Bonfyre American Grille
To compliment the cuisine, Bonfyre’s bar features classic cocktails with a modern twist, creative new libations, domestic craft beer selections and a wine list consisting of 60 labels from both North and South America.
As always, the food and service is great. We always enjoy the Sunday morning brunch.
Definitely make a reservation. Very busy. Usually the steak is good but mine was way overdone. Server brought it back to the kitchen leaving me with my green beans and potato. Rest of the party was nearly done eating by the time the new steak arrived. Sadly lacked flavor.
Hi my party was annoyed with how you charged for drinks. If a drink is $10.00 charge $10.00. Don’t charge for ice. Find a better computer system. I know one person in the party won’t return. Food and service were great!
Disappointed because food was very blan. Staff was very nice, but I would never go back based on quality of food.
Service was excellent and so was the food. Definitely worth a repeat visit.
Very good service and excellent food.
I had grilled shrimp with sticky rice and green beans. It was all amazing. Service was fast and friendly. I will most definitely be back. I am hearing impaired but I was seated in a big booth and I could hear my friend in our conversation. Very nice lunch.
Lunch at Bonfyre was the perfect restaurant to treat my brother to lunch on his birthday. The friendly service made our lunch time relaxing. We both enjoyed our very tasty lunches. Looking forward to my next lunch date at the outstanding Bonfyre Grill.
Food was very good and large portions. The service was excellent. The server was delightful and enhanced the experience.
I have enjoyed Bonfyre a few times and have always been well pleased. The meal and drinks were very good. And the service by Sterling was excellent. I do recommend Bonfyre and look forward to my next visit.
We had the steak wedge salad, Grilled Seafood Trio, and Jambalaya , all were excellent.
Our party of 6 (one child) were at Bonfyre Grilll on a Tuesday night - which was relatively empty. Most of us ordered the Filet Mignon with the sides being steamed veggies and twice baked potato.
Two of us had to send our steaks back to be remade because the steak was overcooked. What a circus this was! The waiter asked my husband if he would like his sides while his steak was remade which he took, however he didn't ask me the same question.
My replacement steak was brought out within 5 minutes and it looked and tasted like it had been sitting under a heat lamp for quite some time. It was thin and mostly cold as was the cold, over baked flat potato. I did not eat either.
Filet Mignon had been highly recommended. At $32.00 per plate, we certainly expected better.
We had a wonderful celebration dinner. Many thanks.
Food was great. Service not the best. Our waiter never smiled once and was not around a whole lot. We weren’t aroundalotof other tables but it was still hard to hear ourselves. But I would still go back.
Highly recommend the seafood risotto and the blood orange cosmo!
I and a friend ordered the Prime Rib. Both of us were served the toughest piece of prime rib that either of us had ever had before. Neither of us were able to eat even half.
It was excellent in every way! Our server was spectacular!
Great eclectic menu! I was there on a Monday night during spring break and it was quiet.
Amos , the server was great very attentive and well-paced. The jambalaya was excellent and the whole experience was great for a business lunch
I really enjoy visiting this establishment for birthday dinners & my family joins me. We have seen many people fall when walking from the step up seating area. This time was no exception & my brother fell twisting his ankle. I would appreciate neon taping on the step so someone else doesn’t get hurt worse. It is dark in there & I feel this would help greatly. Other than that the food & experience were wonderful
We had a great time for a birthday dinner for 6. Great service. Table was too small for all our food and drinks.
We visited on a snowy Friday evening upon arriving home from out of town. We called on short notice, but were able to relax and enjoy our meal after a long trip before heading to the grocery store. We got such pleasant and quick service and the food is reliably good, particularly the beef. We were so pleased that the restaurant was open and available to us that night.
Very nice evening with friends from out of town. Food very good, Server was excellent.
We have been to Bonfyre many times and have enjoyed each visit! Always delicious food, kind and knowledge staff members, and warm atmosphere. Perfect for fun group gatherings or romantic date nights!
Delicious! A little pricey but worth every penny. Service was great too.
The kitchen went above and beyond to make wallet gluten free for us, and it was the best wallet we ever had. No breading, but the flavor was out of this world; cooked to perfection. Server was very helpful and a joy to be around. Great place & great service.
Four of us enjoyed a warm Friday night dinner. Two of us ordered delicious ribs, while the other two had walleye, which was also quite tasty!
Our server was friendly and efficient.
It was a tad loud due to the popular bar, but we were still able to have easy conversation.
We will be back!
Really good menu.
We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience at Bonfyre. We had oysters and shrimp cocktail for an appetizer and they were delicious. The meal was perfectly timed and we had time for conversation before our entree’s arrived. My companion had the fish special and I had the wood fired mixed grill. We tried each others meal and they both were fantastic. A bit pricey, but the atmosphere, gourmet food and attentive service are worth it. We’ll be back!
Great service, great food. Loves the atmosphere, food and drinks.
Solid business lunch destination.
Solid, reliable go to business lunch meeting place.
Great as ysual
Such an amazing experience! We went and celebrated our 3 year anniversary, the food was delicious, the server was very kind and intuitive to our requests and questions. The staff truly made this experience exceptional. Will be returning!!
Always a great meal at Bonfyre.Something for everyone.It is our go to place!
It was incredible!
Nice service. Had to send back a filet for more time on the grill but this was done politely and promptly.
Met with friends who had moved away from Madison years age. Food was great and service wonderful. Recommend highly for a casual, nicer dining experience.
Went for a fancy dinner on the cheap side and had a great time! Had great food (the chicken parm was AMAZING) for less than $30 a person. Would definitely go back for some future date nights
Crystal was our server and she rocked! My steak was good, but not the best I've ever had. We'll go back, that's for sure