As one of Wisconsin’s most acclaimed fine dining destinations, Carnevor creates a premier dining experience featuring exquisite steaks and an extensive wine list with more than 750 selections. Carnevor has private and semi-private dining options for cocktail hours or formal dinners for up to 30 guests.View Private Dining Details
The whole meal, as always, was exceptional! Carnevor never disappoints!
Great meat!!!! Super service! Love the incredible desserts. Old school. It is a little loud but no biggie
Was our 25th wedding anniversary for which we got a complimentary desert which was excellent
Our go to place for date night!
Appetizers and entrees were amazing!! Probably the worse service I have gotten there, though.
Never offered to get us another drink, unless we asked. Never asked what sauce we wanted for our steaks and just brought out what he thought was good. When I was always asked, prior visits.
Good dinner, little pricy for two but had a good time, enjoyed the octopus, the spanish wine and the mushrrooms were very good. Steak asked for medium and got it medium well but ok.
Amazing food. Atmosphere is nice, but it can get a bit loud when the restaurant is full. Either way, excellent dinner.
Extraordinary, as always!
Excellent beef. Always good. Large portions.
Gina, Fred and GM-Brad are all wonderful hosts!
Carnevor is a great steak place. It started with a very nice loaf of warm house made bread. Then a nice salad. The 45 day dry aged new york strip had excellent flavor, just a little more fat could have been trimmed from the outside. Carmelized brussel sprouts were great. My companion had the wet aged strip special which was also very good. Of note, most steak places slightly undercook for rare, medium, etc. Carnevor exactly as ordered. The decor is very interesting too
Carnevor was once again just fabulous! My favorite steakhouse in the city. Our waiter Will was amazing as always and Brad took good care of us as well.
Always a great choice for a special occasion! Excellent food, a terrific staff, and an overall awesome experience!
Best steak I every had hands down.. i thought WARDS was the best until I ate at carnevor.. will be seeing me again
We had a great meal and our server was fantastic. Only complaint would be the noise level. A bit tough to have a nice conversation with your partner. Other than that everything was top shelf!
My son wanted to go to Carnevor for his 17th bday. Our experience was wonderful! Our server was so nice and accommodating, as well as pleasant with a great personality. Our drinks were delicious and our food was just as delicious! We can't wait to go back!
The food is outstanding. The steaks are the best and the side dishes are extraordinary. Service is friendly and excellent. Expensive but great value.
A great meal as always. The service is fantastic and the steaks are cooked perfectly. Excellent wine section. Highly recommend!
Very good steak, my favorite in Milwaukee. The Brussels sprout side was just ok.
It was our daughter’s birthday dinner. Will took great care of us and we had another fabulous dinner. We love celebrating all our special occasions at Carnivore! Than you, Will for the best night ever!!!
The new setting is a significantly more snug that the former location but the space overall looks like it sits quite a few more people. While the overall experience was top notch the seating arrangements we are bit claustrophobic particularly with the all the dark wood.
I would say good for groups and special occasions, less so for a romantic dinner out.
Had a 6PM reservation and was seated right on time. Will was our waiter and informed us of all the specials and gave us a great explanation of everything on the menu. My wife and son started with salad and I had the lobster bisque. Excellent soup with chunks of lobster. My wife had a filet with scallops, my son had the domestic Wagu beef, and I had the 20oz. wet aged N.Y. strip. All the steaks were prepared exactly how we ordered them and were tender and flavor full. We were celebrating our Son's 20th birthday and Will was kind enough to add homemade donuts for dessert, nice touch.
First and foremost, the steak ranks up there with the best I have had. The wine list is extensive with a good price spread and excellent selection. Staff was very knowledgeable and prompt.
Our server was great but the noise level was extremely high by other patrons near us. Our meal was average for the price. We would not return.
One of my favorites. Always great food and service!!
Great location, great decor and delicious food. The steaks were great, and cooked to true rating. The sides are delicious and inventive. Put it on your list.
Every thing about this restaurant is amazing. Food is extremely delicious, service is great. We loved our time here.
Food was fantastic and great service. Server was attentive and patient. My bone in filet was cooked perfectly as ordered and extremely flavorful.
Food was decent, but for the prices there is alot better in the area.
We went for anniversary and arrived before our reservation and got seated before our reservation and it took us 1 hour to get our appetizers and another hour to get our entrée. Was disappointed in how slow it was, but the food was excellend.
One if the best steaks and salmon I've ever tasted
Excellent experience all around. Will definitely be back
Excellent service, food was very very good little on the pricey side but over all worth it. We will be returning! Loved our waitress she was awesome
Wonderful steaks. Friendly and highly attentive service!
They went the extra mile to make my boyfriend’s birthday very special
Great food and excellent service. Second time here and will be back for a third.
Awesome experience as usual!!! Stan is amazing. Always provides A+++++ service!!
Great portion sizes and the food was delicious! I will definitely go back!
Literally the best steak I have had in years! Each dish was prepared perfectly! My hat's off to the head chef and the entire kitchen staff. The entire staff went out of their way to make for a wonderful dining experience.
Outstanding food, service, and environment....highly recommend!
My expectations based on other reviews are read were high. However I was somewhat disappointed with the food. The bacon appetizer we we're told takes the longest and it was very overdone when it arrived. My husband's lobster bisque had an extremely fishy flavor and was gritty with some type of spice. His steak was done great however my veal chop was over cooked. The dessert was the best part of the meal. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was romantic and sexy. I just wish the food was better given the amount of money you pay.