We drive over an hour to get to this restaurant and it’s worth every mile. It’s one of our favorite places; actually, it’s probably our favorite! The waitstaff are top notch and the entire place goes the extra step to make things so inviting. The food is always delicious and very fresh.
The crab cakes are amazing and a terrific value. Real crab meat and well seasoned. Everything we had was great but the ribs were disappointing. They were not the “fall off the bone” ribs that I would expect and they were dry. Perhaps we were unlucky that night. The service was outstanding and we enjoyed our visit. Certainly good enough to return in the future.
We were seated right away upon arrival for our reservation at 7:00 pm. Our server was great and our meal was very good. We both had the surf and turf, fillet was done just perfect and the lobster was pretty tasty. Hot rolls with the sweet butter were very good also. This was the first we were in for a very long time and was very pleased with everything. I think we will be coming back more often.
Steak was not prepared as ordered. Well done. Was ordered medium rare. Very dry.
The place was very cold the night we were in. We tried the new brick over pizza. It was decent, but I don’t need to go back just for that.
My biggest request would be for them to go back to the fresh cut fries. They were good and differentiated the restaurant from others in the area. Now, they are just like the rest serving frozen mediocre French fries. Burgers are still very good.
Our waitress was great! She described the types of foods listed on the menu. The ribs were the best. Scallops were tasty also,
My son and I had a dinner near his college and it was just right
We always ask to be in the bar area and we love it!! The restaurant is more quiet and is good for bigger groups.
Every time is fantastic, food and service is great, a lot of options for food and drink.
Love this restaurant!! Great food - especially their steak!!, and awesome service!
Always great to go there, my wife is picky and see loves the food here!
Food was very good not a large selection to choose from.
Sent email already and no response. Worst meal I have ever had dining out. Ribs were burnt,steak was terrible piece of meat and way over cooked and burnt and steak on salad was burnt and over cooked. Meat should fall off of ribs. So disappointed. Taking family out to eat and driving 45 minutes to get there for that!
Great dinner with great service. We were up stairs with a group of us and there were a few other groups. A bit noisy but we helped with that too!
THE FOOD AND SERVICE IS GREAT AS ALWAYS. FROM THE RIBS AN SCALLOPS TO THE SALADS
AND ROLLS. A GREAT PLACE TO EAT!
Awesome meals! Amy - amazing service!
Thoroughly enjoyed ourselves!
2nd visit. Loved it as much the 2nd time as the first. Great service, absolutely wonderful food (we had salad, scallops, steak, and salmon). Will definitely go back, even though it's pricey. The food is THAT good.
Our experience was ok.
Food was good. Service was good.
What a great restaurant! If you are looking for a nice steak house house, with great service, great food and a great atmosphere - this is the place to go to!
BJ’s is a local hot spot, a must visit location during a stay in the area. Wait staff is awesome. A great menu worth the price.
The service was phenomenal and the food was good though nothing to write home about, but we paid entirely too much $ for what we got. The oysters are overpriced and the steaks are far too expensive for only being 6 Oz sirloins. We have no problem paying a lot when we go out to eat, but we were disappointed in the value at BJ’s.
New menu with great variety of choices without being overwhelming. My father ordered the salmon special which he thought was delicious. My mother got the half rack, which never disappoints. I got a simple French Onion soup and salad. Everything was very tasty, (except soup lacked that great bubbly mozzarella cheese that French Onion soup is known for). Our waiter was excellent- very charismatic and attentive. And he made the evening extra special by topping the yummy meal off with a Chocolate Sundae in celebration of my father’s birthday.
Great relaxed atmosphere! Friendly, knowledgeable server! Very much enjoyed the raw oyster bar!
Super fly and groovy place to eat. Prices are a tad bit high.
The food is outstanding! Love the presentation! Wait staff always friendly!
We had no idea that downtown Selinsgrove is so quaint! Very happy we found BJ's!
It was enjoyable. We will go again
Favorite place to visit when we are in town. Great menu selection.
Excellent every time!
Good food Good service everyone is always friendly .
We were in town for a wedding, we all met up the night before had dinner and drinks. Staff was very friendly food was good. We had a great time and would recommend for sure.
we had an excellent experience. the food was great and plentiful. the waitress was excellent, very pleasant and attentive. the atmosphere was very nice. will be returning again.
did not care for the ribs and the fries I thought were fresh cut but not so and the online menu is not up to date so I guess this a one and done for me.
The food was great. The wait staff was very helpful and friendly. I will definatly come back.
We were very please with the food and service we received that night. It was my wife's very first time being there. Thank you
BJ’s is my favorite restaurant in Selinsgrove. I just took my husband and son for dinner and we all enjoyed our meals.
I have no idea how many times that my husband and I have dined at BJ's. We just keep coming back. It is a destination restaurant for us. The food is delicious and innovative. Usually, I order the New Bedford Scallops which I adore! The wine choices, the excellent cocktails and the scrumptious desserts all make for a fantastic dining experience!
Food was great and our waitress added to the experience. Very pleasant and checked on us just enough to make sure we had everything we needed without interrupting us every couple of minutes
Oysters and calamari were excellent
Fried pickles soggy
Ribs were very average
Waitress was okay
Lady at front not nice at all