The ambience was warm and cozy. our server Rogers was very professional and went out of his way to see if we could have the muscles prepared to our liking in white wine. the drinks and food met our expectation and all in all it was a wonderful dining experience
The food was very good and the staff was very attentive. My family and I enjoyed our dining experience very much!
The guacamole is made fresh and to your taste. The other entrees were properly prepared and satisfying. A solid place to go when you're in the neighborhood.
Went here for my husband birthday. We really enjoyed the food! Delicious. Service was great especially using ipads to see the menu!
The food honestly was really not that great... I expected more...
Everything was great at Casa Pepe from the staff to the food. We enjoyed ourselves & will be back.
Service was great. However the food was disappointing and it was so.erhing I could easily cook myself at home and even better. Nothing special and tasteless.
Great food, great service!! We will be back!! Had a great time...
Visiting family in Brooklyn we use to eat at Casa Pepe years ago remembered great Spanish food. ordered many appetizers and guacamole waiter less then thrilled to make it and no chips to eat it? we all ordered paella with lobster not great. Many drinks with very little alcohol in them?!? we all left completely sober didn't need our DD at all?!? 6 people and we realized they tacked on a 18% gratuity to bad we were giving them 20%......you just can't go back sometimes
The food and service at Casa Pepe were impeccable.
The food is always excellent, but before you order your second drink just take a look at the price.
Great drinks but a little pricey.
Seems like it is under new management. Didn't honor their advertised pre-fixe dinner. Portions small. Will not go back.
We went for our son's birthday, was very nice. Food was good and plentyfull, everyone enjoyed their meals. Sangria was delicious. The service was good, but the servers could have smiled a little more. One thing I was unhappy with, they charge for soda refills. That was annoying.
From start to finish everything was great. The drinks were made to perfection. The food was tasty. Everyone (15 of us) enjoyed their meals. Raymond, our waiter, was great. This was our first time at Casa Pepe and we are already planning our return trip.
Casa pepe is a great, reliable restaurant. Whether I want Mexican or Spanish food, I am never disappointed. The staff is great for celebrations and parties. Also the brunch is fantastic
The restarant tries to pass cheap truck food for gourmet food. The menu does not match what you actually get. Good drinks, horrible food.
Love Casa Pepe! Been coming here since the 80's. When I'm in the mood for awesome spanish food...this is where I choose!
This place is super weird and over priced. We were the only people in there on a Saturday night. Food is just ok, not worth what it costs.
I enjoy coming to this place. The staff is nice and the food is delicious. Their drinks are on point and they are very accommodating.
I've been going there for years so I guess that speaks for itself.
We enjoyed the service, the ambiance, the delicious food and the value for the price. I highly recommend this restaurant.
The food and the service were great! The prices were very reasonable and the sangria was outstanding! Every dish ordered was great, and the table side guacamole was a nice touch. Free valet is always a plus as well!
Great food, fun atmosphere. Big portions, very attentive staff.
A steady mainstay in the area. Consistent, and won't disappoint.
I always enjoy eating at Casa Pepe. The food is delicious, the staff is friendly and courteous, nice decor and good music.
Excellent food lobster grilled Octopus
Very good service I will go back again. Food was delicious. Family had a great time 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
A nice place to enjoy good food in a pleasant environment.
Everything was fine but the quality of the food are decresed because I been customer for 20 years
GPS put me totally out of the way, but I'm so happy that we found it. The food was delicious and so were the marguaritas! I would highly recommend the porkchops. The shrimp was also very good. I will definitely return!
portions are very small, drinks are watery and pricey.
This restaurant was so incredibly rude. We had reservations for 8 and arrived promptly. To be seated at a table near the kitchen. One table was round and one was square. Which logically makes no sense. I wouldn't recommend them or return ever.
Food is always good here. Sangria is a must have. The appetizers portion was smaller than in past visits. But still worth the visit.
I went there for Valentines Day dinner . It had a very good pre set menu. The food was delicious and plentiful. Real Lobster in the Paella. Drinks were not to strong, I would have liked it stronger for the price but over all we had a great time. I would definitely go there for a girls night out
Good food, wonderful servics
The arroz con pollo is very good and the fried ice cream is to die for. We went for brunch, since it looked inviting on their website. When we got there the waiter told us they no longer serve brunch. I don't know when they stopped but I told the waiter it's still on the website. That was on 11/8 -- it's now 11/12 and the website still says they have brunch.
We enjoyed the guacamole being made in front of us at our desired spice level. Drinks were great and made exactly the way we like them. Our food came quick and well prepared. We enjoyed it. We went on the night of game 3 of the World Series so it was a little loud when the cheers from next the dining room. But that's expected. I'm sure it'll be quiet when we return.
Not what it used to be. Although the appetizers were good, the Paella was barely edible. We added the Lobster option thinking it'd be a great plate, but all of the Seafood had clearly been frozen. The Lobster had a smell to it, and the Shrimp (normally my favorite item) were just not edible. That said, the service was good, in fact very good, and the Sangria is always great, but the quality of the food ingredients has dropped off significantly, and that will cause me to avoid Casa Pepe in the future. I hope the owners bring back the old history by bringing back the old quality, but until then I'll opt for other choices in Bay Ridge, especially at $55pp before tip (1 half pitcher of Sangria, 2 appetizers, 2 main courses and 1 shared dessert).
I have always wanted to try casa pepe and Finally got the chance to, lets start with the good our server was ok and did his Job. now the bad, food was down right dated and lacked quality seems like they cut alot of corners with the seafood and vegatables and used the cheapest produce available. paella tasted like vigo rice packet with tons of butter and salt to compenaate. shrimp was tiny and slimy with no real texture. grilled octopus was very fishy and over cooked very off putting. "chef salad" used low quality feta cheese with evan worse canned olives you can taste the metallic aftertaste. had dessert that was no better the coffee was burnt and watered down there was not one thing I ate that can redeem this place. .I can see how this place could have passed for decent in the 90s I would of given food no stars
The food was excellent. We loved their quacamole and I really loved the seafood with garlic sauce. When I presented the $20 open table dining check, I don't really believe the waiter knew what to do with it. He gave me my check but did not deduct the $20. I had to explain what to do with it. He kept saying "We will give it to you" which made no sense. Was he going to give me $20 back in cash or just keep the dining check and not do anything with it?????