Had the best service!

my best options for when you were with a craving for seafood

I wish it had been better. Our jumbo crab appetizer was good. Our lobsters were dried out, as if they had been sitting too long under a heat lamp. The cheesecake was missing any flavor. We've had much better meals there, so I write this one off as a bad night in the kitchen.

We had a very nice time at the Atlanta Fish Market - our second visit. This time we made reservations over Open Table (who gave us NO points - grrrrr), and I particularly liked the blue crab bisque and the Scottish salmon. Service was okay but not great but I would go back again.

There is no doubt that the resto has superb fish. However, this time the lobster roll was below standard. It was made of mediocre lobster salad with, shockingly, a few bits of cartridge. I had Cousins lobster truck Maine lobster roll and a friend had the CT roll today, both absolutely fantastic. Shame on you, Buckhead Fish Market

A nice place to enjoy fresh fish and or seafood! Nice environment for dining pleasure.

Our service was so amazing, great food and perfect location if your doing a night out.

Despite it being busy, we were sat close to our reservation time. The waitress was nice and the food was excellent. The crab cakes were my favorite.

Food is always good however; this is the second visit where the server was not very attentive. It’s amazing how a server can make or break your experience.

Our meal was just ok. Steamers were soaking in garlic which

For the third out of four times asking for the same thing..... cook the crab cake well... all i get is an almost burnt exterior and raw interior crab cake as well as scallops. It seems as though the fish market is only concerned with getting diners in and out as soon as possible.
We will not be dining at the Atlanta Fish Market again. Too much money for the fairly good food and mediocre service.

I came to celebrate my birthday and it's been years since I had been. I'm glad I came because the food was exceptionally and as a result of this experience, I plan on making this a once a month treat. Service was top class from the beginning to the end. Thanks and look forward to returning. Plus, it was a perfect environment to have a conversation without talking over noise.

The food was good, as always. Our server, Desislava S., was excellent and very personable, adding to the enjoyment of the evening.

Greg

Waitress was somewhat unattentive. Food was good but i have had better crab cakes there before,

excellent quality fish. good service. nice environment.

Excellent Food! Great service! Chef Bobby is the best chef in Atlanta! Great atmosphere!

A fun evening with a friend for a birthday dinner!

Thin overcooked sea bass. Manager replaced it and the replacement wasn’t much better. He gave us free dessert and handled the situation pretty well...but we will think twice about coming back. This was our first bad experience with this restaurant. :-(

Had the seasonal soft shell crab muniere. Was a bit salty though I’d order it again. The service was attentive, professional, friendly and unobtrusive.

Wonderful service
Wonderful food
Wonderful ambiance

Everyone's meal was delicious! Our server, KC, was outstanding. Looking forward to returning soon.

Excellent food and service

Everything at Atlanta Fish Market was fabulous. The service was awesome. The recommendations made by Sarah, our waitress, were good ideals. For example to have the shrimp and scallops blackened truly gave the meal a great taste. My husband did enjoy the sea bass special. He was his birthday and dinner at The Atlanta Fish Market topped off his day and made it really special.

Highly recommended. We will return again.

Great food, great service! Will definitely go back for lunch.

The hostess Erica was the best!
Great food & selection, consistent quality & preparation.
Always a pleasant experience

The Atlanta Fish Market has a great variety of seafood, served in many different ways: you can have it fried, grilled, sautéed, and there why live crab and lobster as well...huge menu so something for everyone, even non-fish lovers

Loud and decor could use a refresh but food was great and service was impeccable.

Very average experience. Too much Mayo on the lobster roll, and the French fries were pedestrian. I have come to expect more from Buckhead Life restaurants. Not worth the $$.

The food was
Fantastic as was
The service. Can’t wait to go again.

2 fantastic meals but birthday boy's meal bland and overcooked. He had fried shrimp and it had absolutely no flavor and was majorly overcooked. Disappointed.

My husband (deceased 2016) and I LOVED THIS PLACE!!!. I STILL DO!. The HEAD CHEF (Bobby) is THE MOST AMAZING GENTLEMAN...CREATIVE, BUSY yet approachable. He is the reason we've patronized this restaurant for so many years. Please pass by VERY BEST REGARDS to him!

Fish Market was excellent as usual. Service was great, food was excellent and always quick.

Outstanding Anniversary meal in all aspects.

Going downhill... might as well go to Red Lobster if I want moderate to low quality seafood. Very disappointing....

Charging 2 dollars for valet parking is redicius for this level of dining.

I came here for my Birthday and lobster roll . I want to go to this place because of the lobster roll . Our dinner is at 6 pm and first disappointment is that early they are already out of lobster roll . Secondly our server did not even recommend nor make an effort to make us more happy by at least offering something since they are out of the meal that I came from . The sea bass fish that my husband ordered does not taste like it was charge . He didn’t finished his meal at all . Our water was never refilled and the chair in that restaurant by the booth is very uncomfortable and definitely need to be replaced.
I keep trying to come back to this place to give a chance to improved but for the past 2 visit was disappointment.
Definitely not coming anymore .

Can't go wrong win any of the Buckhead Life restaurants. Always, fresh. Always impecable service.

Eat here whenever I’m in Atlanta. Always good. Food is great.

The restaurant was very warm, almost uncomfortable. The area where we sat was noisy. I wished I had asked for a different table. The food was good but hard to hear each other.

Imagine a Cheesecake Factory for seafood, this is it!