Lovely place, great ambiance and service. Alec the Sommelier was very helpful.Great place to have a special quiet dinner with great friendly staff.
Wonderful all around!❤ Seafood salad DELICIOUS! Burrata with prosciutto, awesome. But the Bouliabaise... PERFECTION!! MOLTO BUONO!! We will return again and again!
Great place! Great ambiance, food and service.
Will be back
Great place, 5 stars is not even enough!!!
Will be back soon!
The reservation was for 2.30 lunch , so the place was practically empty . Service was good , food average .
overpriced below average food, pretentious atmosphere and quite unprofessional service.
List of specials is longer than the regular menu and is recited by the waiter for at least 10-15 min; why would you have so many specials when there is a standard menu?! Because the special dishes are the same as in the menu, only are charged at a premium rate. The waiter, after knocking over and spilling the glass of white wine, did bring the wine to replenish, however, he poured the wrong and cheap wine into the glass that still had some $25/glass wine left in it. Totally unacceptable. The food is "diner" quality, unfortunately.
Overall poor experience, can't recommend to anyone.
Never disappoints in any way! Great food, great service, and you can actually have a conversation! Not a lot of restaurants that provide that sort of environment. There is not a bad table in the room. All 4tops or more, with space between them!!! So, dining alone or a couple, you are never jammed in between othe guests. You actually have some degree of privacy!How rare is that?!?!?! Love dining there!
As always, Caravaggio does not disappoint. Superb service, great wine list and food...ahh...the food. Fettuccine with black truffles, Dover Sole...Vin Santo. The best!
We had a wonderful dinner last night. The service and the food were exceptional.
It is close to my daughters's apartment so we will certainly return when we visit her!
Wonderful atmosphere, impeccable service and delicious food.
Superb in every way.
My husband and I had New Year's Eve dinner at Caravaggio and we will return well before 12/31/2018. The service was excellent--beginning with our ten minute wait at the bar. The bartender was extremely gracious and, importantly, made great cocktails. The service staff during our meal was extremely adroit in serving a large number of people in an efficient and gracious manner. Somehow, they really succeeded in making you feel as if you were part of a large family celebration--all of whom were glad to be there. As for the food, it was delicious. We had a simple salad to begin and it was a delicious mix of greens/manchego cheese and a very light dressing. I had the rack of lamb--which was perfectly prepared and presented. My husband had veal stuffed angolotti which were the best he/we have ever had in terms of flavor and overall texture. Lastly, as to the wine, we discovered a Calabrian wine which was at the very low end of the price range but was absolutely delicious. Truly. We look forward to our next visit to Caravaggio--which will be soon.
Wonderful food -quality -preparation - presentation. Great to be able to hear each other speak. Interesting room ambience- great find!
We were looking for a New Year's Eve menu that wasn't Pre Fixe and this was a perfect choice. Atmosphere was soft and comforting with very good acoustics to keep down the noise. Tables are spaced nicely, especially for NYC. The food, wine and service were all excellent. Can't wait to go back.
The service was impeccable. The food was terrific. They did not have the wine we originally ordered, but the waiter’s suggested replacement was even better. We hosted friends for their anniversary and it was a memorable meal.
Just lovely! A beautiful setting, warm welcome, great service and food.
The greeting people which includes the check in person and the coat check person were very cold and unfriendly. We really thought all of the waiting staff were excellent. Food was excellent. Did not like our table felt like we were tourist stuck in the corner, even though we live three blocks away. The whole feel is just a little stiff for such a fine restaurant. We will be back because of the food quality, hope our experiences better next time. This was our granddaughter’s 18th birthday, so everything could’ve been better.
This was our second year spending Christmas Eve at Caravaggio's. The ambience and service are impeccable and the food is exceptional. On this very family-oriented evening, they insure that the only thing you need to think about is spending time around the table with your family. Leave everything else to them because they know how to make you feel at home while dining in a NYC restaurant.
We could not have found a better locale for our family Christmas Eve. The service was friendly yet professional and the food delicious. The roasted veal chop and muchroom ravioli with black truffle sauce were particular hits.
We will return!
Was wonderful. Fantastic food, extensive menu, classy, elegant, great service. I will go back for sure.
Really enjoyed. A dining experience.
Wonderful food attentive service lovely atmosphere comfortably upscale. Caravaggio is consistently satisfying. A favorite !
This is one of our favorite restaurants in New York. It is elegant and special, yet warm and inviting. We absolutely adore it every time we are there!.
My husband and I ate here after attending the Met Breurer on Madison Avenue. Although the lunch was pricey, we enjoyed it very much. We both ordered lamb shank which was exceptional. The meat literally melted off the bone. The cabbage soup was perfect for a cold early-winter afternoon. The wine was the most expensive part of the meal, but that seems to be fairly common for many restaurants. Great service--- we love northern Italian food.
What a terrific find so close to the Met. The food and the service were outstanding. This restaurant has beautiful Christmas decorations.
Wonderful in all ways!!! We cannot wait to return during our next visit from Charleston, SC!!!
An Italian restaurant that offers some unusual food options - all of which were very good.
We were 4 for dinner last Sunday, very well received, meal and wines were excellent. This is our 3rd visit to your Restaurant and as usual it was a most agreable experience.
We travel to NYC from New Orleans twice a year and continue to be amazed at the service, food and ambiance of Caravaggio. Coming from a city of exquisite dining and service, we continue to be amazed here. The drinks are superb and the wine pairings are always fabulous. There food is creative and unique. I can never pass up the "pasta special" with fresh grated white truffles tableside or the Dover Sole if it is a special. Sam greets you as you are seated in the beautiful dining room with their incredible art collection. If you had to pick one establishment to dine in while in NY, this one should be at the top of your list!!
Great service and food. Excellent location especially if you're planning a visit to Met Breuer, which is around the corner on Lexington.