Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

Carmine’s is a huge tourist restaurant. Very crowded and loud. One order feeds 3-4 people. Some may find that wonderful, but for two people it was way too much food and a terrible waste. Our spaghetti was very dry. I don’t want to go back.

Been here several times and always great food. The pasta dishes are out of this world. We tried the stuffed artichoke and it was very good; lots of extra of sauce to dip the bread into. The Veggie Lasagna was fantastic. Strawberry lemonade is very refreshing with real strawberries. The cappachino was a bit strong for my taste so I only drank half of it. The place is a bit pricey but for the city & the great food it's worth it.

Great food. Enough food in All of our family style dishes for 5 adults

We had a wonderful experience at Carmine’s yesterday! It’s alway one of our places we go when we come to NYC! Everything was perfect! We had the greatest waiter and the food was great! I always appreciate that they let you know how big the portions are!! Such a wonderful day!

Waiter to chatty about political issues. He thought he was there to entertain us. Meanwhile he never asked us if we wanted something to drink!

Great restaurant! The portions, even for family style, are enormous.

Had lunch prior to seeing moulin rouge on broadway.

Early Lunch before seeing the play - Aint Too Proud to Beg. Food was excellent, waitor was courteous and pleasant.

Too much food. 2 people should be able to have portions for 2, not 4. I don’t get this.

The food and service was great we will be back again

Very large portions..... pricey for a couple, A Bargain for a Group!

I've been to Carmine's a few times and this past Friday was the worse service I've received.

Big portions

Surpris par l’impossibilité de commander des plats individuels.
Seuls des plats pour 3-4 personnes sont proposés.
On a pu prendre à emporter les restes. Mais bon..
Bonne cuisine, on a bien mangé. Un peu gras...

Solid food and close to the theaters! Never disappointed.

Amazing food and a true New York experience!

First time at Carmine’s. Food was excellent and servers were great!!! Gonna go again before we leave to go home!!

Carmine is always superb in the quality of food. The food and the wine selection was great. Our server, Ryan, gave us an amazing service.

Food was amazing. Our server Ryan was great! Overall great time.

Our lunch break experience was exceptional, as always.
Next stop - Carmine’s Las Vegas!!!

Food was amazing and the servers were so nice! We were there closer to closing because we just got out of a show and so it wasn’t loud and it was a very chill vibe. The cheesecake blew me away. Our party of four shared a salad, pasta and dessert and left stuffed with leftovers!

Muy bien la comida. Extremadamente grandes las porciones. Sin duda para compartir entre 2 o 3

Delicious food and drinks , good atmosphere and service

Great place. Family style. Plenty of food to go around.

Good food. Designed for theatre meal

Anniversary

Una locura de sitio! Raciones gigantescas de buena calidad!!! Spaguettis con meatballs una delicia.

Great food. Portions are huge. Fun place to come with friends to share

Very good, portions are insanely large, I wish there was a small option for two diners, it makes ordering more than one item wasteful. Food and service was great though!

Had to wait 30 minutes to be seated standing up even though I had reservation for my party of seven

Great food and great service! So happy the had an allergy menu!!

Unfortunately I had to wait a long time to be seated and finally I went back to the hostess to understand what the problem was and she finally sat us. The server was dressed very sloppy and he was not friendly. He actually tried to talk us out of things we ordered. Asked for a drink and he never brough it. Then he made a mistake with my debit card. I’ve had great experiences but I brought a friend for the first time and it’s sad that was her experience of my favorite restaurant

Our waiter was excellent give great advice on how to order because of family size portions

Although I had an outstanding time with exceptional service and good food that would have been great had it come out hot and not barely warm. Our waiter was exceptional in that he was pleasant and did not push us to over order or hurry. But my pet peeve is food that does not come out hot. But it was still very tasty and more than enough to share. But I would not recommend the tiramisu. It was basically a big bowl of whipped cream (that must have had a stabilizer like gelatin added) with chocolate shavings and a couple of ladyfingers on the bottom. Skip dessert and go for an appetizer.

We had requested a special table in the back for our anniversary but were told when we got there that the back was reserved for people with limited time. Where we ended up was so loud we couldn’t even talk.

While the food was very good, the place was overloaded at 4:45 pm, diners trying to get through before the plays start. We waited 20 minutes to be seated, then after an appetizer, waited an hour or more before entrees appeared, and then only when we finally found our waiter and asked. He made up some story about the kitchen being too busy, however all the people around us, who arrived after we did, were served promptly. They must have lost the order in the kitchen. Very noisy, closely spaced tables. Best to not go here under any time pressure especially in a peak period.

Fantastic food and great establishment but impossible to order the right amount of food for two people! We left with a giant takeaway bag and had to toss it because we were going to a show!

Always a good meal at carmines great drinks and the service is great also

Ones again...one of the best places to eat in NY. This is my 57 time in town and and I will keep comming for Carmine’s

The food is totally average at best, really don’t understand the hype. Tasted like something you would get at a cheap bar.
Not worth paying for. Waiter forgot our drinks too.