Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Caracara Mexican Grill
Special prix fixe dinner menu for $27.95 Mon-Wed. (Starting end of May 2021) Monday is Mojito drink spls; Tue is Taco Tuesday in Tequila lounge after 4pm. For a light lunch enjoy our salad and sandwich offerings as well tacos and enchiladas. Comfortable bar booths available as well as outdoor seating in season.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Mahi or Camarones Citrus Marinated served with plantain and corn tortilla chips
Rolled chicken breast breaded & stuffed with Chihuahua cheese, poblano pepper & mushroom. Topped with tequila, mushroom cream sauce
Pint Red & Green Salsa & Chips
All around very good
We enjoyed the actual food at the restaurant however, we were disappointed in the Mojito ‘s. They were premade and very short. Way too much ice. Upon ordering a second I requested less ice, but we’re still disappointed that they were not made fresh.
Good food. Good service.
First timers. Will def be back. Loved the atmosphere. Fresh guacamole made table side is so good. Tacos were delicious and the beer was cold. Service was very good as well.
wonderful atmosphere, great food, and friendly servers. All in all a fun night and a great restaurant! Will return.
They Made my son’s birthday special!
Great, friendly service. Always delicious food and drinks.
Been coming here for 2 years and I love the ambiance. The food taste amazing and the drinks made by Pedro (Bartender) are the best mixtures I’ve had. Not strong, but not weak. Just perfect!!! His cucumber jalapeño margarita and coconut mojito are on point!!! 2 thumbs up!!!!
I love the atmosphere of this restaurant. Food is delicious and at a great value
While the food was good and out waiter was nice - the hostess was not. I booked for standard seating and was told when I arrived that only high tops were available. I noted that we had a standard seating but the hostess noted that parties of 2 were being seated at high tops near the bar at the moment - I obliged. However, 10 minutes later another couple was seated in the main dining room for a table for 2. I asked my waiter why and was told it was because they had a reservation (meanwhile so did I). It's disappointing to seen the range of care.
Excellent food and drinks!
The food was delicious. Love the taco skillet and table side guacamole!
We felt rushed with the time limit. The food was a little salty and drinks had too much ice for the price. They should really offer pitchers of margaritas.
Quiet birthday dinner - drinks and the food were excellent
The food and service is always very good
We are never disappointed always excellent!
I love this place, the food is amazing, def coming back 😁
Fabulous ceviche! Perfect chips! Extraordinary paella. Best restaurant on Long Island.
I had been to this restaurant pre-covid a few times and it was jammed packed with live music playing, was sad to go back and seeit at 1/2 capacity. We started with the table side fresh Guacamole with chips, it was very good. Then we ordered 2 dishes: Shrimp Tacos and The Scallops Tropical. Both dishes were delicious. We also ordered a side of Brussel Sprouts which were interesting, Ive had better. For dessert we had something with Bananas and cream cheese, this wouldn't have been the choice I would have made, but it was good if you love creamy dessert dishes. We were beyond stuffed, the service was good, I loved the decor, management was very attentive and made sure to tell us the Covid protocol as we entered the establishment.
Excellent find !! Guacamole great, made right in front of us. Tacos .. Thumbs up !! Worth trying out !! Michaeladas were awesome !!
We ordered Guacacole it was made at the table, and since we have had it here before was looking forward to it, don't know why, it was tasteless, there absolutely was something missing, since I love Avocado, we ate it, but would not order it again here. The entrees were tasty and good.
Nothing says Birthday Celebration like margaritas and queso fundito!
Walked in to 2 used masks on the floor. Stopped in the bathroom before we were seated for dinner. Bathroom was filthy and in need of a face list. One stall was completely overflown with toilet paper. It was evident the restroom was not serviced for some time. Asked for a high top table on open table and was seated at a regular table. We have been going here for years and sad to see this place is going down hill. No Mexican music playing for the vibe. It was rather boring for a Friday night. I did take into effect Covid but doesn’t hurt to have some upbeat music. The waiters mask was constantly falling below his nose which caused him to touch it multiple times as he made our guacamole. The food has changed so much. My favorite was the blue corn calamari. It now looks like greasy little scraps. We always got the pitcher of sangria. For $40 it is sooo not worth it. They fill the pitcher to the brim with ice and pour a pre made mixture. It tasted like pure water and zero alcohol. I left feeling underwhelmed and disappointed that we wasted $120 on junk.
Our waiter, Rob, was attentive, humorous, and polite. Our food was very good (enchiladas suizas, braised short rib) and the margaritas were well done. Slightly expensive, IMO, like Besito, but a good dinner nevertheless.
Excellent as always!!
amazing food & service! can’t wait to go back!
Food and service was great.
Dinner was delicious. The Waitress made some suggestions about our choices and we are so happy that we listened to her.
Can't wait to come back!!
I like the place and I’ve been a few times before but this time the waiter was being rude telling us that the restaurant close at 9 when its not true also they make us wait a long time to get our order
Food and service were excellent.
The food was very bland.
The drinks were great. We ordered skillet tacos. The pork ones were pure fat & the steak ones were also very fatty. There were 2 waiters & the manager was sitting at the bar drinking. It took forever to get a second drink / our check.
Great service. Nice ambience. Yummy cocktails & Delicious food!!! A+++
One of my absolute favorite restaurants! Authentic and delicious food and drinks. Never disappoints
Second time we decided to eat here because the first time the food and service were amazing. This time around the service was not the same, their was no lime for guacamole, no hot sauce only mild sauce and the waitress who attended us didn’t really give us any options. Overall the food was okay.
Food was a 10!
Of special note was the Iron Skillet Tacos, the fried plantains and the table made guacamole.
The food presentation, taste and service was excellent including fabulous cucumber margarita drink made by Mr. Pedro.
One of may favorite spot now.
Thank you Caracara Mexican restaurant see you soon :)
Good food, great ambiance and good sangria!
Food is not great. I would say less than average.
Salsas had no taste.
My pulpo had guacamole that looked aged (black)
Nothing really impressive not even the margaritas
Flavorless. Dry. COLD. Food tasted stale if it had any flavor at all. Baby octopus was disgusting desiccated and stale I was scared to breathe when they put it in front of me. Nothing tasted fresh. No authentic Mexican dishes. Even the beans were stale. Even the salsa was watery and flavorless. Not fit to serve in a convalescence home. Oh, and the menus were dirty too! You will need to order many cocktails to get through this joke of a meal.
Drinks were amazing, guacamole made right by table side was so delicious as well as the tacos. Very accommodating for people with special food requests and our waiter was fantastic
Caracara Mexican Grill offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 777-2272.
Caracara Mexican Grill is rated 4.5 stars by 1173 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.