food was just ok. Waitress was new and tried hard.

Delicious!

Did not expect such a nice Italiano menue in Boone. I was pleasantly surprised and I even challenged them with a Gluten free pasta with clams. Everything was spot on !

I've eaten here several times, and the food and service are always great.

Food took a while to come out but it was good. The bartender was new and very slow. A decent choice

We have eaten here many times and it was great. This time, the place was packed, denser than any restaurant we have been in in 8 months. Compared to Stonewall at Banner Elk, this was way too many people. The prices were inflated and the quantity was skimpy. The noise level was so high it drove us out. I doubt if we will ever be back.

Fantastic experience as always. Ricky Pedroni continues on the legacy his father, Peter Pedroni, began almost 40 years ago. He’s has kept what made Casa great and has placed his mark and makes it “greater”. There’s no weakness here, service, atmosphere, food and the total value are unrivaled. Looking forward to getting back.

This place was hitting on every level....food and service. A reasonably priced wine list. Seemed like a family owned restaurant where the owners care deeply about the food and total experience.

Highly recommended.

Food was great, but took atleast 20 minutes for our drink order....another 20 for our food order!

Great food, service and ambiance

YES THEY HAVE A GOOD SELECTION OF PLATES, THE AMBIANCE IS AS GOOD AS WE CAN GET WITH ALL THE COVID-19 RESTRICTIONS, FOOD WAS GOOD, WINE SELECTION SO SO,