Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Wed - Thu 5:00PM - 9:00PM
Great food and service! Good experience. Our server was very nice and made sure to answer questions.
This was not our first visit to Bay Harbor. So it’s not surprising that our experience was delightful. The food was excellent; and, even though she was in training, our server (India) was attentive and very friendly. All of that along with a wonderful view of the marina ... what’s not to like !?
Poor management, salty food, and bartender didn’t even know what a negorni is. Has promise but not a good mother’s day. VERY OVERPRICED. Server was very good shout out to Jaz.
A little too expensive. Sides were terrable steak was good side vegtable dried out carrot mashed potatoes with steak??? How about a baked potatoe.
Waitress was great. Hostess was not so good. She didn’t greet people. There was a bunch of us waiting and it looked like she was doing paper work. She never acknowledged us. This went on for over 10 min. There when we left she was no where to be found. We needed her to call a shuttle. Food was very good. Great view
Good food, but unprepared for Mother's Day weekend. Poor service. Hostess, waiter and bartenders all made excuses. Did not honor our request for window table even through some were open. Have eaten there before without these issues, so will give it another chance.
Bay Harbor is a lovely restaurant. Food and service were great. The view is beautiful!! For some reason though, they didn't have our reservation, because they hadn't connected Open Table to their system.
Food was amazing! Server was very nice and pleasant!
If you like seafood this is a great place to go. If you don't, they have a decent streak. Thank you to the staff for the birthday brownie.
Overall a nice experience! The filet was under cooked, medium was the ordered temperature, it was rare.
My medium filet was underdone and over salted. The second attempt was a smaller cut, better cooked but still over seasoned.
Excellent service. Excellent food. We had French Onion Soup, Perch dinner, Cheesecake with lemon sauce and beer. Lobster Bisque, Pecan crusted California Halibut, Carrot Cake and Moscato. It was a wonderful evening.
Nice veiw of the marina and restaurant was very nice. Food was very good.
Waitres was rude very condescending
Only good thing about this place was our server. Our server did a great job, but the $39 file was one of the worst steaks we have ever had. Definitely should not of been $39. You guys hype up this restaurant way too much online, and it is not at all what it looks like. Maybe we just got a couple bad steaks I hope.
One of our favorite restaurants. Only negative was a special order vegan entree which was wonderful but the size of an appetizer and priced more than anyone else’s entree. Next time we shall ask for cost in advance of service.
Fantastic food, fantastic staff, fantastic view in the very early spring.
Bay Harbor is one of the areas best restaurants. The food, wait staff, and atmosphere are consistently excellent. I will return soon!
Took my parents out to dinner here. It was a nice night out. The perch and walleye were amazing! Tad pricey but it’s a lovely place and I would go back again for a special occasion.
Excellent location to watch the sunset over Sandusky Bay. One of the best spots for walleye in the area.
It was just ok. No bay harbor salad, which they’re known for. The restaurant has cobwebs and all of the brass railing is so tarnished. You can tell it’s all about taking in the money but no love for the interior.
Overall, a very nice experience!
Steak was too rare (ordered medium), and a little tough.
Service was very good!
The Bay Harbor Inn is our favorite restaurant in the area. The atmosphere is so pleasant, and the food is EXCELLENT! Our waiter, Ed, can always be relied upon for excellent service. We highly recommend this restaurant.
The prices are not something that bothers us, but the quality of the food was terrible, our steaks ordered medium, and we got very, very rare, potatoes were cold, and the carrots were so hard, we could not chew them, the soup that we had as an appetizer was warm not hot as soup should be, the only thing that was good, that we enjoyed was our lobster, and from here on out, we don't look forward to ever coming back. We got to the places we can have lobster and steak. We feel our meal other then the lobster should have been comp. We were given $25.00 off should have been at least $50.00. Not the quality we expected ☹️
Great location, good menu! I'm sure the view is more impactful during the day - pleasant, spacious dining room. Food was quite good - not earth-shattering - but quite good.
Our server, Clay, was a total delight!!
Over the years we have eaten at this restaurant several times. Had only one bad experience which was New Years Eve. We went for Valentine’s Day this year and everything was fine. Had good service and food was good.
My husband and I had a wonderful Valentines dinner at Bay Harbor! The service was superb, the atmosphere was perfect as we were able to sit, relax and enjoy lovely conversation and the food was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend Bay Harbor for any event, it's a very special place!
Outstanding as usual.
This is one of our favorite restaurants. The food is always delicious. Our server, Abby, is absolutely wonderful and very professional. We always have an enjoyable evening when we dine at Bay Harbor.
The food was very good, but had to send it back because it was cold. The two waitresses we had were very good and very friendly.
Bay Harbor is *never* a bad idea and worth the drive. Always cool in Cedar Point's off season to make the 'trip' to the point and dine here. Upscale but not ultra exclusive. Not cheapo dining but you get what you pay for. I love grouper oscar myself. enjoy!
The restaurant called me the day of my reservation and told me they had to change it to an hour later. They said they never saw my open table reservation that I had made 3 weeks previously until that day! After 2 phone calls they ended up squeezing us in the lounge at our requested time but the atmosphere was not nearly as nice as the main dining area. Use caution and don't expect to keep your planned dinner time when booking at Bay Harbor. The manager was not very kind and did not care to make things right because of a mistake on their end.
A favorite New Years Eve destination for our family and friends. Food was delicious, service was excellent, atmosphere & environment was festive and comfortable. We will definitely return.
I can not believe that I have lived in the area my entire life (43 years) and didn't know this amazing place existed. The place is beautiful, the menu has lots to offer. Everything we tried was DELICIOUS! Best crab legs I've had in the area.
We made an Opentable reservation and the venue was closed for the season.
Delightful. Food, excellent. Service, wonderful. Atmosphere - quiet enough to hear the conversation, button dull. Will go there every chance I get.
Exemplary service and outstanding food selection. A Cedar Point restaurant open year round. Worth the trip even in the off season.
We had another excellent dining experience at the Bay Harbor. We weren't pleased a couple of years ago, with a new chef and some changes, but we gave them some time and all things are good now. Good wine list and good food, and the view is always first class.
Had the Clam Bake special for $51. Had it before and brought friends this time. Wonderful Clam Chowder, Steamed Clams, then a good size whole lobster, followed by Blueberry Cobbler. No one could eat it all. We all had plenty left to take home.
Delicious food. Beautiful view.