If you are looking for a lighter bite, join us in our bar where we offer a menu featuring baby lamb chops, shrimp quesadillas and the best burger in town. Wind down the work week on Friday evenings with happy hour between 4 and 7 with discounted house drinks, domestic beer and wine(Happy Hour Mon-Fri). Every Sunday, Captain Bill's presents one of Long Islands premier brunch buffets. Featuring unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas and Champagne as well as an extensive buffet. Bring your friends and family for a wonderful Sunday Brunch dining by the harbor.
Broiled Seafood Platter
Scallops, Shrimp, Flounder, Baked Clams
Captains Seafood Tower for Two*
Chilled Lobster, Jumbo Shrimp, Clams & Oysters, Colossal Crabmeat & Seared Tuna Carpaccio, Trio of Sauces
Lobster Roll with French Fries
The food was mediocre, the service felt very rushed, there was a wedding going on there at the time so maybe that contributed to the lack of food quality and service.
It was unfortunate as we took special friends there and it was a complete disappointment.
Delicious fish dinners with broccoli rabe. Love outdoor dining, which they had plenty of. Lovely and helpful waitress.
Delicious lobster roll perfect water view ambience
Everything was great. The food and atmosphere was amazing. The staff was very nice and accommodating. Our waitress was so sweet. Will definitely go back again
Great food, great service. Captain Bill’s never disappoints
Excellent food and service. The view is spectacular.
Great menu and outstanding food! If the weather is good, sit outside and enjoy the view. Highly recommended!
Service was not great.
Waited twenty minutes no wait staff came to table as tables seated after us were served. Left without eating, better options for dinner in the area.
The views over the harbor were so enjoyable adding to a fantastic dining experience. Had the lobster roll with fries and salad which was so good. They did not skimp on the lobster and the roll was soft as butter. The grouper (lightly breaded and covered with a lemon sauce) as a main meal was accompanied with string beans and mashed potatoes... food was perfection!
Captain Bills seems to have lost a step since pre-pandemic days. The food was decent, just not as tasty or sizeable as we remembered it. The seafood was fresh though and prepared in the typical ways. If you manage your expectations, you won’t be disappointed. Service was friendly but just a little harried and not as attentive as usual. It is moderately loud inside. It will likely be awhile before we return.
The food is consistently delicious!
The food was very good. The waitress was very cordial and attentive. the view of the water was extremely nice, and to end it all, the dessert was delicious.
Good food, nice restaurant with really nice outdoor dining deck. Definitely worth a try
Food was a bit disappointing, key lime pie awful, fish halibut bland. But nice outdoor environment on bay.
Always a great experience when we go to Captain Bills. Looking forward to our return. Order the stuffed Flounder, you will not be disappointed!!
Always count on a great experience when eating here!
The food, service & staff was excellent. I will definitely be back again.
Great meal tonight. We sat outside and had a great view of the bay. Excellent service and delicious food!
Always consistently delicious!!! I had prosciutto wrapped jumbo shrimp.. fantastic!!!
The calamari was over cooked. My swordfish was dry, overcooked. The pasta was overcooked. So not really a good meal.
Despite the rainy misty weather the view was wonderful. We felt special celebrating our wedding anniversaryThe staff was very attentive
Need more gluten free options.
Gf pasta substituted for linguine would work.
Missed Bread sticks and crackers.
Restaurant was extremely busy but the staff were friendly and pleasant and attentive. Food was delicious. Love Captain Bills !
We received food before our drinks
Bus boys did not work the room
Had to beg for water
Table was left unattended and a mess for 20 minutes after apps. 1 hour before dinner order was taken.
No regular cappuccino decaf only.
Came out watered down. I have it all the time. Forgot to bring us dessert menu. We love the place go often. Just a bad night all around. Our 1 st time guest enjoyed the food. Probably would have had 2 or 3 more rounds of drinks but not able to order. Kinda of gave up. We were their from 7-10 at table.
Nice atmosphere and great views of the Marina. Baked clams excellent
Service was terrible!! Waited 14 minutes for server..
Our Anniversary lunch was lovely. The outside patio was peaceful and quiet. Our meal was delicious and the service was excellent.
Capt Bills has always been a favorite of ours. Being on the water and having delicious food made our decision easy on where to go for my husbands birthday. Unfortunately it didn’t work out that way yesterday. The waitress was very slow and had the appetizer brought out after waiting do long for it and then a minute later our main courses were being delivered. My wine glass was dirty, my husband ordered a second drink and waited 20 minutes for it. It was not an enjoyable time. My surf and turf that I ordered plain was swimming in grease. I had to remove it from the plate and use a clean side plate. Ugh!! Sorry captain bills but it wasn’t good and I’m now inclined to go elsewhere.
Best seafood platter! BBQ ribs w mac n cheese delicious
AmaZing food, service, and location.
The restaurant experience last night was spectacular the food was fabulous the service was wonderful beyond the ants was perfect and we're looking forward to going back very soon
This restaurant has always been our go to when we want consistent food and service we have learned to rely on. Last night the salmon was dry and service no so great. Kudos to the bus boys who did a fantastic job.
Mediocre, small portions of food. Decent ambiance, but prices were high for portion size BEWARE: on-line menu understates prices considerably - at least $10 more on your bill per person. Wine pour low.
It took too long for the server to greet us. It was not busy.
Always come back here. This is where my husband and I had our “magical” wedding!
Food is always fresh and tasty!!! Service is always friendly!!
Been here a couple of times with family and my boyfriend and I would definitely recommend it here. It’s a little expensive but it is definitely worth the money
Was looking forward yo eat a chicken dish with potatoes n veggie n didn't have any on menu so I ended up with salad n grilled chicken on top it was ok but preferred a dish that they use to serve there
Captain Bill's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 665-6262.
Captain Bill's is rated 4.4 stars by 1191 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.