Very poor service. !0 minutes after being seated until we were approached by Waiter. Justin T. was the most inattentive server I have experienced in a popular , well regarded restaurant. He didn't seem to care and my 15% tip was being gracious.
Booked at as a convenient option after sunset and was not disappointed. Food was fantastic. Great service and wine list. Nice setting in the house and on the porch.
65th Birthday! Great experience, delicious food!
Food and service was great!!!!
Overall, food was good. Great location to people watch, and hear music from the Hogs Breathe Across the street. Food is good, but portions have gotten smaller, while the price continues to increase (YoY). We sat on the first floor porch. Our server wasn’t as welcoming as other servers I’ve had in past. Everyone is entitled too an off day.
Food was good, but a server can change your experience....
Fabulous table overlooking Duval Street. Great food, terrific service and a lovely old house porch setting. Couldn’t be better!
Unexpected find on Duval street. Fine dining experience with authentic Italian food. Outstanding appetizers and pasta with sufficient quantities and reasonable prices. Waiter outstanding and attentive. Will definitely return here next time in Key West.
Always delicious and well prepared entrees. Our group of 4 had barmundi (mild Asian sea bass), swordfish and filet. Nice selection of wines by the glass, too.
We had fish tacos and bbq tacos for lunch, not bad. The server pushed the key lime pie as being voted best in Key West, and since we hadn't had any on our trip yet, we got it--but honestly, it was awful. Too much meringue (which was crunchy with sugar) topped a sour but somehow also too sweet, lime-less pie. We had two bites each and sent it back. Unfortunate. Maybe it was just an off day? But the atmosphere can't be beat. Still enjoyed the place immensely and would definitely return.
Our dinner at Bagatelle in Key West was excellent. The service was great when we made our reservation on Open Table we requested balcony seating and got it right on Duval Street. The Surf and Turf was amazing and we loved the Key Lime Pie.
Our dinner was mediocre and expensive. There are better choices for dinner in Key West.
Really great place. Food was phenomenal as was the service.
Vacation ... anniversary
We went for brunch and it wasn’t very good. The food came lukewarm at best. Biscuits tasted like frozen ones. Hollandause sauce was so thick and didn’t have much taste to it. The service was fine but we surely didn’t enjoy the food there.
Amazing service. Great food.
3 of us. All w/ different seafood. Thoroughly enjoyed
This was my second visit. Chowder was good but could have been hotter. Crab cake was warm at best. No refills on ice tea. Expensive for what we received. Wouldn't go back.
Corned beef omelette was rather bland. The most savory item on my brunch plate were the fried onions on top of the otherwise uninspired roasted potatoes.
Food was exceptional! Loving the ambiance! Could hear live music from across street was was wondering! Enjoyed all bagatelle had to offer!!
The bar across the street was a little overwhelming with their live music. We also requested a table on the upstairs patio that we got however we were crammed up there. My husband was soooooooo uncomfortable, and is pretty regularly sized. Besides all that, good food is good food aaaaand it was just ok. I’m talking $36 for 1 lobster tail entrée, meaning lobster tail a small scoop of risotto (that was the star of the show) and asparagus. The service was...... not there. My husband asked for another glass of wine for me and she said while waking away ok another beer. He had to shout to her to come back and say no another glass of wine for my wife. Maybe sitting at the bar would e better.
Four of us ordered several starters, a salad and two entrees. All were prepared beautifully and were delicious. Hot dishes were served hot. Waiter person Natasha was delightful - not only was she quite capable, she was a pleasure to get to know. We enjoyed everything about our dining experience at Bagatelle.
Great food and great service. Wonderful location on Duval Street. Great for people watching. Love the Lobster Mac 'n Cheese.
We made two visits in February. We loved the food and the outdoor seating on both visits. The first visit we sat upstairs and our waiter was not focused on his job. Request for more water and coffee had to be made repeatedly and he always placed the blame on someone else, but he was truly "somewhere else" and not paying attention. He was polite, maybe having issues at home.
On our second visit the service was adequate.
Excellent meal. Wonderful evening of dining. Waiter (Ivan B) was very engaging and attentive. We were on the balcony overlooking Duval. The perfect table. Music from the hogs breath saloon was perfect as it came down the street. Like soft background music. Only small negative, among all the positives was the special (Sea Bass) was $40, which could have been told to us prior to ordering. A little steep and was not as good as the other fish at more reasonable prices.
My 23 year old son and I were in Key West for only 4 nights and we visited Bagatelle on our second night. It was recommended to us from those at The Marker where we were staying. We went there for happy hour and stayed for dinner. The happy hour was great with drink specials and $5 plates. Dinner was excellent. I had the hogfish and my son had the filet. We couldn’t have been more pleased. Our server Ivan was the best. He was friendly and helpful and provided excellent service.
We loved the restaurant so much, we went back again two nights later. We requested a table outside on the porch and we requested Ivan. We got both and had the best time.
I would highly recommend Bagatelle!
Amazing. Really loved the key lime pie.
Everything was great, the service, drinks and food. Roberta was our server and did everything to make our lunch enjoyable. Can’t wait to go back!
Amazing food!! Best in Key West!!! Service great!!
This was for our 30th Anniversary. We were seated at a perfect balcony table for the sunset and people watching. Our server was outstanding , providing insight into the menu, recommending an award winning specialty cocktail that was fantastic and food to match! The mussels, an appetizer, were enhanced by a creamy cognac sauce that was the best I have ever tasted and the entrees were exceptional. To top it off, at the end of dinner, we were surprised with a mouth watering key lime pie dessert with a “Happy Anniversary “ message. A memorable night, with thanks to the Bagatelle staff!!
Great dinner! Loved our second floor table!
The food and wait staff were great, but we reserved a table for two and were greeted by a surly, mean hostess. We arrived there at precisely 7:30 for our reservation and were ushered upstairs by Nasty Nancy to a table by the kitchen, inside. When we asked if we can sit outside, as there were at least 5 tables for 2 and 4 available, the simplistic answer by Nasty Nancy was a concise “No!”. She seemed to insinuate that we were somehow not worthy. She then proceeded to parade 5 couples past us to outside tables and seemed to enjoy it. If I were the owner or chef of this place, I would take Miss Nasty out back and give her the “heave ho”.
The place has great food, but with a greeter like that needlessly ruining the experience, they are probably losing a ton of business. I would recommend going across the street to a place called Paradise, for delicious cuban food and a nice ambiance... and above all friendly people.
Enjoyed eating outside on upper terrace.
The food was good, the sides could be bigger. the service was not great at all from hostess to bar tender.
Food wasn’t bad. Service was a bit slow. Neat environment.
Absolutely amazing Valentines Day.
It was amazing! The food, the service, the environment everything was super great. Delicious food
Food was fabulous! The biscuits and gravy was awesome and the banana foster French toast was heavenly! Expect to pay about $30 for 2 for breakfast/brunch. Just wondering why they did not confirm my reservation with Open Table. Our server was great!
Service was slow and waiter not attentive. Food was mediocre but ambience was great.