Book your next event with us
Steak was excellent. Crab legs seemed like they were frozen and didn’t meet my expectations. Cocktails were so so. Caesar Salad and Tuna Tartar were solid. Lighting was bad as we were in the corner and it was hard to read menu.
Favorite restaurant I’ve ever been to. I keep coming back for more. 😊
Everything was incredible!!!
The steaks are delicious and so was the steak tartare and the truffled mashed potatoes
Food and service both outstanding. Best steak in Milwaukee
It was a get together to celebrate a belated birthday with very good friends! Thanks for the wonderful desserts!
Great food and atmosphere, always one of our favorites!
Carnevor had delivious tasting food. I had the roasted bone marrow, marinated bacon, and dry age new york steak. All very tasty. Definitely recommend going here for sure.
Always a great evening spent at this restaurant. If you want the best service request Stan!!
The only slight flaw was the chewy calamari. Everything else was perfection! The domestic Wagu was sooo flavorful! Great service, great food!
This was our first time at Carnevor and the experience was very good. The steak and Ahi Tuna were both outstanding. The service was attentive and very professional. Carnevor has definitely earned a place on our “preferred restaurants” list.
Service was informative. Atmosphere was great and most importantly the food was incredible. We ordered the 20 oz ribeye with mini potatoes and the tomato mozzarella salad. Flavors were amazing! Hands down best steak we have ever had.
Food was amazing, but the bathroom was dirty and almost out of toilet paper.
Beyond outstanding. I had the Mishima boneless rib-eye which just tasted perfect. Great texture. Love the herb Garlic butter, shitaki reserve and waygu jus toppings o. Mmmmm
great menu and perfectly cooked steaks! only problem was the use of too much salt on everything including the asparagus. wine selection outstanding and service top notch.
Best steakhouse I've ever been to. Staff was excellent, food was wonderful, and prices were appreciate. Only complaint was it was a little dark inside. Still had a beautiful interior and great ambiance
Took my wife here on a date because we love meat! The decor made us feel like we were in a cave about to devour our kill, it was wonderful! The food was a bit on the expensive side, but the quality was definitely there! Big ol bone in ribeye was the perfect choice for how the decor was! Definitely in my top 10 steaks
Dry aged NY Strip is amazing. Cooked perfectly. Calamari is fantastic.
Food was excellent overall, my steak was too done vs what I ordered. The server and manager made it right and we're great about the situation.
Food was amazing and so was our server. They were very personable and everyone made sure to wish me a happy birthday. Just overall GREAT! I’ll definitely be dining in again. Thank you for making my night.
This place was beautiful. The ambiance was incredible very nice darker lighting really makes it for a nice date place. The bar was amazing and the bartemders and servers were all very nice and punctual. The wagyu steak I ordered was the best ive ever had and they gave us a desert for me ajd my girls one year anniversary. That was very nice. Im recommending this spot to everyone I know.
Excellent steak and great service. Try the donuts for dessert and you won't be disappointed.
Outstanding food and wine. Ambiance is great. Waitstaff very attentive and competent.
If you’ve never been, do yourself a favor and go! Yes, it may be a splurge night out, but Carnevor delivers on every note! Service, selection, quality, vibe. They hit it on all points! Treat yourself to a fantastic dining experience!
Did not appreciate the constant roaming of host/hostess obviously checking the status of diners. It's a small enough dining area and would be more tactful for them to ask the waiter/waitress. Did not feel comfortable enjoying meal or even finishing up with a cup of coffee with staff watching you!!
The food was decent, but over priced for what it was. Our server was wonderful.
My boyfriend and I have been here 4x, and they never disappoint us. Best experience ever overall. I highly recommend!
Special day with my son
This is the only place that comes to mind for an expensive steak dinner in Milwaukee. Never have I been disappointed here and I doubt I ever will be. The Wine Sommelier picked a perfect wine for what My fiance requested. His choice was perfect wine for dinner with a approachable price., considering the extensive collection they have available.
Johnny Cash - Ring of Fire
Poor lighting, extremely loud, overly enthusiastic cleaning crew constantly asking if we were done with our food. Food was maybe a bit overpriced for its quality
Standing at bar waiting to be seated, employees off shift taking up seats and drinking with a colleagues who was drunk. Dinner was okay, steak was overcooked and the server never told us about specials for the night. Not what I expected at Carnevor. And the person who was over served at the bar came over to say hi to my date and fell in front of our table, not cool at all
As usual an outstanding experience from the bar to the front of the house to the food and service. Exceptional meal.
Very attentive wait staff without being over bearing. The filet was incredible as were the Alaskan King crab legs. We will definitely go back -
This was our first time and it was our 11th anniversary, they sat us right in the middle when there open tables all around made it very uncomfortable for me and my wife, the waiter wasnt very greeting, when asked her to explain the special for the day she got an attitude about it. The steak was great but the sides were horrible never told us the mac and cheese was made with blue cheese and the double bake potato had corn it. Would not go here again.
Steaks were perfectly cooked, tuna tart a d steak tartar were delicious. Great service
Delish steak, bread and butter. Everything was perfection!
Very good meal, excellent service