Good food however they were out of their delicious brussel sprout appetizers and chicken - so disappointing!
Felt like we were being pushed to finish and leave. Waitress brought us our bill while we were still eating and never asked if we wanted dessert. Also the Open table menu is not the same as their current menu and when we questioned it, the waitress said the new owners of 1 year did not have access to the website to fix it due to a dispute with the previous owner.
Nicer dinner in a resort ski town. Prices reflect the ski resort, but the food is much better quality then many close to the slopes places. Service was top notch. Wife and kids 10 and 16 loved it.
Really good food, nice atmosphere, good service with fun environment.
Great wood and beers.
We ate dinner here one night while on a ski trip to Steamboat. On the plus side, we had a reservation for 7 people and were seated right away. Other than that, we were all relatively unimpressed overall. Our 20-somethings enjoyed the whiskey flights but everything else was overrated & not worth the expense. The food & menu were nothing great. Our waiter was somewhat condescending (scoffing at my husband for ordering a mere Budweiser, etc.). He also struggled with splitting our bill over more than one credit card. Overall, Carl's Tavern was our least favorite dining experience in Steamboat. We much preferred The Ore House & Mazzola's in every regard.
Outstanding selection of whiskey and bourbon. Friendly service and good food. We will be back!
The best burger I have had in a very long time! This was a recommendation from someone I was chatting with in the bus! Glad we went!!
A favorite of ours! Alwasys glad when we can get a table.
Great ambiance great food great service thank you Scott for making it personal!
Excellent service. Food was fantastic as always. We love Carl’s Tavern!!!
Fantastic Whiskey List
great cornbread and beer. great kid menu as well. look forward to our visit next year
Great place good food and easy going. Lots of TV’s as we watched the Olympics . Food is great. I would recommend this place for a casual dinner.
Second time there with my teenage boys and I remembered why I hadn’t been back for a while. While the service was great and the food good we had to shout to have a conversation, and my boys are not quiet.
Service was great but my burger was over cooked and dry. Friends salmon was incredible!
Great cocktails. Service was good food was good but didn't wow. Pricing was good for Steamboat. Will comeback for happy hour!
We chose Carls while in Steamboat mainly because they take reservations for Super Bowl Sunday. The reservation required a 75$ pp minimum charge. Some thought this was a put off but I knew that would be no problem for us for ~4 hours of dining, drinking and enjoying the large group excitement of watching the game. Wasn't disappointed at all. Great atmosphere with large screens everywhere. Service was perfect. Interesting menu - only wish I had a chance to try some of the other sandwiches/ entrees. We had the burgers, they were very good but in retrospect, I can get a good burger many places. Shoulda tried something different; I'm pretty confident I would have enjoyed anything on the menu. The highlight for us were the crab cakes we had early on - nicely crusted with good proportions of breading/meat - delicious. Hopefully, we'll return to Steam Boat and if so, we'll return to Carls.
As always Carls was very good. I would like to see them add ribs to the everyday menu. We enjoy Carls for a simple night out. The burger is great as well as the chicken sandwich and flatiron steak.
This is an annual stop on our trip to Steamboat Springs. We ran into issues of being out of menu items and poor seating last year as well as soup coming out after the entree in the past. We love the location, several menu items and our earlier experiences so we gave it one last try. This year was another bust. We were greeted and then waited as the host/hostess tried to figure out a table configuration for my husband and I... oh no, not again! This year was worse. We were put in the back corner behind a table of 10 against a wall. We asked to move the table out and they said there were other tables being moved into the area. We ordered the special Fried Chicken and our waiter then informed us that they were out (supply management... it was only 7:30pm). I ended up ordering the amazing Crispy Brussel Leaves and a Tavern Salad. Here's the cake - I ordered the blue cheese dressing on the side. It was warm and did not taste good. I asked for the citrus vinaigrette AND then was told I would be charged .50¢! OK, it is only .50¢ but seriously, the first dressing was bad. We've moved on and will branch out next year. Good luck in finding your new wings under the new management.
Chicken pot pie special was super tasty. It did feel like our server was rushing us....he kept coming over to remove items off the table while we were still working on our meals. It made it awkward to tell him no, please leave us alone for a little longer.
One our favorite spots that we hit every time in Steamboat. Dry rub wings and Brussels appetizer are two regular faves. Wide ranging menu and consistently solid food offerings.
We always enjoy Carl's and must eat there at least once while we are in Steamboat Springs.
Great family dining experience. All enjoyed their dinner and we hope to go back before we leave.
Visiting from out of town, a local recommended Carl’s for game watching. We are huge Falcons fans and wanted a fun place to watch the playoff game. Carl’s staff completely hooked us up — gave us a booth with the perfect TV angle and did not rush us so we could stay for the entire game. We had apps, dinner, drinks and dessert. Food was fantastic, and the staff was awesome. We had our two kids with us, and thought it was very family friendly too.
We chose Carl's because of its reliable casual food and convenient location. All 5 of us enjoyed some variation on a burger and I also had a salad....all of which were very generous portions and done to order. Under new ownership, the service has improved substantially, though some of my favorite menu items have disappeared. The biggest problem for me is always the noise. We arrived at 8pm and the noise level was so high we had trouble talking across the table. It was slightly better by the time we left.
Food & service were good. Menu at restaurant didn't match what was available online. Waitress commented that when it reopened, menu shrunk a bit. Still good selection available, but some desired options from online menu were no longer available.
We were seated at a very comfortable high top table in the back. The noise level was fine where we were seated. When we left the front of the restaurant was loud and bustling. We would come back for the dirty business and cornbread appetizers. The stew was delicious, the Reuben not special. Double black diamond burgers were massive. Overall a fun night.
What a fun place for New Years Day (dinner) with the family. Alabama-Clemson on TV and happy, cheering fans. Two vegans in our party of 4, and our delightful server, Jorge, made sure everything came out perfectly. We'll be back...food was delicious!
We have been to Carl’s many times over the years. It’s usually one of my favorites. We were a little disappointed this time. Menu is much more limited and the food wasn’t as good as usual. Miss the vegetarian option they always had.
The salmon had too much sauce on it which drowned out the salmon.
Steak was average.
We went to Carl's to watch an out-of-town football game. The staff was very accommodating with regard to putting the game up on a screen that we could all see. We sat there for over three hours before we were told that there were other reservations that needed the table. The staff was again super great about setting up a space for us to continue to watch the game.
Carl's is my first choice for lunch or to watch a game in Steamboat.
I have always loved Carl’s and always ate Sunday chicken which was on the menu daily. However, new ownership took over and now they only have fried chicken on Sunday. So after years of their chicken I had to order something else. Bring back fried chicken every day PLEASE.
Our adult family of 6 spent our ‘last supper’ in Steamboat Springs at Carl’s Tavern. Our reservation was for 8PM, we arrived 15 min early and were sitting at our table by 7:55PM on a very busy Friday night (great coordination by the host staff!). We had crab cakes and corn bread for appetizers and both were excellent (yep, we can see why Carl’s was voted best corn bread for 2017!). We had a mix of meals, from burgers to salmon to THE BEST RUEBEN that I have ever tasted. We had planned on sharing desserts but the food was so good that we finished our meals and were too full to eat a single morsel more. Wait staff was friendly and energetic- full of smiles and great recommendations (loved the Naughty Nordsmen cocktail). Overall, an excellent dining event that topped off an amazing week of skiing and snowmobiling at Steamboat Springs.
We had dinner at Carl’s. It was pretty crowded and a bit noisy. Good food though. We tried the cornbread, home made pimento cheese and crab cakes. They were good not great. My sons chicken was tasty but a little dry. The waiter had a large table he was waiting on and ignored us until I asked for another waiter. Then we got all kinds of attention. Overall a good experience though.
Good food. Great service
As always Carl’s doesn’t be disappoint. The staff and food are always consistently solid and you always feel like you had a good experience at a fair price. We will keep returning. Wings rock, burgers rock, Brussels are unique and delicious and solid variety of other options.
Burger was requested to be cooked medium and came out bright red. Check your meat before you eat!
We were there during Christmas week and it was busy. For a while, we felt that we were invisible as every wait person passed by and did not acknowledge us. Finally, when someone was assigned to us, we were able to order. We enjoyed the food.
Usually Carl’s does not disappoint so we think they were just way off for the night. We were hurried through our ordering and dinner which became annoying. The chicken was dry, the mashed potatoes were not cooked right. The ribs didn’t have a ton of flavor. Not a great night.