Carlo & Johnny
It was absolutely deliciously! The only thing was they asked if it was a special occasion and I answered Anniversary when making reservation. When we arrived the hostess greeted us with Happy Anniversary, but after that it was never mentioned. It was our 52 which I understand is not a milestone but an acknowledgement would have been nice. Just an observation! Other than that it was wonderful!!
Love celebrating my bday there , thanks to hubby and family
Great service. Charming ambiance. Food was excellent, except the lobster Thermidor... which was over cooked and fishy... not fresh.
We were celebrating a belated birthday. We had Austin for our server and he made our experience wonderful. We have already booked our next dinner in December.
Love the atmosphere and food. We had a booth, which is a little quieter and more comfortable for me. Steak was perfection! Sides were good as always, and the desserts were lovely. They currently have a brown butter pie and a brownie and ice cream dish on the menu. If you like dark chocolate, pecans, and ice cream, then get the brownie dessert! Probably best to share it with someone unless that's all you get.
Charlie Bledsoe, General Manager is the reason we continue to come back for every special occasion. This past Saturday my sweetheart and I just wanted to celebrate each other, life in general and were very happy to do so dining at Carlo & Johnny's. The service was impeccable as always, raw bar always amazes- the tiger shrimp are the largest I've ever seen- coast to coast! The Collinsworth signature filet mignon can't be beat and the selection of wine pairings and bourbon continues to grow. Charlie even sent out a piece of the signature butter pie for dessert and I continue to promise myself I'm going to learn that recipe one of these days! We'll certainly continue to support our very favorite local Cincinnati restaurant. Thank you and your entire staff for always being so warm and welcoming, we feel like family every visit.
Our waiter, Dan, is a true professional. Attentive, caring and appreciative of everyone.
Great food with exceptional service.
Everything was superb, the only complaint that I have was that the steak that I ordered was $70 and cooked at the wrong temperature. Rather than fire up a new one, they re-grilled the one that they had asked me to cut in half to determine if the temperature was correct. Wouldn’t have minded except for that it was $70. My husband was very upset as we only go out to dinner a few times a year and technically couldn’t even eat our meals at the same time. I kept telling him that I was pretty sure they’d try to make it up to us somehow but they didn’t.
This restaurant is one of the best restaurants we’ve ever been to and we will continue going
Marine Corps birthday and Veterans Day!
Everything was amazing, our waiter Chris was THE BEST. Made our anniversary/birthday very memorable, can’t wait to return!!
Charlie always greets us like old friends and treats us like family. Cameron was our server and was one of the best we’ve ever had. Kind, attentive and just seemed genuinely interested in why we were there celebrating. He’s a definite asset to your staff!
Never fails that the experience here is an excellent one! The service is amazing and we had the perfect table. Can't wait to go back!
Anniversary. Go there every year.
James was perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Our main waiter (Zac) gave us excellent & prompt service!! All staff there from the bartender to the main desk were so helpful & friendly! The food was beyond amazing!!
Excellent experience all around, from service to food to atmosphere.
Food is always top notch but it’s the outstanding service that takes the dining experience over the top. Thank you Dan for taking such good care of your customers.
Adrian, our server, was by far the best service we’ve ever experienced anywhere! The food was very good as well. A bit heavy on the salt and med rare on my steak was more of a rare but the flavor was very good.
They do steak incredibly well. There were four in our group, who each got a different steak and all were incredibly pleased. The sides were mostly very good, but two in our group did not really care for the macaroni and cheese. While they said it seemed special in the several types of cheeses used, they found it too rich and heavy to go with the steaks. The Brussel sprouts were especially good, as were the mushrooms. The prices ares quite high, but the steaks are incredibly good. There service was wonderful and they catered to food allergies readily and deliciously.
The shrimp cocktail was outstanding as was my 8 oz. filet. The Freddy Salad was good. The wine was top notch. Our servers were excellent. The only drawback was my wife's 12 oz. lobster tail which was over cooked, gummy texture, and not nearly 12 oz.
Definitely a special occasion restaurant; the food is outstanding, the service impecabble, all in a beautiful setting. My son won't ever forget his 23rd Birthday Dinner!
Excellent steaks, beyond comparison. My thick-cut filet was cooked to perfection; it was cooked just right the entire way through, whereas other restaurants have trouble pulling this off. This was my second or third time here and I'm always very impressed. There are other steakhouses closer to my home, but Carlo & Johnny's is absolutely worth the drive.
We had a very delicious meal and our server Zack was outstanding. His recommendations were excellent and the service was perfect. Everybody at your restaurant is so friendly including the parking valet who helped us with wheelchairs and walkers.
Food and service are phenomenal as usual. You can't go wrong with any thing on the menu.
Chris, our waiter, made good recommendations and he was personable. Our food was excellent and prompt. Other than the table next to us being quite boisterous (not Carlo & Johnny’s fault) our evening was enjoyable.
It was our first time dining here. Hands down the Best service that we have experienced at any Jeff Ruby restaurant. From the moment we entered until we left all of the staff were attentive and friendly. Loved the bar area for a before dinner drink. The restaurant had a fantastic ambiance. Unfortunately we both felt the steaks were not up to par with other Ruby restaurants or other steakhouses in this price point. Maybe it was just an off night. The service and ambiance made up for the food and we had a fabulous anniversary dinner.
Great evening. Great service. Will definitely go back
Zac was an excellent server!
Outstanding service and amazing attention to detail
OMG! FANTASTIC!!! Best food and 5–Star service ever!! Awesome ambience💕Here’s the run down: Best Long Island I’ve ever had, the raw bar AMAZING, unbelievable melt in your mouth steak, the risotto was perfection, put a whole knew meaning to mac & cheese, & the butter pie was out of this world!! Thanks for making this a very memorable anniversary💕
We love Carlo and Johnnie’s.. it’s been our spot for anniversary dinner for several years
The wagyu steak was way better than I expected it to be. I ordered Bearnaise sauce with it, but the steak had so much flavor it tasted better without the sauce, and the sauce diluted the flavor. I really wish I ordered without the sauce, but I know for next time to get just the steak. I was also surprised at how much bacon was on my Freddie salad this time. Last time I went for my Birthday there wasn't as much bacon so it tasted better to me. This time they covered that salad in bacon and I was surprised. It wasn't a big deal since I can just choose not to eat the bacon and set it aside. The waiter I had was fantastic and much better than the one I had last time I went here. Overall a very awesome time.
A very pleasant experience. Great setting, service and food.
Absolutely wonderful as always
What an absolute wonderful place for a special occasion. Food was exceptional and the service even more so. Highly recommend this place if you love steak and olde time elegence and service.
Everything was wonderful. Matt and Nick took really good
Care of us tonight.
Everything in the restaurant was fantastic. From the service to the coffee at the end of my meal. Kirk was an amazing waiter. I will definitely be going back for special occasions
Anniversary dinner. Always our favorite spot for celebrations. Top notch service and crazy good steaks.