Let us do the cooking! Celebrate Easter at Andrea's 25!
Dining Reservations starting at 1pm.
Sunday, April 1, 2018
I always enjoy dining atAndreas 25... the staff, service and atmosphere are exceptional and the food is wonderful...
First-rate dining experience the owner Matt personally greets his diners and the manager Anthony is outgoing and friendly and can’t do enough for you. The waiter and busboys we’re all attentive and friendly. On a Saturday night you expect to wait 10 or 15 minutes even with the reservation but both Anthony and Matt kept letting us know our table would be available any minute and actually bought us a drink!!! But the stand out starof this family restaurant is the food the Hawaiian ravioli at just the right amount of kick to it I would definitely order it again a robust yet delicate dish. The veal Parmesan was tender and the sauce was amazing just like your grandma would make on a Sunday morning. Kudos to the chef
I love this place. The food is amazing!!!!!
We waited for our table for more than 30 min even though we had a reservation, they gave us a free appetizer while we were waiting at the bar but still our plan was not to wait for so long, if the place was so busy it was better to let us know that there were no tables available at the time than making us wait.
When we received our food we had the artichoke appetizer and it was still frozen on the inside, they replaced the dish and didn't charge us for it but the first impression we had on the food was not good. Finally, the ONLY main dish available for vegetarians is the Mac&Cheese all other dishes had some kind of meat on them, I ended up having as dinner a Caesar salad and the frozen/replaced appetizer.
Food was delish! Went with 2 other couples and everyone was very happy! Service was great!
Food is beyond delicious. Service was wonderful, friendly and professional.
Love this restaurant but it was a Saturday night and we had to shout to hear each other at my table.
It was pricey for the cas atmosphere
The waiter made a huge mistake. Undercharged is. My husband brought it to his attention and he came back and bill was still wrong. We saved him a $200. Error and he barely acknowledged it. I would have thought he’d have bought ya a drink. Off- putting
The wait staff was excellent. We never had an empty glass of water. Managers were very attentive always making sure everything was good
Great place. Food was delicious. Service was stellar. But music selection was strange. It was dance pop, which I like, but it didn’t fit with the overall ambience which was more upscale. Old school Frank Sinatra would have been better.
We have dined here frequently and this was our worst experience. They were crowded for a Sunday evening and Matt, the host was apologetic as I have a reservation and we still waited for a table. Upon arriving at the table, we sat there for 20 minutes before Matt came over to take our order and he was surprised we had no bread or water. He ultimately was our waiter. He was running back and forth and unfortunately, never came by until after we were almost finished with our meal to see if we wanted another drink or even anything extra. The food was excellent; however, we skipped desert and had to wait for a check. Finally we asked another waiter to please have someone give us the check. Hopefully this was an isolated incident, but it did leave a bad taste in our mouths-- Will most likely go back, but not for a while.
The food was excellent with some interesting items on the menu. The service was very good as well and they were punctual with our reservation. Our only complaint was the noise level, which was tough to take. We were six people at a round table in the corner and it was very difficult to carry on a conversation.
I would definitely go back , but not on a Saturday night or other peak time. Perhaps a week day evening would be more tolerable.
Three out of four of us liked the dishes we ordered. One of us, who ordered gnocchi said it was just OK, no raves. We were there on a Friday night and the place was really noisy; probably because the bar was full. Overall, a decent dinner. About $160 including tip; about par for most of the restaurants we frequent.
Great food. An added plus was half price on a good bottle of Cab!
Food was delicious and the service was wonderful . Had a great night.
Well... there was a lack of diversity. The room kind of stared for a while. But the food was excellent the price was perfect and service was fast.
Food was good, friendly service. Would recommend to friends and family.
Amazing service great food
Highly recommend. Great food great service.
Have been to this restaurant four times in the last two months and have had an excellent experience each time. Service always great and food consistently delicious!
First time at the Commack location as we were regulars at the Woodbury one. Food, service, and overall experience were fantastic. Staff were friendly and attentive and food was delicious. We will definitely be back again!
Food is very good. We actually go out of our way every so often to get Andrea 25's Veal Valdostana. It is the best tasting on Long Island. Miss there Woodbury location.
Andrea’s 25 never disappoints! The food is absolutely delicious and is prepared exactly as requested. The waiter was attentive and seemed to appear whenever we needed him. BY FAR THE BEST PLACE TO EAT IN COMMACK!
We had the Pollo Picante and Pollo Polementano, both of which were quite good. We ordered both "spicy" and the Polementano was seriously spicy, the way I like it and the way most restaurants are afraid to serve it, though not overpowering. For dessert, the Italian cheesecake was excellent. The wine list prices are about on par with most good restaurants (not inexpensive) but there's definitely something for everyone on the list. Service was friendly and knowledgeable. Noise level was a bit "up there" for a Sunday but there was a party on the opposite side of the room so that's show biz. Will definitely return.
This place was packed. The food and service were excellent! Looking forward to going back.
Very busy and excellent Italian restaurant. Don't judge it by its strip mall location. It has a wonderful ambiance and great quality food, drinks and service. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal. We were seated rather quickly on a Saturday night with a reservation. The only reason that I didn't give it 5 Stars across the board is because it is very noisy and hard to have a conversation. I totally understand though being a busy restaurant on a Saturday night the noise level is to be expected. We will be back.
We eat at this restaurant all the time and this was the first time I didn’t give it 5 stars. I have a feeling it was because it was a Saturday night. No toilet paper or soap in the ladies room. My dinner was cold and brought out in a cold plate. And the noise level was thunderous. Also we ordered a dessert to share and the waiter seemed annoyed when we asked him to cut it for us. He pointed to our butter knife to indicate we could do it but eventually did as we had requested. I will definitely go back but never on a Saturday.
Our first time at the restaurant and defiantly won’t be our last! Food was amazing! Had a great time!
Food was great but not hot enough. Certainly will go back again
Had A delicious meal. A number of choices could have ordered. Service a little slow. Will go back.
Excellent place. Great atmosphere. Staff very friendly and excellent service
Excellent as always. Politely greeted and served quickly at both the bar and our table. I recommend the chicken scarpiello. Huge portion and delicious. Risotto balls are a must for appetizer. Been here 5-6x and each time I leave exceptionally satisfied. Will be back.
Both the food and the service were fantastic.
Great food and great service!
Staff and ownership very friendly, excellent food, great appetizers and entrees, would highly recommend for a date, drinks with friends or a family dinner.
Had a great time, service was amazing.
We really enjoyed the food . Service was slow but willing to say they were very busy.Noise level has always been bad there..
We had a fabulous night!! We were celebrating a family anniversary and the staff couldn’t have been better. They accommodated all of our special dietary needs and made us feel welcomed and at home. Highly recommend this restaurant!!!!
Great service! Sal is the best! All the dishes were fantastic!
Great service and food.
I’ve been there many times but I brought a friend for her birthday! Everything was perfect! The food! The service! The festive atmosphere! This is my favorite restaurant!