When you think traditional, top-notch Italian cuisine with impeccable service - you're thinking Benny's. It's got all of the old world charm without feeling dated - and the menu has everything you've loved about Italian food since you were a kid, plus all of the things you learned to appreciate as your palate matured. I honestly cannot say enough about the service at this restaurant - you're treated like you are the most important person in the restaurant and everything is perfect always. You won't get flashy, you won't get gimmicky - you get classy and delicious!
We went to Benny’s to celebrate our daughter’s engagement. The staff made the night even more special and the food was excellent.
While the food was very good, the service was very slow for our group apparently because they had been booked for a larger lunch event at the same time, and they had insufficient staff, both in terms of the chefs and waiters to serve us in a reasonable time period. What should have been an hour or so lunch, lasted more than two hours. Nevertheless, the food was very good.
Overall extremely pleased. It is a little pricing for recurring meals. Absolutely recommend
It was our third time to Benny's everything was as good as the first time. Benny is a wonderful host. He makes it a point to walk around to each table and chat with you. Cant wait to go back. His veal dishes are great and so is the gnocchi in the veal ragu sauce.
This was my first visit to Benny's and I must say - every course was delicious! I especially loved the trout special and the flourless chocolate cake. Plus, the super courteous wait staff went out of its way to make sure my gluten free needs were well taken care of. We felt like special guests at a friend's home. That's not so easy to find these days and I look forward to visiting again soon.
Benny’s is a neighborhood institution. The food and service are outstanding, and if you’re lucky, Benny will come by and tell you stories about his life and the restaurant.
The shrimp with champagne sauce special was fantastic!! This should be on the menu every day!
Have been here at least a half dozen times over last two years...is consistently very good in terms of food, service and ambiance.....never lets me down
Food was fine as usual but service was terrible. We went for a nice night out but were served like a fast food restaurant. Out in 45 minutes. We said we were in no hurry, but we got the bums rush. Suggest you order appertiser first and wait to order entre
Delicious! Warm atmosphere and friendly service.great veal dishes.
Whenever we have concert tickets to "The Space" in Westbury, we always go to Benny's for dinner before the concert. The location is perfect, the food is always wonderful, and we enjoy Benny's very such. Prices are great and portion size is perfect.
Great service, great food, authentic cuisine. Pleasant dining experience.
Great food and dining.
As always we enjoyed impeccable service. The Food was superb . I had a plain grilled veal chop that was not on the menu. We also ordered the stuffed rainbow trout. Both entrees were great. For starters we shared the buratta and the beet salad. Each was served as separate portions. This is definitely my favorite place to come for a "class act" dinner.
Great food great people
Valentine’s Day dinner with my lady.
Generally good but on our last visit they were short on a few items including pizza bread and ice cream!!! We could not understand when they told there out of stock on those items.. Otherwise, we did enjoy our dining. Would try them again.
Great food and outstanding service
I highly recommend it
Always excellent and authentic
Benny was delightful. I love when the owner takes the time to meet and engage in conversation.
With Benny's constantly being on the list for top restaurants on Long Island I had I expectations. The service was great, the food OK, a bit on the salty side. The house wine by the glass was pricey. I will give it another try however.
The whole family went - including our two young kids. Everyone really enjoyed dinner. The service is friendly and attentive. The food is delicious and fresh. The starters of Fried Calamari, Spiedino Alla Romano, Beef Carpaccio and Eggplant Rollatini were all very nice. The mains of Veal Sorrentina and the Bucatini con Le Sarde Alla Siciliana were very good. The kids loved the Fettuccine Carbonara which reminded me more of an Alfredo. We watched them make the Zabbaglione fresh - very good stuff. The kids loved the tartufo - the ice cream in it was very creamy. I was really pleasantly surprised and would recommend Benny's.
Excellent Italian cuisine....
We have been fans and patrons of Benny's for years and always enjoy the food and service. This time we took guests with us and they agreed.
Very professional service, great food, father and son owners actively working a busy restaurant. Would have given 5 stars for service; but had to wait 30 minutes before getting up and requesting the check
They are always wonderful here. The food is delicious and they serve you with old style grace. I always have a terrific time here and have it on my list of favorite places. It is authentic Italian cuisine done at the highest quality level.
Excellent experience as always.
It is the best Italian.
Bennys is great. I have been coming here for years. Besides the excellent food and service, Benny himself makes it a point to greet each guest by name. Its always a pleasure having a chat with benny.
If you are looking for great italian food, go to Bennys. You will not regret it.
Excellent food and service. The menu offers a varied selection of Italian specialties. Our dinner tasted liked you were sitting in someone's kitchen.
Lovely atmosphere, delicious food, excellant service and you can even carry on a conversation! Have eaten here many times and have never been dissappointed!
Very warm atmosphere, attentive service. Food delicious. Best of all you can hear the conversations without having to shout at your companions!
Benny's Ristorante has been a fixture in Westbury for longer than we lived in the area (37 years). Fortunately we didn't move far away so we can get back often. The pasta dishes are fabulous, especially the Fettuccini Carbonara and the Bucatini con le Sarde alla Siciliana, which are two of my favorites. They will serve them as a main dish or appetizer. Other appetizers on my list are the Pappardelle Frutta di Mare (fresh pasta) and the Eggplant alla Benny (usually on the Special List). Main Course take your pick. I have never had one I didn't enjoy and I always look forward to enjoying one of the special dishes for the evening.
The staff is always friendly, extremely accommodating and if you have a special request, all you have to do is ask. (Note: If you have a very special occasion and you would like a quiet little table in the corner...literally, ask for the wine room. It's a table tucked in the wine room perfect for two or four). The main dining room is calm enough to allow for quite table conversation but lively enough let you know that you're not the only one having a good time.
If you live anywhere nearby or are traveling to the area I highly recommend letting the food and charm of this well established local restaurant provide you with an enjoyable night out.
We all enjoyed our meals. Portions were good yet everyone cleaned their plate. Our children (12 and 9) loved the salmon dish. Very attentive, pleasant service. The only thing that brings down my overall rating ever so slightly is the fact that we found it a bit cool in the restaurant, especially with temperatures outside in the teens, it would have been nice to have a little more heat. Nevertheless, we had a nice meal and enjoyed our time.
It's too bad that it's only a 5 star option. I would rate Bennys a 10! We were there on New year's eve. This was a wonderful dining experience. The food and service were wonderful! We do dine at the finish nyc restaurants. This was by far a great dining experience. Cannot wait to go b a ck!!!!
Benny's is always wonderful in all respects. It is a pleasure to dine there. We love it.
This was a get together holiday dinner of "cousins". Benny's was selected because they offered Bucatini con le Sarde alla Siciliana, a dish that's not easy to find on Long Island. The dish did not disappoint. Other dishes and appetizers (Eggplant Rollatini especially) did not disappoint as well. The service was great. We ordered multiple appetizers and the staff separated them equally among the six of us before bring them to the table - a very nice touch. Benny's is on our repeat list.
Food was very good. Generous portions. Very slow service.
Fabulous traditional Italian meal. As always. All home made pasta! And one of the only restaurants left serving traditional Zabione desert. Very friendly and Attentive staff.
Classic old school Italian restaurant. Never had a bad meal here. Highly recommend.
Consistently delicious over the oat 15 years and many many meals.