There were 4 of us. Three meals came out perfect. Mine did not, my tuna came out way over cooked. They did replace it and it was good. The service was good but I had expected a little more attention. We had to ask for additional water and we’re not offered additional drinks. Overall it was a very nice place.

Overall great experience. Good was really good and the waitress gave us a glass of champagne to celebrate our special occasion.

I enjoyed my dinner at the Atlantic Fish, my waiter was exceptional, the food was great and the desert was fantastic, the PO lace was quiet which allowed us to eat and enjoy our time there. I can't wait to go back and try other amazing things that they have on the menu.

Amazing birthday celebration for my husband. Thank you for an extra special day

Our waitress Amanda was friendly and attentive, very much appreciated

Beat presentation of delicious food! Our waitress was outstanding. The outdoor seating was very comfortable

Had a great meal, starting with delicious fried oysters. The service was excellent!

We had a wonderful dinner at Atlantic Fish last night. It was full to capacity, but service and food were both excellent. We started with oysters followed by wonderful crab cakes. Our server was Nicholas and he did a great job on a crowded night. We will definitely return to Atlantic Fish, one of our favorite Boston restaurants.

Our waiter Tony was fantastic and entertaining. Food was delicious!

Amazing place for our first night in Boston. Johnathan was on point with service!

I enjoyed the food and professional, attentive service. I look forward to eating here again in the future.

Atlantic Fish has never let us down. Great food and service

Great place for seafood....chowder was tasty, crab cakes were good, and lobster pasta was very good. Fun ambience, with many booths and tables....a bit crowded and noisy.

The staff and service were excellent. The food was delicious. We had a great experience.

While the service at Atlantic Fish was excellent -- our server, Connor, was knowledgeable, personable, and attentive -- the food was unimpressive. The lobster crab Louie was so mild as to be almost tasteless. The Fisherman's platter contained some dry, overcooked pieces of whitefish, some tiny mussels, and some overcooked shrimp and scallops. The atmosphere at Atlantic Fish was lively and congenial, and the wine list was excellent, but the food was so lacking that I would not go back there again.

Atlantic Fish Co. Is a lively, bustling restaurant with excellent food. This restaurant never disappoints!

As always excellent.

Our waiter, Christopher, was phenomenal! Very personable, humorous, and he valued our time. He truly treated us as if we were his only responsibility, but what was even better was we had the pleasure of watching him in action, responding and interacting with his other tables! A true gem of an employee! They are extremely lucky to have him!!!

A person’s hair was found in our food.
Team was apologetic but the presence of the hair caused questions of the facility’s overall quality.

Best meal we've had in Boston!

I made a reservation well in advance but stuck in a corner with a small bench and chair. The sea bass recipe apparently changed since my last visit back in 2018. Did you change a clean healthy dish into a rich heavy cream with pasta dish?

Great food. First time visiting. Will definitely recommend.

Great as always. A must fir steamers, fried clams and lobster every visit to Boston. Waiter was the beat and the food is awesome. The entire staff are so nice.

service waiter SOD was excellent. Drinks, food were very good. A bit expensive but this is great seafood in a major city Boston. Would defiantly come back again. Was there for lunch, not sure if dinner menu is same?

The iced tea was delicious. However the grilled cod was over cooked. But the mushrooms were terrific. A reason to return

We had a reservation for 2, Thursday at 8:15pm. We arrived at 8 and the hostess said we would be seated at 8:15 and we could go to the bar for a drink in the meantime. First impressions, it was very crowded and loud, , I had a bit of covid anxiety but we found a spot to have a drink....as I said it was crowded. The staff were so nice, we were seated at 8:25 at a fabulous table by the window (no outdoor seating this night as it was pouring) We had a lovely bottle of wine and I went for the baked stuffed lobster which was gorgeous. My husband said at some point later that it was my birthday and the brought a delicious slice of key lime cheesecake (my choice)with happy birthday written on the plate in chocolate. Go for it! It is a bit pricey, but the staff were great and so was the food! We had a wonderful night!

Highly recommend....

Loved it!!!

Our waitstaff were personable & efficient. The asparagus side was surprisingly smaller than expected (4 stalks). The raw oysters were well done. The fried whole belly clams were well cooked w/ a tasty tartar sauce. The clam chowder was solid. I think that the noodle side that came with the octopus was a little flat. The wagyu carpaccio was the dish I enjoyed the most.

The food was outstanding as usual, and the service from Morgan was exceptional. The only disappointment was that several menu items were unavailable because of late deliveries, as we were very apologetically informed.

Great food! The service a little slow through the middle of dinner

Great place for a special occasion.

The lobster meat was just thrown in a bowl and the crabmeat or crab cake whatever was on top and was burnt on the outside, the Lobster had absolutely 0 taste and the presentation was so poor that not only will I never go back but I will tell people to never go there. We were offered a free dessert for a birthday but instead drove to Chart House for dessert and after dinner drinks. This was after 3 weeks of planning and calling and ended with the worst meal and service ever.

Always a great experience.

Food was delicious. Service was impeccable. A kitchen snafu was handled respectfully by management

Best Seafood and Service in Boston. A neighborhood gem.

This was my second time having dinner here and it was not as good of an experience as my first. Being seated right next to the kitchen entrance with carts of dirty dishes rolling by constantly was not pleasant. Or food was good and timely however our waiter disappeared for a very long time after we were done eating and we were left staring at each other saying “ if you see him call him over”. Yet we never saw him. When he finally returned we just asked for the check. We were no longer interested in finding out about dessert or coffee. We had been waiting too long. The start of our meal up till dinner was good until that point. The noise level also bothered me which is irritating when you’re left there for a long period of time waiting for your server. I would go back. But I would refuse the table near the kitchen and pray for a more responsive wait staff. My first experience here was awesome and so was our waiter.

Always a go to for special occasions.

Wonderful food...great service. Good value for the price.

Very nice experience. Service was excellent.