Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Caracara Mexican Grill
Special prix fixe dinner menu for $27.95 Mon-Wed. (Starting end of May 2021) Monday is Mojito drink spls; Tue is Taco Tuesday in Tequila lounge after 4pm. For a light lunch enjoy our salad and sandwich offerings as well tacos and enchiladas. Comfortable bar booths available as well as outdoor seating in season.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Mahi or Camarones Citrus Marinated served with plantain and corn tortilla chips
Rolled chicken breast breaded & stuffed with Chihuahua cheese, poblano pepper & mushroom. Topped with tequila, mushroom cream sauce
Pint Red & Green Salsa & Chips
Menu offered really original food you would not ordinarily find at a typical Mexican restaurant. Everything was really outstanding. We will definitely be returning!
The food is always delicious and fresh and I asked the chef to alter my dish and he9
Had the paella, bland rice looked like it was Uncle Bens minute rice. Paella Valencia is supposed to be more seafood with a few charizo and chicken. This was all chicken pieces and charizo. 4 mussels and 4 mini shrimp with the rest being all Rice literally a plat piled high of all rice for $34. Def not worth it!
Had the tres leche my husband said it tasted like the Entenmann’s pound cake with milk poured on top. Needless to say we wont be back it was ok!
Restaurant had a smell of lacquer or stain. It was very overpowering. Food was good, drinks were good. Service was good. Shame the smell was so bad.
We hadn't been there since before the pandemic and realized how much we missed it. Dinner was wonderful as was the service. Everything was as we had remembered.
Lorenzo was our waiter and I cannot say enough good things about him! He was attentive, he explained some of the meal options and was so so sweet! The food was spectacular, and the drinks were even better! Def recommend this place anytime!
Always great service, food and atmosphere!
This was my 1st time going and would definitely return
Have never been disappointed at CaraCara. Best margaritas in town!
The free Chips and salsa was the best thing we had!!!
I ordered the chicken tortilla soup, which had zero flavor. And one shred of chicken in it... no exaggeration.
Then on to the main course... ordered the chicken fajitas.. i believe they call it open skillet tacos or something.. terribly small portion for the price and again skimpy on the protein.. at best it was one chicken cutlet cut in pieces and a ton of cheese. Again.. lacking flavor...
Same scenario with my husband’s meal.. we will not be returning.. way over priced and not enough food... lacking all the flavor. Disappointed
We ate outdoors. Service was excellent. Food was really good. I had salmon and it was cooked exactly how I requested. Top was nice and crispy. Only issue was mojito could have been stronger
1st time at Caracara
We each had a margarita and shared some shrimp tacos
Great place, close to home
We shall return
Very disappointed. Order was delivered too soon after ordering. Rice and Beans were too hard/ undercooked. Entree was bland. Dessert (Flan) was burned on the bottom. Overall we felt rushed.
Great delicious food and you get a lot for your money
Solid place for Mexican!! Always a good meal.
We've been here several times and each visit is better every time! Attention to covid detail is clearly evident and the staff is polite and attentive. Tableside guacamole is terrific and the drinks superb! All 4 of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals with no complaints! Will be back again soon!!
Great place, currently due to COVID there’s a 1.5 hour max. Would have loved to have an extra hour of their margaritas
Food was bland. We ordered skillet steak tacos and steak quesadilla. The steak was tender but needed more flavor. The quesadilla was not hot, the cheese was already gummy. They need to give the table more salsa. They use the smallest condiment ramekin instead of a proper bowl. The frozen margaritas could be better. Dinner was edible just not great.
Very nice restaurant. Food was great. Would go again.
The food was outstanding and the service was great. We asked our server for recommendations and both were spot on. We also got to meet one of the owners (Pete) and it was a pleasure to speak with him and the success of his establishment. This is our new go to Mexican Restaurant.
Our waiter was great. Very accommodating and friendly. It was very noisy and packed but that’s expected for a Friday night. Overall food and staff were great
Never disappointed. Super tortilla soup and perfect pollo relleno. As always, perfect service. Best restaurant on Long Island.
All around very good
We enjoyed the actual food at the restaurant however, we were disappointed in the Mojito ‘s. They were premade and very short. Way too much ice. Upon ordering a second I requested less ice, but we’re still disappointed that they were not made fresh.
Good food. Good service.
First timers. Will def be back. Loved the atmosphere. Fresh guacamole made table side is so good. Tacos were delicious and the beer was cold. Service was very good as well.
wonderful atmosphere, great food, and friendly servers. All in all a fun night and a great restaurant! Will return.
They Made my son’s birthday special!
Great, friendly service. Always delicious food and drinks.
Been coming here for 2 years and I love the ambiance. The food taste amazing and the drinks made by Pedro (Bartender) are the best mixtures I’ve had. Not strong, but not weak. Just perfect!!! His cucumber jalapeño margarita and coconut mojito are on point!!! 2 thumbs up!!!!
I love the atmosphere of this restaurant. Food is delicious and at a great value
While the food was good and out waiter was nice - the hostess was not. I booked for standard seating and was told when I arrived that only high tops were available. I noted that we had a standard seating but the hostess noted that parties of 2 were being seated at high tops near the bar at the moment - I obliged. However, 10 minutes later another couple was seated in the main dining room for a table for 2. I asked my waiter why and was told it was because they had a reservation (meanwhile so did I). It's disappointing to seen the range of care.
Excellent food and drinks!
The food was delicious. Love the taco skillet and table side guacamole!
We felt rushed with the time limit. The food was a little salty and drinks had too much ice for the price. They should really offer pitchers of margaritas.
Quiet birthday dinner - drinks and the food were excellent
The food and service is always very good
We are never disappointed always excellent!
I love this place, the food is amazing, def coming back 😁
Fabulous ceviche! Perfect chips! Extraordinary paella. Best restaurant on Long Island.
Caracara Mexican Grill offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 777-2272.
Caracara Mexican Grill is rated 4.5 stars by 1206 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.