pan seared with a lemon zest breadcrumb crust served with broccolini, roasted carrots and sweet local corn in a citrus buerre blanc
herb crusted served with grilled asparagus
Fettuccini with Lobster, Shrimp and Arugula
in a yellow tomato pomodoro
Everything was delicious and the service was very attentive.
Everyone enjoyed everything that was ordered.
Very good food and service
Always the best…food, ambiance and service!
Anna sweetest hostess and Patty best waitress!
Everything was great. Server was great and attentive. Food was tasty and cooked as ordered. Always love coming here for dinner
As always the food was delicious. This is a favorite restaurant.
As usual food was outstanding, service a little slow due to being short staffed!
One of the best mining experiences I’ve had in a while. Everything we ordered was delicious, timed and served properly, and the staff was so kind and attentive.
A wonderful dining experience. Service was exceptional. The bread basket with warm crusty bread was divine. We shared tuna two ways- a light and tasty appetizer. I had fettuccine with lobster and shrimp. The pasta was perfectly prepared and the sauce paired beautifully with the seafood. My husband had pasta with sausage spinach and ricotta. He loved it. I tasted the sausage and will order that dish next time. For dessert- the best tartufo we ever had. Highly recommend.
Food & service very good! Will definitely be back!
We had a birthday celebration and it was very nice. Staff was great and very attentive. Food was superb and the atmosphere was warm and inviting.
Food is delicious
Great food and service!
As usual the food was very good. Unfortunately we were seated in the main dining room and there was a very loud party seated us. The shouting loud and laughter made everyone in the room uncomfortable. Testarossa has a smaller room they use for large parties and we believe they should have been seated there. The situation made the experience much less enjoyable than it could have been.
Also one of our party knocked over a drink filling the drink on the table and the pants of one of our party. The waitress who had just been to our table was about to enter the kitchen looked our way to see what happened and continued into the kitchen. We had to stop another witness for additional napkins and help. There was otherwise no offer of help or to replace the drink.
Testarossa is still a fine restaurant and we will continue to patronize them but in the future will be more careful in where we sit.
The outside is set up very well and the food is always on spot but the service was awful and the waitress was rude. We know it’s hard to get help these days so we overlooked it and just enjoyed the food and each other.
A comfortable, go to, great food, eat in or outside...It works well!!
Loved eating outdoors. Very nice atmosphere. Food was great as always. Had a wonderful celebration of our daughter’s birthday.
Always good. Never disappointed.
Lamb chops outstanding
octopus salad wonderful
We are always happy with our meals
Absolutely delicious - we had a wonderful meal, enjoyed drinks, appetizers, entrees and dessert.
Good restaurant. Good menu. Good service. All consistent.
Food was served hot in a timely matter and was delicious. BRING BACK OLIVE LOAF BREAD.
I have eaten here several times. Each time the food is amazing, the fish is always cooked to perfection. The service is exemplary the menu choices are alway varied. I would highly recommend them.
Best restaurant !
Always good food. Good prices. Great meeting place.
The food is always consistently delicious
Always the best!
They never miss. Everything was perfect
Sat in a hole in the wall
Food is on point
Food is always great and the hostess was very accommodating
Very good menu. A lot of choices and specials. Attentive service. Not overly pricey. Would definitely go back. Lived near by and never heard of the restaurant, yet it was filled.
We have been coming here for 20+ years and moved to NC. We came back to NY for a visit with Family and decided to meet some our Family at Cafe Testarossa. We were not disappointed, the food, decor, bar area and Bartender were fantastic. Every dishwasher great.. We will definitely be back
Friendly service. Excellent food. Would recommend to friends and family.
Very good food with a variety of choices. First time here since COVID and they have certainly kept table separated and still provided ambiance
Food and service is outstanding. We selected the outside seating, which is at the rear parking area of the building and isn't that attractive from all viewpoints. The wind and sun can be uncomfortable at times.
The inside seating is very comfortable and the noise level is low.
Wonderful service, and our dishes were delicious and very special. We loved the almond encrusted chicken and the lamb chops!
Cafe Testarossa offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 364-8877.
Cafe Testarossa is rated 4.8 stars by 912 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.