Anastasi Seafood Restaurant
Broiled Seafood Combo*
Scallop, crab, flounder and shrimp.
Fish and Chips Platter
The ceiling could use replacing. The tiles are covered in water stains. The ceiling fans were rusted. Thought it was odd they didn’t serve tap water. If you wanted water you had to purchase it. Overall dinner was great. The dining room could use an upgrade.
Food was great. Service good. Only issues were tables were right on top of each other, so no covid distancing, and you end up part of all neighboring diners conversations. Beverages were overpriced by about 200% for simply a small bottled water. And they added 2.5% to bill for using credit card. I call that undisclosed robbery when everybody is using credit cards primarily these days and especially during covid pandemic.
I love this restaurant fish is amazing always fresh my server was so nice I appreciate everything in this restaurant I would recommend it wholeheartedly
I asked for a quiet table but was seated next to a loud profanity-using table.
At first glance it seems inexpensive but when the food arrives........a raw combo for 15.00 included One oyster, One clam, One shrimp and a crab cocktail.
Best seafood I have ever had! The crab & shrimp chowder was amazing!
First time at Anastasi but what a discovery! Was also allowed to bring my own wine for a $15 corkage fee which added to the overall enjoyment.
Seafood very fresh and delicious worth every dollar
Go here now
As always amazingly fresh seafood with a homestyle environment. Brought some friends along and they were impressed!
Everything was great. Service by Eric was exceptional!!
Funky place with consistently fresh delicious seafood.
The food was fresh and awesome! Be prepared for big portions!
You would probably drive right by this place without giving it a second glance. You may, after seeing the outside, have second thoughts about your reservation and go elsewhere. That would be a terrible mistake. Granted, it doesn't look like much from the outside. Even upon entering, you are not overwhelmed with ambiance. But please, take your seat at one of the 8 tables. Order a drink from the full service bar. Order an app ( calamari for us), then sit back and try to decide what to have for dinner off the extensive menu. The entire menu looked delicious. We settled on a grilled whole Branzino for her and Pescatore for me. Both were perfectly prepared. Do yourself a favor and get a table here some night. We will certainly be back.
Wonderful food and service
Fresh shrimp and mussels. Generous portions. Relaxed atmosphere. Great service!
Food was soooo good!!! Best sea food I ever had!!!
A little smaller than I expected but it was nice
Food is excellent and reasonably priced. Service is friendly. Restaurant is a little dumpy looking. Seating is very close; if you sit at bar you will be constantly bumped.
Fresh seafood and a neighborhood gem with fair prices and gracious host. Outstanding wine and beer list.
Seafood, seafood, seafood. Get there for the happy hour specials!
Food was fresh and delicious!
We were seated promptly upon arrival. The waiter was very attentive. The food was amazing from the appetizer to the salad to the entrees. Dessert was the "Best" cannoli we have ever eaten. Before we left the owner came over to introduce herself and make sure that everything was fine.
This dining experience was A++
We enjoyed the food and atmosphere immensely! What a staple in the community! Don't turn the building into condos for yuppies!
I am never disappointed when going to Anastasi. The only issues is it seems that they overbooked and even with reservations you can wait 30 plus mins for a table. But the food is worth the wait.
My brother had the oyster stew and said it was good. Besides that, everything was disappointing. The tower of shellfish appetizer was just off. Nothing good about it. My pan fried scallops main course were dry and chewy. We had high hopes for this restaurant and that continued after walking through the door, but it just didn’t live up.
The place could use a little maintenance on the ceiling tiles...replacements; air vents need a good cleaning. Place is small, couldn't help but notice.
Always good. Always fresh. Always fun. Be ready to interact "a little" with other patrons. It is a bit of a party like atmosphere. Sitting at the bar is fun if you can get a seat (room for 6 - 7 comfortably). Best Moscow mule in the city. Wait staff is usually family members or long time employees so they want to make sure you have a great experience. I had trout sauteed in butter and lemon. Crispy skin, light flaky meat. What really impressed me, the vegetables were good too. They were not an afterthought. They weren't garnish. They were meant to be enjoyed!
THE BEST RESTAURANT! Delicious food amazing staff. We dine here often because it is wonderful!
Delicious fresh seafood, great variety, perfectly prepared.
Wonderful birthday dinner with family. My daughter picked it because she wanted blue crabs and was thrilled with her dinner. My husband raved about the risotto and my son enjoyed his trout. The waiter was helpful and attentive. All in all a lovely dinner in the Italian Market. We will be back soon!
Anastasi offers fresh seasfood in a relaxed, casual atmosphere in the heart of the Italian Market. Around the room are displayed fish and seafood items for retail purchase, an enticing array. Along one side is a bar, with a small but nice winelist, draft and bottled beer and mixed drinks. Everyone was happy with the food, ranging from scallops to mixed seafood platter, to lobster, to fish and chips. The vegan with us was satisfied with a side salad, beets, broccoli rabe (and a shot of tequila). I got fish and chips. The fish was inside a perfect crunchy batter, that stayed crunchy to the last bite. This is rare in my experience. The chips, otherwise known as french fries, were also crispy and delicious. I would definitely come back when I want excellent seafood, either to dine in, or buy ingredients for home cooking.
Wonderful fish and very pleasant service! This is a special little spot all in its own right! We had a very good time!
Eric is very personable which really contributed to a great experience
Best Calamari in the city. Food was fresh and presented well. Eric our server was great. Even the Manhattan was good.
Excellent food and service.
Delicious, fresh, home like feel. Would reccomend this place to anyone. A hidden gem
What a great place..
Super good service and really fresh and we'll prepared food..
Anastasi Seafood Restaurant offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (215) 462-0550.
Anastasi Seafood Restaurant is rated 4.5 stars by 302 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.