Always love BMC. Get the ribcap!

There's a reason why we're there every other week. Exceptional food & service. Never a bad time...

The food was very good, although Very pricey. The service was good, but they were very persistent at clearing the table when we were all just sitting and nibbling. The woman’s bathroom was out of soap. I did tell the worker but I don’t think they filled it right away because when my daughter went a little later, she had to tip the bottle that I’d already unscrewed the top and laid on it’s side.

Everything about the dining experience was memorable. The service was some of the best that we have ever had. Our server was great. Very knowledgeable and made great suggestions about the menu. The food came out in a timely matter. The presentation was beautiful. Everything was cooked and seasoned to perfection. We will definitely be back soon. Thank you for an amazing dining experience.

Great food & service, but was pricey for the wagyu for 2.

I had an incredible time!

Bartenders on the evening (we sat at 7:30, on Saturday Nov.6) were phenomenal.

Wait staff was greats tomahawk was fine but not great as hoped. In fact the strip steak had more flavor and was better. Process for electronic gift card or good. Becomes a process at end when trying to pay. Should be able to provide as a note at time of reservation and server can apply to bill. Overall solid experience and would come back but two bits of constructive feedback. Thx!

Used to be my go to steak house. Over the past year I have been massively disappointed. Quality of the steak has deteriorated - in particular the tomahawk. The fries tasted as though they were using frozen fries from a packet. Heart broaden as I used to love the spot.

This was a great choice for a birthday dinner. We shared the ribeye for one...which is huge, and it was arguably one of the best pieces of meat I have ever had. Don't miss the baked oysters as a starter. Wine list was great too...with some small vintages and unique picks available. Beautiful room and lots of people watching available.

We sat outside. It was a bit chilly, but the heater above us helped us warm up. The service was excellent.

The food review:
*Broiled oyster - good, similar to a clams casino
*Kale salad - this was very good
*Porterhouse - Expensive! We asked for medium rare, came out more like medium, but still tasty.
*Salmon - the server recommended medium, came out well done and overcooked.
*Mushroom side - good
*12 layer chocolate cake - decadent

The bill was quite a sticker shock, but this was a special occasion, so this is a treat. So this is not a regular spot to dine often.

Food was exceptional. Staff was great and we did bit feel rushed.

Food quality very mixed. Some good cuts and some very poor cuts (like 50% was fat).

The steak was excellent as was the house made ricotta. The bacon was overcooked and chewy and the string beans had to be sent back b/c so much salt. The service was fantastic.

Menus seemed smaller. Only one salad option.

Amazing steaks ! Great service from servers and staff. One of the best meals I’ve ever had in my life ! Broiled oysters were fabulous to start with. Definitely coming back.

Delicious experience. Very good service, and mouth watering food. Just a bit windy and food gets cold easily, but that's just part of NYC!

By far one of my favorite steakhouses. Food is delicious. Ambiance is chill with a cool vibe. Service always top notch.

The ribeye is the way to go.

Service and ambiance were excellent, but my steak was over cooked.

-Food was delicious.
-The staff was very kind and attentive.
-Get the duck lasagna. Even if you don’t eat duck. Get it, it’s phenomenal. So are the broiled oysters.

The restaurant has a nice ambiance but IMO, severely overpriced. Ordered the Tomahawk for 2, cooked medium, and it tasted as if it was well done, in addition to being cold. I wouldn't put this restaurant as high on value, $460 out of pocket between 2 people with the Meatballs being the best part of the meal. Maybe covid is to blame

Absolutely amazing!

Thank you for excellent service all around

Great meal as usual, busiest I have ever seen which was awesome. Music a bit loud. But always the best meal!

Amazing food and service and great seating outside.

A great place overall - but hideously expensive !!

The staff was so accommodating! Great dinner!

Remains unequivocally, the best steakhouse in the city. The panned mix has not taken off any of the sheen, rather they seem to be doing an even better job all round - sourcing of meats, service, staff friendliness ( Paul eat al), sommelier knowledge base, moment of first impression at the host/hostess stand.. keep it up!

Delicious for any occaaion

This is the first disappointing meal I’ve had here, so much has change including service and quality of food. They removed their signature cote de boeuf steak from the menu, and added a 50 dollar “covid fee” to the tab. I wish they would have warned us before we sat down, that’s just highway robbery. The 50% indoor capacity meant closing down half of the restaurant dining area and jamming people into tables next to each other. I don’t understand the logic here, it’s just utterly ridiculous. The worse part was that i made a reservation for outdoor dining and when i showed up they had none available. I’ve been a big fan of BMC for many years, maybe new management? Who knows but i do know that is probably the last time i will go there.

Excellent steak, but you will pay for quality.

Incredible food. Great service. Definitely come back and enjoy another meal here.

Our favorite restaurant. The first place we went to go indoor dining since Feb 2020!

Food didn’t disappoint. Most delicious chateaubriand ever.

Amazing food, lovely service. Definitely pricy, but if you're in desperate need of a celebration like we were (and a great outdoor dining setup!) this is the place.
Worth mentioning, it may be a steak forward restaurant but the broiled oysters and bricked chicken were out of this world.

One of the best meals and dining experiences I have ever had. Cannot wait to go back!

This is really a very delicious meal. Excellent service.

First timer here and I had a wonderful experience. The service was phenomenal. The food was really good and well priced. I want to visit again before I head back home. I was in NY for business. It’s a must!

this is now the coolest steak restaurant in NYC. Makes a great change from the more traditional joints in the city. Great décor, old school hip hop playing, excellent staff and great cocktails all set the scene for an incredible menu.

We had the east coast oysters 5/5, Meatballs 5/5, Ribeye Steak 5/5, Bone in Filet 4.5/5. Steaks have a great char style and come as big portions (20oz bone in rib eye). The sharing cuts look impressive but we didnt get to try. It's definitely pricey, meal for two hit around $440 when you add in a bottle of wine and some cocktails. Overall it was definitely worth it.

Seating seems very crowded indoors given Covid precautions. They said the capacity count was within regulation but seating felt tight.