Carnevor

Amazing service, outstanding food, the perfect date night.

AMAZING FOOD

Outstanding experience, as always.

My first experience was good! We didn’t care for our potatoes much but the steak was great, service was superb! I like the ambiance and we were seated right away with our reservation

Food and service was absolutely amazing! The best steak I've ever eaten.

Awesome food and our server was amazing!!! We would love to go back again.

Great steak! The Caesar salad is the best I’ve had. A bit pricey but definitely worth every dime. My favorite steakhouse

Carnevor serves the best steak in Milwaukee. We celebrated my wife’s 5 years of being cancer free. Our server Fred was great and everyone made my wife feel special. She had a ribeye and I had a filet with crab legs. Outstanding!

Always a great experience with spectacular food, drinks, and ambiance.

Absolutely one of the best steaks I have ever had! Excellent service and drinks! I would definitely recommend. We WILL return.

Amazing service without a doubt. Everyone there knows how to handle guests and they are on their toes 100% of the time. Of course, its not cheap but you know that going in. If you want a fabulous experience this is the place

We go every year for our son’s birthday. We loved our waitress and waiter-it made the night perfect. The staff is top notch and very attentive. The steaks are simply the best! Thank you-see you next year!

The staff there was so friendly and the food was amazing! 10/10 will come here again.

Amazing food, service & ambiance. Also worth noting that the safety protocols where efficient and followed precisely.

It was a bit loud couldn’t hear the waitress......

Excellent food but the customer service was not very enjoyable, especially for a soecial occasion. Disappointing.

Service and Food was amazing. Easily the best steak in the area. Our server was amazing and very attentative to what we were looking for.

Our waiter Eric was amazing! We definitely will be scheduling another reservation in the near future.

First time at Carnevor. Everything from the initial contact through the dessert was excellent. Eric, our waiter was great. The food was incredible. I had the 20oz Ribeye and my wife had the 5oz Wagyu filet. Both were phenomenal. Drinks were great, ambiance was great. No complaints. Will definitely be back.

service and food were excellent

Fantastic food and great atmosphere. Would definitely go again

Great food, drink, and service! Everything was delicious.

The service started out amazing, starting with the valet, to the hostess, to the server. The food was phenomenal. The only complaint was there was an extremely rowdy table in our section and it sort of took away from the otherwise positive experience.

Fantastic! Set in a pleasantly dark, cozy environment we were waited on by staff that used our names and made us feel right at home. And the FOOD! At a place named 'Carnevor', you expect great steak, and both the Domestic Waygu and Filet Mignon were beyond expectations. Apps of bone marrow and thick-cut bacon were so good, we almost didn't care if the steaks even came out! And the truffle mash and risotto sides were also delicious. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

Everything was amazing! People who are concerned about social distancing, etc should feel very safe here. Many tables have been removed so all dining parties are at least 6 feet apart.

It was amazing!!

Amazing! I can highly recommend

The meal was just excellent. Very good service and the atmosphere was pleasant. The noise level was moderate to low and we enjoyed our dinner and conversation without needed to raise our voices. Overall the experience was tremendous.

We really enjoyed our time at Carnivore. We are avid steakhouse goers, this was our first time at Carnivore. We will happily come back.

Outstanding as always! We were greeted by Mark and welcomed back! Eric was an amazing waiter and his attention to service was excellent! The food, wine and ambiance were amazing! To welcome us back they offered a complementary desert! To the entire team we say thank you!

It had been eight months since my last visit due to COVID. I was really excited and looking forward to finally eating at Carnevor. I ordered a med filet and received a very well done filet. The recooked filet came back near raw. The general manager who is a very nice guy offered to cook another one by then the experience was not very good I just settle for the near raw filet. The general manager didn’t charge me for the filet but I was very disappointed that the experience was not good. I live in Fond du lac so I don’t get down there often. I always believe in another chance but the expense to drive that far I will have to think before I make a another reservation. Just being honest as the staff at Carnevor is awesome...

It is rare to find a place where the steak is evenly cooked. Wet aging it certainly helps, but what happens in the kitche is key.

The shitake reduction sauce was not particularly shitake-ish, possibly for adding too much of whatever reduced it (wine) or because it was prepared in well in advance. A VERY minor flaw. I cannot wait to return.

Must go for a date night, or nice adult convo, in Milwaukee!

You can't go wrong with the Dry-aged NY Strip, but be prepared to pause your conversation, because, really, you'll need a moment with just you and your steak.

Fabulous dining experience. The food and service was excellent.

Best atmosphere, steaks, and fine dining experience in Milwaukee!!

The service was amazing and the food was just as spectacular. Will definitely go back here to dine again.

Great ambiance & food was delicious! Always go back for a special occasion!

From the manager personally greeting us and the kind attentive care you expect at an upscale restaurant, Carnevore did not disappoint. The food was mouthwateringlly delicious from start to finish, and dessert was just as amazing. Just moved to Wisconsin and this has become my new favorite place to eat. I plan to bring everyone here.

Ask them to go light on the seasoning on the stakes. It’s a bit too salty for our liking. Been like that for our last couple visits, but since we only go once a year we forgot to ask for light seasoning.