The waiters are extremely friendly. The service was amazing

Our food and service was amazing. This restaurant was the perfect ending to Father's Day! There was no long wait time for the food to be prepared. Everything was fresh and hot.

My entire party was disappointed at the small portions of food. The prices aren’t tiny, but the amount of food we received was. They do not allow switching side items without charging you $2 to switch to any other item; that is ridiculous. This was just overall not a good experience and we will not go back…there are too many other great restaurants that serve decent portions of food for the prices charged.

Our server was just ok. I’m use to getting outstanding service because for the 20 plus years I’ve been coming there, that is what I received.

The food was outstanding as usual.

Waiter was pleasant, professional and attentive.

My halibut entree was the second best halibut I have ever had -- the first being halibut that I cooked for myself at home. It was also a generous portion which is frequently not the case with fish in restaurants. I had a great Father's Day lunch.

I enjoy my birthday meal.
The seafood is always top notch.
I would highly recommend AFM!

The food was great and their is a casual and friendly atmosphere.

The food was delicious. Our server had exceptional customer service. The only thing I did not really like was I didn’t get that much food lol. I’m used to taking a doggy bag home at ate all of my food.Their food is portion size to each individual. So next time I’m going to order double.

Compliments to the chef! Enjoyed the sea bass, lobster, crab cakes! Everything was Devine. Juicy, seasoned well and fresh!

Great food and service! Server was helpful in picking entrees for our first time. The drinks were flavorful and bartenders gave you your money's worth.

The server was excellent. We sat in the bar lounge area. Our reservation was at 7pm and we were seated at that time and immediately greeted by our server. Great personality and the food came out quickly. For appetizer we originally wanted oyster Rockefeller but unfortunately, they were out. We opted for gumbo and for dinner had the broiled platter. Excellent 👍 will come back again 😉

Excellent service from our server, Richard. He really cared and it showed. Despite a reservation we waited about 15-20 minutes to be seated. To be fair it was packed. We got placed in a room off to the side adjacent to the bar which was hot, stuffy and very loud. I'm an out of towner and was visiting family, and it seems I must have bad luck getting seated in the main dining room, having been stuffed in this same back room the last 3 times I have visited. Bummer. Overall glad we went, food did not disappoint, Richard our server was EXCELLENT but the experience & ambiance suffered by our seating location. Suggest guests request main dining room to enhance their experience.

Dishes weren’t clean, bathrooms were horrible, management notified and did nothing, servers standing around doing nothing, not worth the prices.

Our server Audrey was awesome and full of personality! We had great drinks, the Scallops and the Sea Bass - grilled - all delicious! We were seated on time and the place was lively with lots of folks enjoying an evening out. We are never disappointed when we come here - usually for special occasions- this was a birthday dinner.

Celeste and Easin remembered us from a previous visit and checked on us this visit .Kyle was our server this visit and was pleasant and eager to to satisfy our service and meal requests. Scallops and halibut were wonderful. Ask for 90’s room for quieter meal, request bread if desired

Food was delicious and the server was very attentive. We celebrated our anniversary and they brought out a special dessert. The valet staff was wonderful and so hardworking, especially out there in the rain.

Great servers, kept glasses full, answered questions. Friendly. Minimal wait for seating.

Excellent Father’s Day dinner. Good and service very good. Please help and hire more valet to support them, they are working hard

The service and atmosphere were family-friendly. The service was great from the valet ($3 + gratuity), hostess, and waiters. The grouper was awesome, however we were disappointed with the crab cakes’ texture and taste. The scallops were also too salty. Overall, the experience was great but we will be selective with our menu choices.

Service was very slow but it was busy

Our experience was absolutely terrible. The lobster roll was awful and had celery in it, which was gross. It took over two hours to dine here. Our drinks were never refilled. We ordered mixed drinks as well that were poorly made. Our waiter only came by for drink orders and meal order. We had to stop another waiter to track our waiter down for the check because we were running late for a meeting because the meal took forever to come out. The only decent part of the meal was the sushi appetizer. Our expectations were set way too high because of the reviews on open table. Don’t be fooled by the good reviews like we were!

Yes, this is our third visit in as many weeks ... my guests on their return visit through town wanted to come here AGAIN, and who's to blame them?

The food was spectacular! I had the Chilean Sea Bass with the sticky rice, soy sauce and spinach. I've had this same dish several times and it's always a home run! I never regret ordering this entre. The waiter was attentive, polite and engaged and the food was very timely; albeit the restaurant was packed and lively. My friend ordered the broiled seafood platter and thought it was excellent. The most succulent scallops you'll ever put in your mouth. I'm ready for a rerun on both meals. So many great options to choose from. You can never go wrong at The Atlanta Fish Market.

Great as always

The lobster tail appetizer was great. Our waiter Kyle made some great suggestions and was just right attentive.

Everything was excellent at the Atlanta Fish Market.

Good food and service.

We will be back.

The food and drinks were sub-par as was the service.

Food was pretty solid not the best I ever had but pretty good. Server was nice but the restrooms smelled so bad I couldn’t even use them.

Our server was slow and always seemed confused. Had to ask for silverware. Non attentive and had to chase down to get the check. Unusual for this restaurant.

It was end of the night and it was just good nothing was amazing. But also no complaints.

Food was well prepared. I had the blackened grouper. The whipped potatoes are just ok but the string beans were perfect

My husband loved the swordfish and the parmesan grits never disappoint. I was surprised that we were there at the start of dinner service and were told they were out of fresh bread. The seafood Newburg was ok - they are using more salmon in it now (I don't recall it having salmon before) and it was a little dry. I always like the atmosphere in there and our waiter was nice. Overall not a bad experience, just would have ordered differently.

Food here is always wonderful and the service is topnotch.

I had a great experience at Atlanta Fish Market. Everything was excellent.

You will have one of the best seafood dining experiences in the Atlanta area at the Atlanta Fish Market. The food is amazing in both taste and presentation. The staff is knowledgeable and personable. A five star dining experience for sure.

The food was not flavorful and my adult beverage cocktail was not good. For the cost of my meal I expected it to be better. Would not care to come again.

Terrible service. Food mediocre.

Very bad experience. Took my mother out to dinner and her crab salad was terrible. Soggy Lettuce and minimal crab. They bare acknowledged that it was bad. They reluctantly brought her something else. Grilled salmon but it was horribly over salted and in a burr blanc sauce (all butter which she can’t eat). Anyway, they charged us for the more expensive entree and never even sent a manager over. These places were much better years ago when run by Pano & Paul. Now just a crappy remnant

We are frequent diners at Buckhead restaurants and especially the Buckhead Life Group. The food is consistently very good. Our wait staff was also good. However, we were annoyed with 2 items. First, the air conditioning was not working very well making the dining uncomfortable and second we do not understand why the butter was served in prepackaged individual containers. When asked about the butter we we told the current excuse of COVID. However, we fined at the Lobster Bar on Saturday night and they did not serve butter in individual prepackaged containers.
I can understand prepackaged butter at Waffle House but not at a Buckhead Life Group restaurant.