Expensive for average grilled fish, and salmon was overcooked and in a sauce that ruined the dish.
I had such a great time , the service was amazing! My boyfriend and I went out for Valentine’s Day. The food was good, the waiter we had was very nice, and it was actually quite. We were seated in a nice area. I would definitely comeback again.
went here for valentines day. arrived early but was still seated upon arrival. waiter and overall was very friendly and inviting. wait time for food was minimal. i ordered the red snapper. my bf ordered the salmon. food was ok. at 1st i thought i didn't like it but the 2nd and 3rd bite was ok. the drinks are VERY strong (just what i needed lol). the music was barely there. i mostly heard other ppl talking at nearby tables than i heard any music. Overall i would visit this restaurant again. Its a nice laid back, mature vibe.
Terrific service and food - unique sushi
Bronzino was a little dry
Very disappointing. Food is mediocre. Service made us feel like they were trying to up-sell us to spend more.
Service is spotty; some excellent servers and a few completely indifferent servers.
One of our favorite pre-theater spots - even on Valentine's Day - outstanding service and aside from gearing up for extra patrons - (little tables added to the layout to serve more customers) - there was no attempt to fool people into expensive alternative menu choices for the holiday.
Still superb waitstaff attention and we were able to get out to the performance on time.
Food quality remains truly impressive.
When requesting a table in a quiet area during an early dinner time on a Monday evening, we were told that "nobody will be at the bar" and the table we were seated at would be quietest in the restaurant. This was the case for about 15 minutes when, of course, folks came into the bar! By this time, our food had arrived and we were well into diner. The noise directly behind us was deafening. When I complained, I was told that all I had to do was ask to be moved. This was not realistic once we were well into eating our dinner. The hostess was quite argumentative and not learning anything from her logistic error. I had previously enjoyed this restaurant but found this experience to be quite negative!
My wife and I had a great time at the Atlantic Grill for Sunday Brunch. The service was outstanding, our waiter, Erik was great. The food was amazing, my wife has several food intolerances and they were all met with no problem. The dining room and bar are beautiful and very comfortable. We left feeling like we had made the right choice for our meal. I had read the reviews and saw some negative ones and it was clear after our visit that the bad ones were totally fake, as none of the negative were true for us. I recommend the Atlantic Grill and can't wait for my next trip to New York so we can go there again.
Unfortunately the Atlantic Grill at Lincon Center hasn't the same menu as the one at 3rd Ave. It was my first visit and I was very desappointed.