Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

Commentaires sur le restaurant Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC de personnes qui y ont mangé. Selon des cotes récentes.

1. S

   Sarah

   Londres2 commentaires

   4.0

   Y est allé il y a 1 jour

   1. Cote globale 4
   2. Nourriture 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Very nice, large portions which was explained by the waiter. We ordered more than we needed.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

2. G

   Gabriel

   New York City3 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 1 jour

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Delicious, and quick service as always. This is my go to Italian restaurant in NYC.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

3. M

   Mayela

   San Francisco1 commentaire

   4.0

   Y est allé il y a 2 jours

   1. Cote globale 4
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Delicious family style dishes. We had waaay too much food. Be sure to come hungry and ready to wait a bit to be seated, the place is always packed but well worth it.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

4. J

   Jennifer

   Géorgie côtière5 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 2 jours

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Lots of food we over ordered, everything was great.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

5. N

   Nelson

   Côte centrale californienne2 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 2 jours

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Take care when ordering, everything is very good there but very big too.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

6. M

   Manuel VIP

   México2 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 2 jours

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   Be aware that the size of the servings is BIGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

7. M

   Megan VIP

   Grand Boston1 commentaire

   4.0

   Y est allé il y a 3 jours

   1. Cote globale 4
   2. Nourriture 3
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 4

   Food was okay, not great. Portions are HUGE so a great place to share. Really enjoyed the cocktails as well.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

8. M

   Mark

   Philadelphie 7 commentaires

   2.0

   Y est allé il y a 3 jours

   1. Cote globale 2
   2. Nourriture 1
   3. Service 2
   4. Ambiance 2

   I was very disappointed in the quality of some of the items we received. The Chicken Parmigana had only a little sauce and cheese over a McDonald's McChicken patty, the Lobster Fra Diavolo was not spicey, the lobster was overcooked and dry, the penne a la vodka with chicken had only a little chicken and flavorless vodka sauce. Been a long time customer since Carmine's opened and the food has gone downhill. Won't be returning.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

9. C

   Cynthia

   Washington DC9 commentaires

   5.0

   Y est allé il y a 3 jours

   1. Cote globale 5
   2. Nourriture 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiance 5

   My husband and I came here Saturday May 3, 2025. Our server was wonderful. As others have stated, portions are huge and served family style on large platters. Best to come with at least four other people with entrees that look like they could feed six people. Prices appear high for each entree and other food items because they feed so many. We had the eggplant parmesan and mixed green salad. Both were huge portions and excellent. We had a table of five next to us who could not finish the same salad we had to give you an idea of the portion size. Unless you have more people with you or a way to refrigerate and heat up leftovers, it may not be worth it for you because there will be a lot of food wasted. We were headed to a play and staying in a hotel without a way to reheat food so wasted a lot. While we loved the food and service, we would only return if bringing more people with us so the food is not wasted.
   

   Ce commentaire est-il utile?

10. M

    Michele

    Detroit 1 commentaire

    5.0

    Y est allé il y a 3 jours

    1. Cote globale 5
    2. Nourriture 4
    3. Service 5
    4. Ambiance 5

    Hostess staff was wonderful on Sat nite - very accommodating and met our reservation on time. They gave us a lovely spot - and being my visiting niece is mobility-challenged - it was so respectful! Thank you. Our waiter was outstanding! We had theater tickets and he made sure that our entire experience was well timed and enjoyable! The only concern was that we ordered mixed seafood ($100) over pasta and the single lobster tail was open, the meat was missing and not in the sauce - although our waiter assured us that it was. The mixture contained a few clams, a few mussels, some shrimp and 2 crab legs. We didn’t pursue this but you may want to note to the kitchen for future reference as the gentleman dining next to us ordered the same dish (but with the red sauce) and his order was overflowing with seafood! Our dish had about 1/4 of the seafood that this single diner was enjoying! We spoiled my niece with a chocolate dessert and even shared it with the older man next to us! A floor manager came by to check on our experience and we shared that it was wonderful! Thank you for keeping Carmines in business! I have been enjoying the upper west side location for many years!
    

    Ce commentaire est-il utile?