Join us Mother's Day for our 3-course Prix Fixe menu!
Sunday, May 13, 2018
Really good appetizers, salad (bibb) and steak. The sauteed onions and mushrooms were less than impressive. Nice wine list. Really nice service - waiter even helped us from over-ordering food.
Best steak I’ve had. Simply fantastic.
Service was excellent and the waiter was attentive to every need. Food was prepared to the requested temperature, cannot say anything bad.
We were a group of ten - that celebrate annually after a ballgame. We all enjoy fine dining and this year we choose to eat at a fine steakhouse. The food was excellent — lamb, veal and beef dishes were all excellent. The service was excellent - friendly and engaging. They do have quieter areas - upstairs but we were a group of ten that were contributing to the group vibe downstairs - a excellent - traditional - upscale steakhouse experience
Delicious from start to finish , staff is knowledgeable and friendly
It was a casual yet classy experience of an American steakhouse
Staffs are all friendly
Cocktail shrimps with Benjamin salad are recommended for an appetizer
Awesome as always. Great service, fantastic food. Best steak in nyc.
This was a special dinner for someone who had never been to the states to try a USA steak. We didn’t realize how big the portions would be, very generous so come hungry. The steak was great. They also humored the vegetarian and made a veggie plate! The wine list is phenomenal. Our waiter was very friendly and welcoming.
Great service. Very attentive and accommodating. We will return. Thanks.
Awesome steaks and exceptional service. We’re from Australia, and we’ll be here again when we visit NY again next year!
Food is great as always and service is exceptional. My favorite restaurant. Peters from Roslyn
Third visit over past two years -- live in FL and return for dinner each time. As a very long-time customer (and card holder) of Peter Luger, I think I can speak with some credibility when I say that Benjamin's Steakhouse in the Dylan Hotel, NYC is my favorite. At this level of excellence, what differentiates one restaurant from another is less often any appreciable difference in the quality of the dry-aged Prime steaks served, but everything else brought to the table. Benjamin's strong menu offers a superior assortment of everything else whether enjoyed as appetizers or as a main course. The ambience is charming and cozy; the attention to detail provided by both the servers and management staff during the meal is never obtrusive. Simply, they want all of their customers to feel like VIPs. Have never had a better steak dinner experience anywhere else in the United States.
Everything was absolutely fantastic, the food, the service, the ambiance. I will definitely be back very soon
We had a pleasant time. The steak was amazing.
Excellent service and food. The atmosphere was very pleasant. The meat was perfectly cooked to order. Pricey but good value.
Steak was over cooked and tough. Should have been able to cut through it like butter. I was rather surprised. The flavor was good, but it should have been better.
Everything was great from John our waiter to the food. We will come back again.
Steak average at best. Sent first back, and waiter pompous
Had been here before. Steak is usually as you would expect from a steak house and very good. However, this time, my rib-eye was not as tasty as usual and seemed a bit undersized compared to past. Felt the meal was not as good as last time I was there and thus value for expensive meal was depreciated.
I never write reviews but had to this time. My husband and I had dinner here on Sunday for his birthday the service was impeccable, the porterhouse for 2 was mouthwatering and we love our porterhouse and the sides were amazing. We will definitely be back!
My family and I went for Easter dinner. The staff at Benjamin's is very attentive. And of course, the food is spectacular. The mashed potatoes and creamed spinach is the best I've ever tasted. It was an overall wonderful experience for my family.
Anniversary. Our waiter was fabulous
omelets were tasteless.
fresh fruit was good.
Toujours aussi agréable
Birthday for dad.
Over in NYC from the UK with family - great find and very pleased with food and wine. Good location although if was a little noisy inside but please were sat end of row upstairs.
Superb meal and service! Highly recommend!
Superb steak, atmosphere was good, though a bit loud close to the bar area
Food is excellent. Extremely noisy though, perhaps giving a feel of nya scene.
Coming from Alberta and used to AAA quality, the beef here is equally awesome. When I booked this restaurant it was more for my daughter who’s a meat and potatoes girl. She then sprang that she is now a vegetarian. They made her a huge plate of vegetables and was both flavourful and filling. The Chilean sea bass is huge and equally delicious. My oldest daughter had the surf and turf and was not disappointed either. We topped it off with creme brûlée. So good!
Nicole our bartender was phenomenal. We arrived just before the lunch crowd and chose to sit at the bar , rather than our table reservation. We chose the filet and the ribeye to share. The steak was exactly what we wanted with great wine. Will be back, close to GCS
Excellent waiter service
Poor crabcake, average meat
Seems to belong to another (past) epoch
For nostalgics only
Always excellent and this time the service was extra special.
The food and service were excellent. Would highly recommend Benjamin's Steak House. The Steaks were cooked perfectly and the wine was reasonable priced.
Every review I read states it's wonderful. They are 100% correct. Mario, the general manager, was so welcoming. We will definitely be back!
One of the best steakhouses in NYC! And actually, my favorite due to service. You feel like you’re the only patron it’s that special. Treat you like royalty and their porterhouse for 3 is to die for ... and don’t get me going over the hand cut slab bacon. No one can compete with Benji’s bacon!!!!!! Love that place. Mario the manager is one in a million when it comes to customer service. The best!
Was over from Scotland for 8 days, was staying on Park Avenue so decided to try a Steakhouse nearby and looked it up, seen the reviews, booked it and i was not disappointed, can say in all honesty has been the best Steak (ribeye on the bone) i have ever has and i have ate steak all round the world, the baked clams were very good, had the mash potatoes, creamed spinach and the sauteed mushrooms as sides, my 2 quests who dined with me were very impressed.....THANKS