Bonfyre American Grille
To compliment the cuisine, Bonfyre’s bar features classic cocktails with a modern twist, creative new libations, domestic craft beer selections and a wine list consisting of 60 labels from both North and South America.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Grilled Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Five grilled bacon wrapped shrimp stuffed with jalapenos and blended cheese
Bonfyre Cheese Curds
Stout beer-battered, buttermilk, cheddar cheese curds topped with parsley and served with a side of Sriracha Ranch
Six shrimp, Asian slaw and fresh vegetables, and sticky rice
Kevin...great waiter. Knew when to step back and let us visit as we celebrated an early Mother’s Day.
Food is dependable. The Fig and Prosciutto flatbread pizza...VERY good!
Always great food and service!
Great food, in a convenient location and nice ambiance. A Madison favorite.
We have date night each week and we are trying new restaurants. It was a good night and vibe. It wasn’t really busy which was great and they did a great job with social distancing and the waiters wearing masks and gloves. Food came out quickly and was plenty!! We got ahi tuna salad and 12oz steak.
Amazing food all around. Nothing was bad. Wish I could eat it for every meal.
Awesome food abd service
Food and drinks were great, service was even greater.
The food was really good. The server had a very positive personality. The service was excellent. All around a great place to go grab some dinner.
Had great food and plenty of it. Our server was very pleasant and attentive. We had a nice time chatting with the couple two tables away, there had to be space due to COVID, regarding desserts. We plan on coming here more.
Drinks were way too strong. Meals underwhelming in taste, but good on portions. The appetizers were delicious though. Desserts basic, but alright.
I had never been there before and I loved everything about it. Would definitely
The bartender was extremely nice and our drinks were some of the best we've ever had! Our waiter (Kevin) was excellent as well. We love dining at Bonfyre...especially for the Mort's pot roast and jambalaya.
Great food and ambiance. Our server was amazing and checked in on us. Kids loved their food as welll. Nice find during our quick trip to Madison.
Absolutely amazing. Great Service and the food was excellent 🥰❤️
I took my wife there to celebrate her retirement earlier on that day. The whole experience was great, food, waiter & place. It was a nice end to a busy day, we will be back.
One of the most memorable of our Daddy Daughter Date nights. My daughter loved Bonfyre. Service was amazing. Everything was perfect and made for a special time for the two of us.
good food - nice ambience - covid protocols observed
The atmosphere is wonderful, and the food was very good.
We haven't been to Bonfyre in years and only ended up going because they could fit our party of 7. I'm thrilled that we did! Everything from the raspberry mojitos (many restaurants don't carry mint year round. No idea why), to our appetizers of cheese curds and bacon wrapped shrimp, to the rotisserie chicken, ribs, and steaks were outstanding. When they claim to have fall-off-the-bone ribs, they're not kidding. Stupendous! And gotta mention the service. Jen was fantastic and diligent and very patient with my hard of hearing dad lol. We'll definitely be back.
The social distancing felt very safe. All staff wearing masks. The food was outstanding as always and the staff were amazing
Food was great and so was the service
The service was impeccable and the food and drinks were delicious! Loved the Ahi appetizer and the Pomegranate Mule was outstanding.
Very good experience. Menu seems slimmed down from last time we were there.
We were seated in a back room and their were 2 VERY LOUD women in the same room. We should have asked to be seated elsewhere.
Our server was amazing. The calamari was a bit saltier than normal but still good.
Just a bit noisy that's all. The end table next to a round by the window just didn't feel very cozy and the noise level seemed high
Our service, and all were great! Could not have had a better atmoshere to celebrate.
Thank you again for your service for an eventful night for my family!!
Food felt like it was from a chain. Did not seem like it was cooked from scratch at restaurant. Nice surrounding.
They were out of the Valentine's Special, which was the main reason for choosing this spot. Reservation was for 6:30pm, which was still early in the dinner service to be running out of a special.
We have always had good experiences at Bonfyre. This didn’t quite live up to its usual deliciousness, but we did enjoy our dinner there.
Celebrated Valentine’s Day early to avoid the crowds and it was lovely!
Bonfyre Grille always does a great job whenever we visit. The food is excellent and the staff well trained and friendly. We last visited on a weekday afternoon and felt very welcomed. We continue to be especially impressed by a particular staff person who doubled as our bartender and table server on this day. She has helped us in the past as well. I do not recall her name, but she is always kind, friendly, and accommodating. We have noted it previously and certainly appreciate all her efforts. She is representing the company very well doing outstanding work.
Great experience. Delicious food. Wonderful evening. Definitely recommend and will go back!
The waitress was friendly. Unfortunately, that was the highlight of our evening. Our dinners were disappointing. It also is exceptionally smoky in the restaurant. We will not be returning.
We had a delightful date night at Bonfyre. We started with the fig martini, which was very yummy and a Manhatten. Service was great, pan fried walleye and a miso bowl was delicious. Thanks Bonfyre for a memorable, fun evening!
Good food at a good price. A nice mixed menu.
I would recommend.
It was our first time dining here. WOW! The service was great and the food was phenomenal. One of the best Ahi Tuna salads I’ve ever consumed. Will definitely be returning and would highly recommend!
Service and food always excellent at Bonfyre. Food was served quickly and was amazing as usual!
Dinner with friends on Friday night. We were glad to see there were a lot of people at the bar and the restaurant. Every one was socially distanced and the staff were wearing masks and gloves.
Service was attentive and paced perfectly so we were never wanting. I highly recommend the house bourbon old fashioned. Hand made and very tasty. My friend is a rib fanatic and he says these are the best in Madison. Sweet sauced and falling off the bone tender served with fries and slaw. Morts pot roast was another hit. Very tender and flavorful roast served with tender crisp asparagus and carrots with a side of mashed potatoes. The last two dinners are steaks. My friend ordered the filet medium and I has the New York strip rare. Both steaks were well seasoned and prepared to perfection. Twice baked potato and the best green beans in town come with the steaks. Sorry no room for dessert.
I was so glad to see this place was open again. The tables were well spaced out and our server was delightful and attentive. She also seemed grateful to have the business. Menu seemed paired down (understandably!) but it still had a lot of excellent variety. Well done, Bonfyre!
Bonfyre American Grille offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 273-3973.
Bonfyre American Grille is rated 4.7 stars by 2419 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.