BlackFly - St Augustine

Excellent food and good service. Scallops and flounder, fresh and tender. Salads crispy with excellent dressing.

Awesome experience in every way! Our waiter Jerrod was very knowledgable concerning the menu items and was very attentive to our needs.

I frequent the restaurant because there’s a reason I come from Long Island and I like good food I know good food I come from a restaurant family if you restaurants that are owned by the same people are excellent blackfly has quality quality food right now you for the dollar and their other place collage is also excellent looking for to the top restaurants in Saint Augustine this is it

Incredible fried shrimp and coconut lobster along with the fried rice and shrimp that right there is an amazing meal

Scott B
Saint Augustine

Made a reservation for dinner and it was wonderful. Our server Kaitlyn was attentive and knowledgeable. Food was outstanding bar service was quick. The pizza was great as well as the scallops. Hope we can return the next time we are in town

The quality is always superb, noise level was rather high. Cocktails were a little pricey.

Very Tasty!! Great Service!!!!👍👍👍👍

The food was great - service outstanding - the salads were remarkable.

We have eaten at The Blackfly in St. Augustine many times. The menu items have changed and they removed some of our favorites, the sushi and the crab cakes. Overall the food was good, however, in the past it has been better.

Best ever Brussel sprouts and scallops, and crab cakes

Staff was professional & friendly from the time we entered until we departed - fried flounder was very good as were the desserts (crepe brûlée & key lime pie).

All was fine. Food as usual was very well done. Drink was also done well.

Nice place. Good food. Not outstanding but good.

This was a nice restaurant. The bread and butter and desserts were delicious. My sister got the scallops special which was tasty but all it had was scallops and a lot of brussel sprouts. The pork shoulder was just okay. Nothing spectacular. Service was great and the food came out quickly. Worth giving a try.

Great wine list! Friendly atmosphere! Food was delicious! My husband had Strip steak cooked perfectly medium rare and I had the crab carbonara! Would go back weekly if we lived in St. Augustine. Liz and Gordon

Food was amazing and our server (Alex) was outstanding.

Tables could gave been farther apart during covid. The food and service was outstanding. Haven't had a better piece of beef in a long time.

Eclectic menu
Excellent service
Added bonus Martini Monday

Probably one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine. Food , service great
Wish they had a bigger selection of fresh fish . But all in all very good.

This restaurant does a fantastic job. The food, service and atmosphere was outstanding. Our server, Jessie did a fabulous job in serving us. Highly recommend BlackFly for an enjoyable dinner.

Everything was well prepared and service was very good. Just as we’ve experienced previously and as expected from the professional staff at Blackfly.

Had a wonderful time for our 5 year anniversary!! Food was top notch and service excellent l! We’ll definitely be back

Seafood is great as usual! But let's not forget about the pizza too!

All around great food and experience. Will always go back

Wonderful, as always!

Fun place for dinner and drinks. Great food surrounded with ideal ambiance. One of our top 5 in all of St. Augustine and # 1 for the Banana Bread Pudding!

Black Fly never disappoints!
The food was delicious, the ambiance was wonderful and the service was on point. Thank you for a great dining experience.

Great food and service!! The lobster was especially good.

George was are waiter- excellent, , friendly , and efficient!

I was expecting more based on the restaurant's "ranking", but was disappointed by the lack of ambiance and high prices. While the food was good and the wine selection very adequate, the quality wasn't particulary noteworthy and the portions were relatively small. On the plus side, the waitress was very pleasant and knowledgeable and there was no problem getting a reservation. For the money, there ae better options in St Augustine.

Good as always. A little noisy

I had the Dynamite Salmon and it was excellent!! My husband had the Tuna which was also excellent. Key Lime Pie was very flavorful but I would have preferred a lighter crust.

Excellent food and drinks

I have never been disappointed at this restaurant. Justin was a great server. Carrissa S is also great and very fun.z

Overrated and overpriced. I’ll not be eating there again

Blackfly is a wonderful fine dining restaurant with a casual approach. They feature a superb cuisine with all the favorites, and tantalizing specials, a diverse and complete international wine menu, great cocktail and aperitifs, and after dinner selections, and outstanding, attentive friendly service. I love coming here and I am a frequent patron.

Great food! Would highly recommend the steaks! Will be back again!

Nice people. Great environment. Super food

Fun decor. Food was just average. Very expensive. Overall, it was disappointing. Not sure I would recommend this restaurant.

Proportions were a little small, but the food was good. Are you up being a kid didn't enjoy their mojito with the local rum.

Good as always.