Great food, nice decor.
Make sure to ask for Nicole for your service. Fabulous!
Great food, great service, what more can you ask for?
It was lunch celebration for my friend's birthday. The salads were delicious and could easily last for two meals.
The brownie dessert was like fudge with whipped cream and vanilla ice cream.
Service was very attentive and polite.
Noisy ...but that’s ok ....food was just average, nothing to rave about
enjoyed the evening with friends...service was very good - food was not as good as it was the few times we were there...slightly overpriced but I think that goes with the territory. The place was packed - we had reservations and only waited about 5 minutes for our table.
Ehhh! Not impressed. Ordered pasta dish with lobster and crab. It was bland. NO lobster to be found! Not a spec of it!
Excellent food and excellent service. Had a great meal
We love coming to Butera's. One of our favorite dishes are the chicken meatballs.... deelish!
Great food and service. Everyone was very nice! The place is a little loud but it’s a family environment. Highly recommended!
Always enjoy this place. The only criticism was the server. He didn’t pay enough attention to us. We rarely saw him. When he brought our food it wasn’t hot. It was barely warm.
Even so the food was good. I would still visit this place in the future.
My husband & I had a date night & the food, service & atmosphere made for a Perfect Date Night! We had a reservation and were seated right away. There was probably close to 15 people piling in after us. I hope they had reservations!
As always the food was great! The waitress was awesome, we have had her before, but not sure of her name.
Good quality italian fare. Great menu with plenty to chose from no matter what your taste. All of their locations have consistanlty provided an enjoyable dining experience.
Great food, excellent service, never rushed! ` Extremely generous portions!
Food was excellent. I had Chicken Parm and the others had shrimp Parm and Rigatoni with broccoli. We started with fried calamari which was cooked to perfection. Nice experience.
The food was delicious and staff were excellent! Really enjoyed my visit.
We ordered an appetizer and the salmon. The avocado crostini appetizer was delicious, but the salmon came under cooked. When the waiter brought it back it was still under cooked in the middle. We returned it and ordered the chicken meatballs that were excellent. My sister got the tartufo for dessert and that was good but melted quickly. I ordered the cookie pie. It was more like cake and I think it had been over microwaved. It was rubbery.
Amazing food, great service, alittle too noisy
Excellent food and service. Seated exactly at reservation time. Highly recommend.
My girlfriend and I went to Butera's for the first time for Valentine's Day. I had seen it many times and had been wanting to go for a while. I live in Smithtown and it's nice to know I have a quality restaurant right in my backyard. The service was great when we walked in although they were very busy. Our waiter was knowledgeable and friendly. The food was good and had a big enough portion for me to save some for lunch the next day. The wine was great and the dessert spectacular. Great date night.
We went there for Valentine's day for the first time and it was a great experience. The food was delicious with modern twists on classic Italian meals. The service was great and it was cute and cozy inside. The pinot noir was one of the best I've ever had. It's in a great location on main street in Smithtown and it should stay there for a long time.
Went there for Valentine’s Day with out 6 & 8 year old kids. Service was excellent. Food was great as always. Place was packed which means it’s good. Always a great time!
The food was superb and the service was excellent
Good food but overpriced good service friendly staff
Service was good but the food wasn’t impressive. My chicken Romano was chewy and my husband did not like the ragu at all. I’m not sure about our friends food but considering they had a lot left over and did not take it home, I’m going to assume they did not like it either. The deserts and the meatball pot appetizer were the best parts of the meal.
We were celebrating my parents anniversary and Butera’s was a great option. They were able to reserve a table in an alcove area of the restaurant and it was perfect. The food was delicious and our waitress was very attentive. I ordered the risotto special and loved the layers of flowers it had.
We were there on Friday night. Had a party of 8, celebrating a birthday. Nicole was our server. She was outstanding. Very accommodating and friendly. The food , every one of our dishes , was awesome.
We always look forward to dining at Buteras. Never disappointed
It took an hour to get our food. Much too long . Short rib pasta very salty. Risotto was good. Chicken meatballs good
Everything was excellent but the restaurant is extremely loud, you cannot even hold a conversation.
The food was ok, service was ok. Too pricey for just ok
Love the food
It was all right
Food was excellent..Staff was courteous. We got a table for 6 tucked into our own alcove which made it almost private..Great desserts..
Definitely going back for dinner again..
lOVE THIS PLACE!!! IT IS CRAZY NOISY ON FRIDAY AND SATURDAY NIGHTS, BUT THE LUNCHEON TIME IS JUST AMAZING....QUIET, GREAT FOOD, LOTS OF IT, TASTY, HEALTHY AND VARIED....JUST WHAT YOU WANT...AND YOU CAN GET A SEAT AND HEAR ONE ANOTHER!!! JUST GREAT. RIGHT IN THE HEART OF DOWNTOWN SMITHTOWN.
Delicious food and friendly atmosphere. . . Service was also exceptional and most attentive!
Celebrated my sister and brother in laws birthday. Buteras is our go to place when celebrating birthdays because they always accommodate our large group with ease. Food was great and service was excellent!
We went to Buteras in Smithtown on Saturday night. My shrimp had a strange taste (which my husband did not agree with when he tasted it- guess it was me!). We called the waitress over and explained this. Her (quick) reaction was to offer to either remake the dish or get me something else. She did not question my opinion at all. The replacement came out quickly (I did not want to re-try the shrimp!). The owner, Jimmy, came over to make sure everything worked out okay and apologized that I should have been inconvenienced. After we finished our meal, he gave us a round of after dinner drinks on the house. We really appreciated how this was handled. We highly recommend Buteras in Smithtown! great Italian food.
food was good but expensive, table was so tiny I had no place to rest my arms. decent experience but no real wow factor.
Awesome, everything was incredible, a terrific mid day treat.