If you are looking for a lighter bite, join us in our bar where we offer a menu featuring baby lamb chops, shrimp quesadillas and the best burger in town. Wind down the work week on Friday evenings with happy hour between 4 and 7 with discounted house drinks, domestic beer and wine(Happy Hour Mon-Fri). Every Sunday, Captain Bill's presents one of Long Islands premier brunch buffets. Featuring unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas and Champagne as well as an extensive buffet. Bring your friends and family for a wonderful Sunday Brunch dining by the harbor.
Broiled Seafood Platter
Scallops, Shrimp, Flounder, Baked Clams
10oz. Center Cut, Gorgonzola, Red Wine Sauce, Crispy Onions
This is our new favorite spot for a date night. This is a quiet little out of the way restaurant on the water with absolutely amazing food. The prices are great and the wait staff are fantastic. I highly recommend Captain Bill's for any occasion or just a nice dinner for two.
Food is always great every time .my favorite restaurant
Food always great service was a bit slow
Wonderful New Year’s Eve dinner
Captain Bills never disappoints. Great food and service
Wish they would post the New Year's Eve menu online. Don't get to see it until you are at the restaurant.
Always a pleasure but more so this time. After an expensive Christmas Eve dinner at another Bay Shore restaurant where the bread basket was an additional fee and we were not feeling very welcomed, Captain Bill's was friendly and delicious.
Not my first time there but once again a very nice dining experience. Nice pick of cocktails and menu has something for anyone. Nicely decorated for the Christmas season. Our server was well educated on items being served, we had several questions that were answered to our satisfaction.
We come from Freeport to dine here. Always worth the trip!
Everything was great. Hostess gave us a great table and our server didn’t hover. Service and food great.
Went to Captain Bills for the first time and we will be back. We had the Lobster & Shrimp Linguini and the Pan seared swordfish special. Everything was absolutely delicious. The dining room was full so it was a little noisy but other than that, it was a perfect dinner.
Just real nice palace to take a date. Great servive
The food and service were both awesome. We had a great time!
Should not allow dogs in dining room during dinner
A delightful restaurant with a great interior (nice outdoor dining in summer months too) and an expansive menu of delicious items. Service was a little slow, but the place is busy and they often have weddings, so it's understandable. Highly recommended for great seafood dishes!
Professional service, fantastic food, good value for the money, overall an outstanding experience. We will be back!
Food was excellent, was quite and meeting a buddy from high school was great we can talk and catch up on things, restaurant closed at 9pm but we was allowed to stay until 10.
We specifically decided to go for the eggs Benedict and left disappointed. There was no hollandaise sauce, eggs we overdone and cold. Overall ambiance, service and food was fine.
Captain Bill's is one of my favorite restaurants lately. Never a bad meal and the server, Dylan, is always very pleasant and helpful.
Our server Chantel attended to our every need. Kind and engaging. Food delivered hot and as ordered. Restaurant temp could have been a bit warmer. Overall great night.
Awesome Place, we go all the time...Thanks Capt. BILL...
We celebrated our 24th Anniversary dinner here. The food was awesome, the view was nice even in the rain and the staff was friendly and efficient. Great experience overall.
One of our favorites never a bad meal or time
Came to Long Island with my wife to visit her mom. Took her here for dinner, which was the same restaurant we had her 90th birthday dinner at.
This is the best restaurant on the eastern south shore.
Best seafood around.
Very enjoyable experience- food and service were great and the atmosphere was incredible
We celebrated our wedding anniversary and could not have had a better dining experience. The food was delicious, the service was awesome and the cost was less than expected to spend. Captain Bill's always delivers.
Great ambiance. All 4 enjoyed their meal. And waitress was terrific!
Very nice meal. Service was great. Not rushed had a nice evening.
We had a very pleasant experience. The food was amazing and the service was phenomenal.
The service was horrible . Mary Rose the waitress we had was rude , didn’t smile , no personality . She had the attitude as if she did not want to be there.
She was so bad my husband which he never does asked to speak to the manger on our way out . The manger instead of saying she is sorry we experienced that, I will speak with her. She was making excuses for Mary Roses horrific behavior.
It was real nice. Everything on time time. Waiters ever pleasant. Great place for first date. Will return.
We've been going to Captain Bills for 40 years. We still enjoy going there every once in awhile. The food remains consistent. Thank you for a great meal always.
Our server was terrible. She never replied “you are welcome” or uttered a sound for the few times she did actually come to our table. Dropped food, never checked back. Then gave a smile when it was time to pay and leave a tip.
Food was mediocre. The mashed potatoes on my husband’s plate were so salty he couldn’t eat them but our server never came over so he just ate around it. Fish was good. Felt a bit like wedding food.
Drinks were not great. We skipped dessert because we just wanted to leave at that point.
For the bill of $150 incl tip it was not worth it. Shame this place used to be really good
The food was not good. Brunch buffet was not hot and was bland. The place a vibe of a old folks rehab center and the food fit right in as if it was a rehab center. By Coffee was lukewarm, mimosa was a light splash of champagne and weak oj, served with ice cubes. All of the hot buffet wasn’t hot. The omelette station ran out of cheese and my wife’s egg white omelette was not egg white but regular. The servers were attentive and polite.
We are recurring patrons . We had the crust duck . Amazing and you have to have the French onion soup perfect and my wife had the clam chowder . Excellent night our
Been there 4 times very good
Always great service and delicious food. Now with outdoor tables.
Great food, amazing drink specials and wonderful service!
The food is great we eat off the Octoberfest menu The service was great and the view of the boats
Captain Bill's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 665-6262.
Captain Bill's is rated 4.5 stars by 1273 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.