Book your next event with us
Valentine's Day Special Menus & More
Valentine's Gala Dance to Live Music by the Felix Swing Band after 8:30 P.M. Eat Your Heart Out: a Multi-Course Menu from Cupid's Kitchen
$70. Pre-Theatre (music) $85.00 after 8:30 P.M. music & dancing A deposit of $50.00 required with your reservation. Not refundable after February 7th.
Thursday, February 14, 2019
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Daily 7:00PM - 10:00PM
Visited New York for the weekend and found Barbetta on Open Table. Great atmosphere, great food and friendly, family feel. Really good presentation of the food - especially the prosciutto and melon starter. The live pianist is a nice touch, too.
Delicious dinner. Very tasty. Nice atmosphere in an old classic setting. The meal was quick to get us to the show on time!
Simply put, AMAZING! Everything was perfect. From the ambiance to the food. Our hostess was a blast!
The only negative is they only offer a pre-theater menu on a Saturday and I really wanted to order from the full menu.
Beautiful dining room, elegant. Divers scallops were very bland. Chocolate mousse is delicious!
The ambiance, cuisine and decor was exceptional. My only disparaging comment was that the service left a great deal to be desired. It was Wednesday evening and with a 6:00 reservation, it was fairly full and by 9:00 we were only one of three tables hat were occupied and still the service was abysmal ! My tip, which as you know is the acronym for "to insure prompt service" reflected my displeasure !!! I will return, however, not at that servers station.
Have been many times and always enjoyed. This time, not so. We had a reservation for 6:30 and arrived about 6:15. All rooms, upstairs and main level were full. Seated upstairs, in doorway, between two main rooms. Only one water glass for two of us. Waiter promised another but it took three requests to maitre'd, waiter and busboy before it arrived. Staff buzzed by constantly but not for us. Twenty minutes for drink order and we were encouraged to place dinner order. Asked that we have sometime with drinks before meal arrived but that did not happen. Such a disappointment on so many levels. Overall, entire interior needs sprucing up and good cleaning, especially stair carpet.
This restaurant did a great job with the pre-theater menu and crowd. Food was good but price/value ratio was high. There are so many options out there now probably wouldn't pick it again.
Sorry but this place is very tired and dirty looking. Food was mediocre at best and not inexpensive. We love the two restaurants across the street, Orzo and Bar Centrale but thought we'd try something new... Big mistake. Very disappointing all around.
There’s a reason they have been around for over 100 years. Perfect place for pre-theater. In and out without being rushed.
Pre theater dinner. Staff treated us as if we had never been to a restaurant before.
Barnett’s is one of the most classical and stylish restaurants in NYC. Glamorous charm of Old World.
Can always count on Barbetta for good food and service. Best of all it’s conducive to quiet conversation.
Went to Barbetta Saturday night with an old friend. I hadn't been there in about 30 years. A boss of mine took me there for my birthday back then. I remember thinking it was expensive but very elegant. Well it still is as elegant or even more elegant than I remembered. It was such a pleasure to be sitting in a restaurant with that old charm feeling of being back in Italy. The two tables are very nicely placed where neither party has to look at a wall and we were sitting right next to each other which made conversation very enjoyable. We tried the pre fix menu which included appetizer, entree, dessert, and coffee. It was all wonderful. The restaurant is first class. The servers are very knowledgable and friendly. We felt very welcomed. I would highly recommend this gorgeous restaurant on the infamous restaurant row.
Lovely pre theater dining experience. Grand dame of restaurant row
The head waiter on the second floor was miserable. Rolled his eyes at every question we had about the menu. Mediocre restaurant at best.
Good food in a place with the ambience of a nicely decorated church basement. The decor may have passed for fancy in 1960, but in 2019, the ceiling tiles are dirty, the radiator covers have screws sticking out, and public schools have nicer bathrooms. Most importantly they have a culture that does not understand the importance of "choice", to today's customer. They had a prix fix only(limited menu) policy before a certain time that is not made clear on the website. This was a birthday celebration mentioned in the reservations and mentioned by them when we arrived. At NO time was the birthday person given a choice of dessert, and was brought something they would not have ordered. We were told this was complimentaryx but we would have happily bought a slice of what we wanted, NOT what they could palm off on us. NO REASON TO EVER GO BACK.
Great spot for pre theater dining. My husband and our friends love the elegant ambience. Eating on the garden patio in warm weather is also a treat.
Another great experience at Barbetta. the Matri'd Shahin Ahmed was very warm and welcoming. Food was excellent. We had the prefix menu which was a great deal . The crab meat and the rabbit was so delicious.. dessert was terrific. Service was excellent , the staffs were very attentive. highly recommend Barbetta. I will surely be back to Barbetta soon....
Delicious as always. Had the grilled zucchini and my favorite the Diver scallops. This restaurant has been opened since the 1900’s, dining here feels like I’m in a scene from Great Gatsby ! Simply phenomenal experience.
The service was excellent, the food very good. It’s a bit pricey, I would recommend for a special occasion.
Did was superb, and very well prepared. I had the rabbit, and my first had the rack of pork. We both had the main salad. All were wonderful, as were the complimentary rooms and breadsticks. Service was attentive but not overbearing. Though in the expensive side, I highly recommend the restaurant.
This was the most disappointing dining experience I’ve ever had. The menu on open table is outdated and it certainly felt like a bait and switch. Extremely overpriced for a appetizer sized portion they were passing off as a 30.00 entree! Ample amounts of salt and pepper were needed. This restaurant is dated and clearly being run by an out of touch owner. Decor is dated, menu is beyond overpriced, short wine pours. The only positive was good service, they should find a better restaurant to work at!
Wonderful prixe fix menu for the theater
Our experience at Barbettas is always wonderful. The staff ,starting when you walk in ,being seated and through dinner are always very pleasant and professional. It is always our go to place in NY.
Romantic atmosphere. Wonderful food. Overall delightful.
I love Barbetta! It’s a special place. I came here to celebrate my best friend’s birthday and enjoy a pre-theater meal. Barbetta is warm, elegant and welcoming. As they say, “that don’t make them like this anymore.” The food was excellent and the service utterly charming. Don’t wait for a special occasion though. Barbetta is good on any occasion!
Place feels like it’s stuck in the past. Service is ok.
Food is average. Would not go back.
Superb service & an awesome sommelier‼️
FROM THE GREETING AT THE ENTRANCE TO THE PRESENTATION OF THE BILL AND EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN- BARBETTA'S LIVED UP TO THEIR REPUTATION FOR WONDERFUL SERVICE, FOOD AND HOSPITALITY. GO AND ENJOY !!!
Selected at last minute and recommended by hotel. Good service but just average food
Waiter was aggressive and acted annoyed by our group after we told him to split the group into two checks because we were two families. We should have not felt this way considering our bill was over $1000.
Exceptional food, service, and ambiance. A real treasure!
I was honestly not impressed with this restaurant at all. While I very much appreciated the history of the place, the service was not on par with the ambiance or the bill. I think they could have dusted the wine bottles a little, while still maintaining the integrity of their age. The waiters continuously gave us the wrong food at our table and we had to switch with each other. The wait staff never came to check on us at any point during the meals and the food was fine, but certainly not worth the money. It’s probably the first time I regretted paying the amount I did for a meal. At the end, about 4-5 tables for each other’s bills and had to figure out who’s was who’s on our own. I won’t be coming back here.
Overpriced junk food. The antipasto sampler was a random throwing of pieces of prosciutto salmon and some raw veggies- hardly a real sampler. Food was ridiculously priced and not tasty.
Went here for our honeymoon dinner. It was delicious. Everyone was super accommodating to my diet needs... they have a set dinner before show menu to pick off.. but I didnt see anything I wanted so they arranged so I can pick off the regular menu.
Such a warm, romantic, and classy restaurant. Very old-world North Italian, with excellent and refined food. We come for special occasions, like a special anniversary, and have never been disappointed.
This restaurant was highly recommended to me. I was extremely disappointed. My food was very bland, 7 pieces of crab, no sauce and wild rice. I expected a nice presentation - my food was just thrown on my plate. I had the beet salad, again very bland as I expected coat cheese on the salad. The beets appeared to be canned beets and I expected fresh beets. The salad served was terrible, lettuce on a plate with a very bland dressing - not worth eating. We paid $150.00 with tip, definitely not worth it.
Worst meal in NYC, quite the disappointment. - tasteless appetizer to dessert. Factor in exceedingly high prices for bland food and it is a waste of good money. Actually my friend sent her main lobster back it was so bad. The saving grace was the waiter did not charge me for it. Save your money and eat elsewhere.