See availability for bonus point tables
Mon - Thu 5:00PM - 5:30PM 8:30PM - 9:00PM
Table for 6. ! Wait staff attentive . Food was great . Positive experience !
Exceeded expectations - everything from the great bread basket , service and food! I had the Porcini Ravioli with black truffle and they were AMAZING! All of the other food that everyone had was amazing as well!
We loved Basicilico. We have been there many many times. We had a 5 pm reservation and were a little early but were seated slightly early which was great because we had tickets for 7 pm at papermill. The waiter took our dinner and drink order which were reasonably served. At five after six our dinner had not yet been served and we asked for the manager. Some how at six fifteen our dinner was served. We asked for our check and gobbled down our meal. I suffered indigestion for the rest of the evening having had a very rushed meal that we were looking forward to. No explanation was never given and after all these years of going to Basilico we will definitely not going again. The meal was expensive and not worth the indigestion
My husband I went before a show at the Papermill Playhouse. We started with Polpo alla Griglia (an octopus Salad) and Antonella salad with goat cheese, figs and almonds . For our main course my husband had Chicken parmigiana and I had the Crostacei Fra Diavolo (shrimp and lobster in a spicy red sauce), and a banana tower for dessert. Everything was excellent! The atmosphere is quiet and relaxing, the wait staff is on top of your every need, and the food was incredible! Will make it our go to spot when in the area!
Delightful as always. Quality service and of cours scrumptious food.
Amazing every time!!! We keep going back because it’s just that good.
Basilico is one of our favorite restaurants. We frequent as often as we can, reservations fill up quickly. The service is terrific and the food is consistently wonderful. The portions are also plentiful. I highly recommend Basilico for any special occasion or just for a nice evening out.
We had lunch at Basilco and enjoyed it very much.
They have a very nice menu . The service was excellent
amazing northern italian fare priced reasonably for the high value delivered
Great food and outstanding service. We will definitely be heading back.
Basilico is our favorite Italian restaurant in the area. They are consistently fabulous in the kitchen and always extremely accommodating towards my food allergies which is VERY appreciated. I come for lunch with girlfriends, date night with the husband and we bring older relatives for family dinners. Everyone always leaves full and happy.
Great food and great service! We will definitely return.
Never disappointed!! Quality of food is amazing and menu is extensive.
Went for Easter dinner food was outstanding and totally lived up to my expectations. Service was very attentive and overall a great experience. I would suggest this place to anyone.
Always reliably good. Varied menus - so- plenty to choose from. Been there many times for lunch and dinner.
Always delicious and the portions are huge. Love that it is byob or you can buy their wine.
First time and food and service was great. Will return.
Wonderful as always!
Always at your Assistance with both fine Food & great Service!
Wonderful food and service start to finish. Only minor issue was that my husband’s veal chop was medium and not medium rare as he ordered. Would have sent it back but he didn’t want to wait. Otherwise, perfection. Not cheap but worth it. Our go-to Italian in Millburn.
Fabulous! Great meal, great service!
Fantastic dinner with food and service!!
Fabulous food and great service. Never disappoints!
Excellent food and service!!!!
A totally terrific meal EVERY TIME!!!
We dined here last Sunday and we'll be back next Sunday. Need I say anymore???
Disappointed. We’ve been eating at Basilico for years and found this last experience very disappointing. Food was average at best and $65.00 veal with $17.00 fois gras had to be sent back. It was rubbery and way over cooked. We received an apology, nothing more. Service was average at best, and waiter continued to over pour the wine, which is annoying at best. This isn’t the Basilico we grew to love.
We usually go to Basilio for dinner on Saturday nights: Today we decided to try their lunch menu. It was a very nice menu and the food was very fresh and delicious.
This is a very nice restaurant whether you are having lunch or dinner. Basilica is one of my favorite restaurant.
Manager and waiter very attentive, food excellent and save room for dessert is delicious!!
Amazing food. Fantastic service. Odd seating. They seemed to squeeze everyone together in one area while the rest of the restaurant was empty. Would have liked a little more space.
Everything was Excellent
The service was stellar and the food was delicious. I highly recommend!
The different dinner selections of the four of us were universally praised as excellent. The desserts were truly exceptional.......again, we all agreed. The attentiveness and courtesy of the servers was unusually good and sincerely appreciated. Best dining experience I can remember.
Everything was great. The artichoke app was very good. I had veal with asparagus in brandy cream sauce which was great; rich and tender. The extensive dessert menu makes this place a real find. Everything I tasted was very good, but my favorite was my chocolate souffle.
Excellent Italian food and service!!
1) Arancini - Rice Balls - lightly fried, and tasty.
2) Carciofini alla Piastra - grilled artichokes - solid choice; nicely grilled and simple seasoning makes for a refreshing start to the meal.
3) Burrata con Condiglione - mozzarella and tomatoes - very creamy and delicious.
1) Orata alla Mediterranea - filet of bass - good
2) Anatra Arrosto - Duck - good
1) Gnoochi with Vodka Sauce - excellent
1) Budino - Chocolate Pudding with Graham Crackers - very chocolately and rich; definitely share this with someone.
2) Torta Calda al Cioccolato - chocolate lava cake; standard for most restaurants.
Overall the food was very good.
Place is small and crowded during prime time; you can literally have a conversation with the table next to you because your tables are practically touching.
Service is rushed; it's a popular place, so they want your order in quick.
Always a good experience dining here and service implacable.
Always a fantastic experience. Great service and atmosphere. Every bite is delicious. Desserts are some of the best I've ever had.
Fantastic as always!!! Top notch Italian restaurant with high quality ingredients and great execution!
This is our third time at Basilico. It’s our go to spot for dinner before a show at the Paper Mill Playhouse. There are always interesting specials and everything we’ve had here was delicious. The service is attentive and friendly. We’ll definitely be back!
We enjoyed the small plates we ordered, especially the cauliflower, the garlic shrimp and the meatball. But everything was excellent and the portions were quite ample. We shared a half bottle of red wine which was very good. Our only complaint was a rather loud group nearby. And the parking situation is always an issue in Millburn.