Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

Excellent food. Attentive staff.

Wow! Each plate is large enough for 2-4 people to share and it was the best Italian food I’ve ever had. So good!

Great service and food!

Fabulous food and service, as always! There’s a reason this place is still going strong almost three decades since opening - many reasons, in fact!

This was our second visit and we will not go back. I’m not sure what the appeal is? The service was not friendly. Our granddaughters meal came out way before ours. We paid $16 for garlic bread that was burnt. Pasta dish was marginal. Sat under a huge ceiling fan that was on high which made the food cold and us uncomfortable. Meal cost $150 without alcohol or desert. Very poor experience overall.

Food was fantastic! Very good value! Definitely plan on a return visit!

A member of our party was in a wheelchair the staff couldn’t have been more helpful, pleasant, and respectful. We wanted for nothing! Everyone was so attentive and genuinely nice!

Great service and food! Recommend to all... Enjoy! Bring your appetite.

Amazing per usual

Great food and nice environment. Carmines is always a restaurant that we like to visit when we come to New York and it is some of the best Italian food we have had outside of Italy!

The food was delicious and the service was incredible. Our waiter was helpful in assuring that we did not order too much food from the family style menu.

The prices might turn away some at first, but the plates are made to split with each other (2 or 3 ways). This was, by far, the best Italian food I’ve ever had. Got the lasagna and spaghetti bolognese.

An emblematic restaurant in Times Square area.
Go!

Family style service with lots of food. Service staff was exceptional, food average - had to send back entree because it was cold. QRestaurant was rather loud.

Every time my daughter and I go to the city we ALWAYS eat here. It is our favorite place to eat. We have also been to the one in Vegas and Atlantic City!!! NEVER had a bad dish at any of the location !!!!

Staff was friendly! Able to share one dish so the price was cheap. Wonderful food!

We had a fantastic time in NYC this past weekend with family and friends! Dinner at carmine's was wonderful. I would always return!

Great food... Great service.., Rest Rooms could use upgrades to match 5-Star quality of this restaurant...

The service and food were great. Calling it family style us a little misleading, I thought each dish was enough for 2 the most..

This is a classic Italian restaurant in New York City and we've been there several times. We enjoy the family style dining and the atmosphere is great. The place is always packed and lively. The food is delicious.

The food at Carmine’s was delicious. However, the service and the price will prohibit a return visit. The waiter never took a drink order and refilled our water glasses (on a 100 degree day) once. He did not remove the dirty forks from the appetizer course and replace them with clean ones for the entree. The $39.00 shrimp fra Diavlo dish came with a $12 upsell to include pasta. This was unfortunate because we found the food enjoyable but not the overall experience.

Always a great family style meal here. All the food was delicious and the service was excellent too. Would recommend to anyone looking for quality Italian food!

Outstanding as always! From host to our waiter to the delicious food and drinks! This place never disappoints.

Well, it was a fantastic place but, it wasn’t what I would have expected. Pasta contained some raw noodles. Our waiter was great but, absent a lot. The ambiance was nice except for the seat I was sitting in, that was broken and tarnished from time-after-time use. It was our first visit.

Amazing food and fantastic service!! We had the Carmine’s salad, manicotti and meatballs! Soooo good!!! We will be back for sure!!!

It was a great experience. We arrived prior to our reservation time and the host was able to accommodate us, which was helpful as it was quite busy. The food, ambience and service was amazing. Would definitely return and recommend to others!

Cute restaurant with delicious food and friendly service. Huge portions - one plate is good for at least two people. Authentic Italian, flavorful food.

The food was outstanding! I couldn’t believe how delicious the stuffed mushrooms were and we got the Friday special, sooo yummy. Our server was wonderful, very informative and kind, on top of everything. Overall great experience! Will definitely be back to try new things.

My husband and I use to come to this restaurant. We love the food specially the linguine white clam sauce. It’s our favorite!!! This time, we went with my grandmother and my aunts. I was so glad that they loved it too. The liked the ambiance, decoration, service, food, etc. Every time we have the opportunity, we like to bring our family to this place. We know that they will like it as well. Thank you Carmine’s

No. Food isn't that great and service was not good. UWS location is much better.

Mucha gente, pero la comida estaba muy buena y el ambiente, años 30, muy logrado

Très bon, rapport qualité prix excellent.
Une bonne ambiance mais un peu bruyant !

What a great experience and the best Italian dinner we’ve had. Will go again.

LOVE Carmine’s. Great food, great deal. Totally fabulous. A must do! Have to book this place at least two weeks in advance though because it’s that good!!!

It was wonderful!

Busy Friday night and we waited an extra 20 mins past our reservation time with standing space becoming very limited. We were happy to get to our table where we met our 2 excellent and charming servers. We order ordered sharing dishes and the food was perfect. Excellent value for money at this vivacious family restaurant.

Service was slow and poor but the food was good. If you are in a hurry don’t come here.

The food and the service were great! Carmine’s never disappoints.

Our dinner was delicious and the family style meal is such a great idea! Our server was awesome and I will definitely be back!

Always a great and plentiful meal! The food is good and the service was excellent. I had a reservation and we came early. Carmine's accommodated us even though they were nearly full. Every time we go to NY we go to Carmine's!! Always worth it!