Date night with my wife. We had a wonderful experience as is the case with Caleb's. We don't seem to get there often enough.

Great burger night. A fun dinner with friends.

Excellent as always! Highly recommend. Food is always delicious, service is great, and atmosphere is consistently pleasant. Brunch is one of our favs.

It was pleasant. Lee, our waiter, was great; very personable and attentive.

One of my favorites for breakfast, brunch, and lunch!
Love the many options to choose from.
Everything we’ve had is always tasty and served by a great staff.

Exceptional indoor dining experience. We recommend the filet medallions and the pork chop followed by the berry and pear crumble. Attentive service. Great value as a BYO.

Tremendous, quickly becoming our "go to" restaurant.

Always outstanding!

Food, presentation and service was excellent. First time here. We will be back!

Always a great experience, we enjoy it very much,

We always enjoy going to Caleb’s for a delicious meal. The service is always wonderful and the atmosphere is cozy and nice for both a date night or an evening out with friends. A must visit for fine food and a relaxing dinner.

Outstanding menu and service. Quality of food is excellent.

Dinner is usually our choice here and always excellent. 1st time for breakfast- food was delicious, service good, wait time- too long for breakfast.

Great, as always

Great service and food but tables still a bit close for me. The family eating near us was talking and had recently had Covid so felt a bit odd to sit so close.

We had a delicious and relaxing meal. Jack, our waiter, was really terrific! He absolutely knew the menu and was incredibly kind and competent. The duck was amazing! It is something I would return for again and again. We were a table of 4 and we all loved our appetizers, entrees and desserts! Highly recommend.

Caleb's American Kitchen has never served me a bad meal. "Traditional" dishes are always creatively produced with the freshest ingredients and surprising extras and sides. The service is friendly and professional without being too formal. The atmosphere is relaxed but clean and modern. I recommend Caleb's to everyone!

Dinner was a great value for price fix!
Love the seared tuna! Jack, our server, was great!

Glad to dine inside Caleb's with additional safety provided. Our Waiter was most helpful and kind.
Additional note. I ordered takeout from Caleb's on New Year's Eve which was also very good.

My husband and can’t say enough about how great everything is ...awesome food and wonderful staff.

Caleb's is a true standout! My wife, myself & our 1 year old son dined at Caleb's as a last minute option after a evening at Peddlers Village. The restaurant was had a nice upscale feel but also made it comfortable enough to bring a small child to dinner. Our waiter Jack was OUTSTANDING! He offered some great suggestions on the menu for the evening.

My wife ordered the Filet Medallions, cooked perfect Med Rare. I had the Lamb Shank & Potato Au Gratin special for the evening. The lamb was perfectly cooked, tender, juicy & bursting with flavor. It also came with a side of wild baby carrots that were excellent. Our son, being 16 months old, we ordered him the Grilled Cheese, which although I did not have much expectation for a kids grilled cheese, it was a step above what I expected, they didn't use the usual american cheese, instead it was made with Brie. My son ate almost the entire sandwich & fries, which for any parent out there of young kids knows that's a great feeling.

I would highly recommend checking out Caleb's once indoor dining is reopened. They do offer a extensive takeout menu, but I can't speak for that as we have not ordered takeout. We can't wait to Return!!!

When the new strictures on indoor dining came down, we immediately made reservations at Caleb's. If we could only dine out one last time this year, we wanted it to be there.

That should tell you all you need to know.

The food is always perfect. I got the lobster risotto, friend got the lamb special. Prices are good and portions are just right.

food was phenomenal, the staff was very attentive and the service was very quick. Highly recommend.

Caleb's American Kitchen serves consistently creative, delicious breakfast fare. Portions are ample and menu is extensive, especially for breakfast!! Don't miss their potatoes-- best I've ever had (and I've sampled MANY home fries/roasted potatoes)!! The kitchen is accommodating and service is courteous and attentive. Always worth the trip; never disappoints!!

We were there on a Sunday evening, and ordered the $28 prix fixe menu. She ordered the fish tacos and I had the veal meatlof...big portions and super delish all the way around. Being a BYOB, we brought our won bottle of red wine to accompany dinner. We both started with salads, and finished with a yummy desert...all for $28 per person. The food was delicious, the service was superb, and the value was outstanding!!!

Food was amazing. Everyone loved everything from the starters to the desserts! Will definitely go back again.

We chose to sit outside on a beautiful Sunday for lunch. The food was delicious and our server was very attentive and nice. The only negative was we were in the restaurants parking lot (not their fault due to COVID) and cars were pulling in and out in tight spaces trying to avoid the planters that were placed to separate diners and cars. Otherwise, we enjoyed our lunch at Caleb's very much!

Food was creatively prepared and was delicious. Quick and friendly service. Caleb was personally checking on customers, which was a nice touch. Partitions set up to separate the tables not only made us feel safe, but added to the decor in a positive way. We’ll definitely be back soon!

Wonderful food and presentation. Excellent service. Definitely recommend.

The pork chops and halibut are always prepared wonderfully

Wonderful food, great service

Food was excellent - the Cobb salads with chicken were delicious. Service was very good also!

We are now "regulars" at Caleb's for obvious reasons. The main one being consistency. The food and service are, bar none, consistently outstanding. I just don't feel comfortable going to breakfast anywhere else. Dinners are equally superb and Lee is our favorite server. Thank you Caleb's...a breath of fresh air and an oasis of sanity in a messed up world.

Great food and great service! Perfect brunch spot.

Have visited here numerous times. Caleb never disappoints. This time a Tuesday. It's their "Locals Burger Night". You don't have to be a local to enjoy. Took the neighbor along with us. Wife and I baled out on the burgers, and not because they're not good. They are. But we opted to order from the menu, instead of building our own burger.
Wife opted for the veal meatloaf which was outstanding (I had a bite). I opted for the Atlantic Salmon, partnered along with the Apple and Blue Salad, and the soup of the day. All were excellent.
A footnote: dress warmly. Temps inside are really cool. That's why I went with 4 stars for ambience. It's more about environment, as the ambience is fine. Caleb; turn up the stat.

Everything that we had from appetizers to entrees to dessert was amazing

Birthday Brunch was delicious!! Our waiter Lee was great.

We went for breakfast several times and the food is great. The only dish we were not crazy about is the quiche which is very sponge-like and not what we expected. But pancakes, eggs benedict, and omelets are great. Coffee is good too. Service is really friendly but a little slow when they get busy.

Always great food and service. One of our favorite spots