This was our second visit to Key West and second visit to Antonia’s. The food is consistently excellent. We had zuppa di pesce and seafood linguine alla vodka both were amazing. I highly recommend this restaurant for food and service.
The food was quite good at Antonia’s. The place has a celebratory food. The best aspect of this restaurant is the wait staff. Our server was magnificent; Very attentive and gracious without being a nuisance. We very much enjoyed our visit.
PEI Mussels were the best!
In the hubbub of Key West the elegance and refinement of Antonio’s was a welcome refuge from Duval Street. Robert, our server, was knowledgeable and competent and explaining our options. Good wine list, lots of choices, sautéed yellow snapper was excellent.
The food and service was excellent - best pasta we have had since our trip to Italy!
Our waiter Robert provided 2 visits before taking my credit card(after I waited and asked another server to get my check), asking if tap water if ok, then brought us the water and took our order. That’s it. No asking how’s the food or what not. Meanwhile, he was chatting and laughing with the tables next to ours, presenting his hospitality or what not for at least 5 minutes.
Very interesting experience, I have never been treated this poorly before, and since I always tip waiters accordingly to their service, this guy definitely did not get my normal 20-25%.
Food was ok, the clam chowder tasted a lot like the one from Red Lobster, and my company really enjoyed his seafood pasta, while my Bolognese was boring and had no highlight.
Very energetic atmosphere, they had groups of guests that apparently really enjoyed themselves, pretty loud. But that’s all right comparing to the poor service I got.
Will definitely never go back, and notify everyone I know to not go as well. I don’t care what’s this waiter’s excuse for treating us so poorly, it’s not worth it.
Awful. The fish main courses took a very long time. When I asked the waiter about the status he told me “fine dining takes time”. I didn’t like his patronizing attitude. Finally the fish came and both of our dishes were far too salty to eat. Terrible experience.
Homemade pasta is excellent. Service and ambiance were first rate.
Everything was outstanding. We really enjoyed the experience.
Excellent service. Food was overall good but not out of the ordinary. Some dishes were excellent and some were ok.
Had the lamb chops which were great although too much gravy to my opinion.
Calamari was ok. Could be better as I personally don't like the sweet spice souse added to it.
Place was noisy but I kind of liked it. It gives a lot of personality to the place.
Over all good experience. It is a tourist place but defiantly not a tourist trap... I'm sure locals enjoys this place as well.
The bill was a little high...
Fantastic service and homemade pasta. What more could you ask for!
Great experience. Food was delicious, and our waiter was perfectly charming.
From start to finish - absolute perfection. If I lived here this where I'd go all of the time. Fresh, handmade pasta, local seafood offerings, amazing wine selection.... you can't go wrong.
Pizza was awesome. Some odge best we've had anywhere. Seafood dished are all excellent. Service was a bit slow but the place was slammed. Definitely will go back.
Great little Italian Restaraunt in the heart of the Duvall district. Calamari is to die for. Shrimp dishes are incredible. Service was great and prices reasonable. Highly recommended.
Maybe the consistently best restaurants in key west. Everything is always outstanding
Server was horrible. Very unattentive, un professional, left at Random times while we placing order. Brought me a bill for 700 for the 3 of us. My husband food wrong. Called him a liar. Was horrible.
Not bad but nothing special. I’m sure there are much better places to eat in Key West.
Excellent food service delightful waitress from Ukraine. Pastas are de- lish!
Being in Key West Antonia's makes good use of local fresh fish and Seafood. The muscles appetizer in spicy red sauce was outstanding. The yellowtail snapper was also amazing. And the seared diver scallops were cooked perfectly with just the right amount of delicious fettuccine to go with it
Outstanding food, menu, and wine list. Osso Buco and sea food were highlights. Service was great.
Very delicious seafoods and pastas. Perfect location on Duval St.
Entrees were very good. Space is a little cozy but good for meeting and talking with dining neighbors. Waiter was attentive but he was so busy that it did make the dining experience seem rushed.
One of the best in Key West and definitely will return
We are regular diner's at Antonia's. Typically, food and service are top notch. This night food was good and service was lacking.
We absolutely loved it!!! I had the clams and linguini. It was piping hot, a little spicy... Perfect!!!! My husband had lasagna.. he was also pleased. Every plate that went by looked delicious. Nice to get out if the loud street tons cozy, memorable restaurant!!! Staff was also great!!!
After a week and a half of cruise ship food we opted for lunch at Antonia’s based on a number of recommendations. Boy were the advisors correct! Starting with perfectly made negronis, the beef carpaccio appetizer was sensational. My wife opted for the pasta special which was also superb. My main course of linguini with pink shrimp was outstanding. Desserts were incredible as well. We could not have asked for a more positive surprise.
We had read about it, and wanted to give it a try. It was very busy and the wait staff did a good job keeping up. Unfortunately, we were next to a loud and somewhat “entitled” group of six adults who obviously knew the staff. All of the fun was great for them, but the two were so loud and long winded we had to shout at one another to have any conversation. Management let the roll on. Other than that, the restaurant and the food were a pleasure.
The food satisfies as always. The service while brisk left us feeling rushed. They want to turn those tables. Would however return.
Very cozy great service!
Excellent atmosphere, service and varied selection of dishes. A bit noisy but not ridiculous so.
Couldn’t have been better!
Great place for special occasion or everyday dining.
'Bin there many times over the years and it is consistently superior. The Grouper was sen-sational and my wife had the Salmon. Hers was also great. And I need to go back and try some of their Pastas. They all look yummy!
Loved are whole experience, food was exceptional.
A must stop for me in Key West every year. Excellent food, great vibe, fun people to interact with. This year there was a service issue...not the norm. Server took my order...all at once...long time passed...salad arrived still not cocktail...cocktail arrived well after salad. The bartender is over worked...too many responsibilities. This really made my experience less than optimal. Even the diners to either side of me noticed the very obvious mis-step. Unusual but could have had a big impact if I were a first time diner rather than a many year regular.
Last minute reservation decision took us back to one of our Key West favorites. We were seated upon arrival at a cozy corner table. The homemade pasta is always the draw for me and once again it did not disappoint. Service was exceptional!
Way to crowded and extremely noisy. To many tables and waitstaff bumped my wife’s chair several times. Need to remove 20% of the tables. Only good place to sit is up front in the window table. Price point is too high for this level of noise and service.
Good bar service prior to seating for meal, table service was abrupt, veal chop not worth the price.
Delicious food (superb goat cheese soufflé appetizer, great veal chop and grouper entrees), excellent service (Brad), very nice ambiance