Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
Book your next event with us
The food was good but the place was busy which I believe affected the service level. I give it five stars because of the food
Just a bit cramped with seating
Perfect ambience for time of year and the chicken romana was outstanding.
As Always,Food Was Awesome!!! We never visit NYC Without dining at Carmine’s!!!
Just over the top terrific! Had carbonara and meatballs, lovely drinks (big) SUPERB service, festive, fun, great introduction to NYC!!!
Fabulous food , very big family portions . Good price Lovely welcome , fast service
Wonderful atmosphere, AMAZING food and loved our waiter Larry!
Had to wait 30 minutes past our reservation in a very cramped loud waiting area. Once we were finally sat we had amazing service and amazing food. It was worth the wait.
Carmine's is a great restaurant for large groups. The food is served family style and is delicious! Unfortunately the service we received was not amazing. We were served our appetizers before we had received water, let alone our drinks that we ordered. We ate most of our appetizers before finally flagging down a server to bring us some water. The food was all brought quickly, but service in between such as having drinks, olive oil or bread at the table were lacking.
Carmine’s never disappoints!!! Reservations should be made in advance versus walking into Carmine’s without a reservation. Food is delicious. Portions are large. Prices on high side but then again, it’s NYC!!!
Wonderful in every way
Had a Christmas lunch with friends- was seated very quickly at a great table!!! Jonas was very attentive. Food good as usual-
Most festive- o e if my favorite spots ever!!!!
Will return this week.
Always a great experience. Carmine’s never disappoints!
Everyone and everything was great especially the food there was a lot of it and it was delicious
Fantastic atmosphere and terrific portions. Best suited for parties of 3 or more due to size of portions. Food was very good also.
So happy finally got to Carmine’s!! Had early reservation so was not crowded when we got there...by the time we finished was very crowded...food and service were both excellent...beautiful, festive decorations...got us in the Christmas spirit!
Wonderful! Fantastic! Delish! Amazing!
Food and atmosphere was amazing!
Had a salad from the specials menu and Meatballs with Angel Hair pasta. Food was delicious! Portions are huge.
We spent a great night in Carmine's restaurant. When we arrived they took our reservation information and we wait like 10 minutes. Then we had our table in the 2nd floor, I think it's much better than downstairs, and everything was perfect. Great service, the food was OMG, you can share 1 for 2, and the taste PERFECT. BTW, the Christmas decorations are so beautiful. So, definitely I would recommend it and I'll go again.
Very lively, waiters friendly and food plentiful! Very popular - best to book beforehand.
We had a FANTASTIC time at Carmine’s for my little girl’s 10th birthday celebration! We made reservations and were seated almost immediately at a perfect spot overlooking the room. The service was great, the food was spot on, the ambience was fun and casual and friendly, and the price was really reasonable! We will absolutely visit again next time we are in NYC!
Husband and wife date from Tulsa Ok.
Always a great experience!
Beautifully decorated, awesome food, drinks are overpriced, waiter was just ok, forgot about us but paying more attention to the larger tables. Super crowded & super noisy. Disappointed that you can’t request a specific table even months in advance. Even when you tell the host you’re willing to wait they yes you to death & sit you anywhere they want anyway. Might return but not in December.
Wonderful atmosphere and service. Recommendations were great - absolutely wonderful experience
Food was pretty good... nothing spectacular for the price. Wish they had half portions. They wouldn’t even provide us mozzarella cheese for my pasta because I didn’t order it in advance. My only choice was the Parmesan on the table . They don’t care because they know they will get the business no matter what.
Larry CHARLES was our awesome waiter...thank you!
Salad for 2 was far too much. Also very wilted. Meatballs were superb. We will come again next year.
The food was amazing. Will come back on my next visit.
The server was excellent!!
Service has been getting worse of the years.
Bread basket - most was stale. Dissappointing. The entree and salad was good. Coffee bitter yesterday. Had a reservation yet was asked to wait about 10 minutes in the bar (11:30 am reservation so not sure why).
Easy to be near to the theaters and stay open until late.
But the food is okay and the service is terrible.
Ambience is beautiful but the service is really poor unless you’re in a giant party. Expect to get nothing and ask every server.
Great old family style restaurant. Our waitress was attentive, kind and extremely nice. Food was excellent and we all shared!!!
We loved the Carmine’s experience! We just wish we had more than the 2 of us in our group as we wasted a lot of food. Since we were going to a show afterwards, plus we didn’t have a fridge in our hotel room we were not able to take our leftovers with us!
HUGE portions of each and every item and no small alternatives. Only good for gluttons or groups. Service was pleasant but very slow. It took 15 minutes to get the check. Food very good. Loved the clam sauce and liked the broccoli but it was enough for 4 people